Hypocrisy on all sides with individual mandate

11

hours

ago

By NBC's Domenico Montanaro

People have accused President Obama of flip-flopping on issues like gay marriage (his stance is "evolving") and keeping the prison at Guantanamo Bay open (he tried, but ran into opposition in Congress). But the really fundamental flop for him is on the individual mandate, the subject of tomorrow's oral arguments before the Supreme Court.
American Crossroads is out with a video highlighting that today, showing Barack Obama in his own words arguing with himself before the Supreme Court.
When Obama was running for president, he spent months campaigning against Hillary Clinton with the biggest distinction between them (besides Iraq) being the mandate. Clinton's team argued fiercely that the only way to cover everyone and control costs was with the mandate. Obama, however, likely realizing the general-election politics of requiring people to buy health insurance, disagreed and said it was possible to cover everyone without it.
Crossroads' tag line in the video is "Obama was right on the individual mandate...before he was wrong."
Of course, then by that standard, Mitt Romney is still wrong, because he defends the mandate for Massachusetts (though he now argues it is OK for states to make those decisions at a local level and not federally). And wrong, too, would be the Heritage Foundation, which first floated the idea of a mandate and became the conservative alternative to the plan then-First Lady Hillary Clinton put forward in the early 1990s.

Drama in the air at health care arguments

Sen. Ron Johnson describes mood in Supreme Court

Read More ›

1. Palin on 'ObamaCare's' Supreme showdown
   
   Could Republicans be the biggest losers if the High Court upholds 'Obamacare'?
2. Inside the historical challenge to 'ObamaCare'
   
   After a first day of technicalities, the Supreme Court will focus on the key issue: whether it's constitutional to require Americans to buy health insurance
3. Santorum goes after Romney on health care
   
   How will attacks impact GOP race?
4. First day of Supreme Court health care arguments
   
   Will highest court be able to rule on individual mandate?
5. Brit Hume's Commentary: Obamacare individual mandate
   
   Weighing constitutionality of law
6. Obamacare reaches Supreme Court
   
   Panel discusses Obama's health mandate
7. Can Romney escape health care issue?
   
   Santorum expands attacks on GOP opponent

1. Supreme 'ObamaCare' showdown: The People Speak
   
   Supreme Court arguments on national health care reform law bring out protesters from both sides of the issue
2. Is health care's individual mandate constitutional?
   
   Peter Johnson, Jr. on Obamacare's Supreme Court test
3. High court takes up health care
   
   Florida is lead plaintiff in case
4. ObamaCare is already a success
   Just in time for the two-year anniversary of the passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, the Supreme Court is hearing oral arguments on the law’s ...
5. What happens if ObamaCare's individual mandate is thrown out?
   The Supreme Court is set to decide whether the Affordable Care Act requirement that all Americans purchase health insurance is an unconstitutional intrusion on perso...
6. Supreme Court hearing on individual mandate tees up blockbuster decision
   The Supreme Court hearing Tuesday on the controversial federal health care law will be one for the history books. After presumably clearing away a technicality which...
7. On a mission to put 'ObamaCare' on life support
   
   Rep. Michele Bachmann on Monday's Supreme Court arguments, Congress' role in attempting stifling the president's health care reform law