Koch-funded charity passes money to free-market think tanks in states
By Paul Abowd
The Center for Public Integrity
In 2009, a network of online media outlets began popping up in state capitals across the nation, each covering the news from a clearly conservative point of view. What wasn’t so clear was how they were funded.
“The source is 100 percent anonymous,” said Michael Moroney, a spokesman for the Franklin Center for Government and Public Integrity, the think tank that created the outlets.
In fact, 95 percent of Franklin’s revenue
in 2011 came from a charity called Donors Trust, according to Internal Revenue Service records.
Conservative foundations and individuals use Donors Trust to pass money to a vast network of think tanks and media outlets that push free-market ideology in the states — $86 million in 2011 alone. The arrangement obscures the identity of the donors wishing to keep their charitable giving private, especially “gifts funding sensitive or controversial issues,” according to the group’s website.
The $6.3 million donation to the Franklin Center was the second-largest gift made in 2011 by the group, a tax-exempt “public charity” that takes tax-deductible donations from donors “dedicated to the ideals of limited government, personal responsibility, and free enterprise,” according to its website.
Donors Trust includes 193 contributors, the majority of whom are individuals. “A lot of donors are flying totally under the radar,” says president and CEO Whitney Ball.
Donor-advised fund
Since its founding in 1999,
Donors Trust and its affiliated organization,
Donors Capital Fund, have distributed nearly $400 million, becoming major vehicles for tax-exempt giving from wealthy conservatives such as billionaire industrialist Charles Koch.
Koch is among an exclusive pool of donors who have used Donors Trust as a “pass-through,” says Marcus Owens, the former director of the IRS Exempt Organizations Division, now in private legal practice. “It obscures the source of the money. It becomes a grant from Donors Trust, not a grant from the Koch brothers.”
Ball helped found Donors Trust in 1999 as a “donor-advised” fund. Donors can open an account and protect their identity from the public and even the recipient of their grants.
In addition, donor-advised funds offer contributors an extra level of control over where their money ends up, which seeks to remedy what Ball sees as the tendency for foundation money to “drift left.”
This was a chief concern of Daniel Searle, the late philanthropist and pharmaceutical executive who was one of Donors Trust’s early board members.
In 1998, with help from Donors Trust co-founder and board chairman
Kim Dennis, Searle established an endowment called the
Searle Freedom Trust, now worth $114 million, which has in turn given generously to Donors Trust.
‘Great guys’
The Searle Freedom Trust is one of dozens of conservative foundations that have given tens of millions of dollars to Donors Trust from 2001 to 2011. Among the group’s donors is the Knowledge and Progress Fund, a Wichita, Kan.-based foundation run by Charles Koch.
The foundation gave almost $8 million to Donors Trust between 2005 and 2011.
Where those funds ended up is a mystery, though some of the recipients, including the Mercatus Center and the Institute for Humane Studies based at George Mason University in Virginia, have also received major funding from foundations set up by Charles Koch and brother David.
Brendan McDermid / Reuters file
David Koch is shown in New York on Dec. 10. In 2010, nearly half of the revenue for David Koch's Americans for Prosperity Foundation came from Donors Trust, in the form of $7.6 million in grants.
Nearly half of the revenue for David Koch’s Americans for Prosperity Foundation came from Donors Trust in 2010, in the form of $7.6 million in grants.
Representatives for the Koch foundations did not return calls for comment.
Before Donors Trust, Ball was the director of development for the libertarian Cato Institute, which Charles Koch was instrumental in founding.
“We think they’re great guys,” she says of the Kochs, “but if they weren’t around, we’d still be successful.”
At a private Koch fundraising meeting in the summer of 2010, Donors Trust hosted cocktails and dessert for what Ball called a “target-rich environment” of wealthy donors.
Several wealthy conservatives who have attended Koch fundraising parties have Donors Trust accounts, including Amway co-founder and longtime booster of conservative causes Richard DeVos; hedge fund billionaire Paul Singer; and Philip Anschutz, owner of the conservative Examiner newspapers.
Dozens of other major conservative philanthropies have Donors Trust accounts, including the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, the John M. Olin Foundation and the Coors family’s Castle Rock Foundation, according to IRS records.
Money in the statesFor a decade, Donors Trust has bolstered the efforts of D.C.-based conservative think tanks, including Cato, the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute — whose president, Arthur C. Brooks, is on the Donors Trust board.
In recent years, it has taken a strong interest in the states, funding state-level think tanks and three national umbrella organizations that coordinate their activities: the American Legislative Exchange Council, the State Policy Network (SPN), and the Franklin Center.
“Gridlock” at the federal level of government means donors see “a better opportunity to make a difference in the states,” says Ball, who sits on the board of the State Policy Network.
SPN has become a major recipient of Donors Trust money — receiving $10 million in the past five years.
In 2011, the nearly $2 million in grants from Donors Trust made up about 40 percent of SPN’s revenue for the year, according to tax records obtained by the Center.
In the past five years, Donors Trust money has gone to at least 51 state-level think tanks affiliated with SPN, located in nearly every state. Last year, SPN used the money to incubate think tanks in Arkansas, Rhode Island and Florida, where it hosted its yearly
gathering in November.
One workshop touted privatization of state and local government services. Another featured anti-tax crusader Grover Norquist. A third focused on how “property rights and markets provide the best way to protect the environment.”
SPN also sponsors the American Legislative Exchange Council, another D.C.-based clearinghouse for state-level policymaking that gets support directly from Donors Trust.
A laboratory for corporate-friendly laws in the states, ALEC hosts closed-door meetings where corporate lobbyists and state legislators meet to hammer out free-market legislation.
Ten state-level think tanks got a total of $200,000 from Donors Trust to attend ALEC meetings in 2011 including the Michigan-based Mackinac Center and the Arizona-based Goldwater Institute, which introduced a raft of anti-union model bills at ALEC’s spring 2012
conference.
The Mackinac Center has gotten $2.4 million from Donors Trust since 2008, according to the Bridge Project, a liberal think tank.
One Donors Trust grant to Mackinac Center was earmarked for “statehouse reporting” efforts. Mackinac put the money toward a media machine of blogs and research studies making the case for the state’s new “right-to-work” law.
The Mackinac Center works closely with other Donors Trust recipients, including the Franklin Center, which counts Mackinac’s “media” outlets in Michigan as affiliates.
The Franklin Center, Mackinac and another major recipient of Donors Trust cash, Americans for Prosperity, co-hosted a day-long
training for “citizen watchdogs” featuring speakers on “school choice” and “union reform” from the Mackinac Center and Republican state Rep. Tom McMillin, who is also an ALEC member.
Against the tideThe California-based Tides Foundation, which Ball calls the “ideological opposite” of Donors Trust, also operates
donor-advised funds. The Center has received funding from the Tides Foundation in the past.
In 2011, Tides raised $91 million and made $96 million in grants, including $26 million to overseas recipients.
Tides gives grants to the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation and liberal groups like the Center for American Progress and the National Resources Defense Council.
Since 2010, the foundation has received $10 million from George Soros’ Foundation to Promote an Open Society, which has assets of $2.2 billion (Tides has assets of $142 million, and the Donors Trust funds have combined assets of $62 million.)
Soros’ Open Society Foundations is a donor to the Center for Public Integrity.
Soros’ foundation listed the specific recipient of its grants to Tides, including its largest gift, a $1 million grant for school nutrition programs. The largest foundations contributing to Donors Trust do not identify the ultimate recipient of their funds, records show.
Donor-advised funds offer private foundations created by wealthy individuals
several tax advantages and a degree of anonymity, but there are also advantages for recipients.
The Franklin Center, for example, maintains a tax-exemption as a “publicly supported” entity.
If the organization were perennially accepting 96 percent of its funding from a handful of wealthy donors “it would not count as public support” and could jeopardize its tax status, Owens said.
Though its donors remain anonymous, the Franklin Center touts “transparency, accountability, and fiscal responsibility as its watchwords.”
One of Franklin’s state-based blogs, New Jersey Watchdog, also received $50,000 from AFP in 2011, according to IRS records.
In 2011 alone, Donors Trust helped the Franklin Center expand by funding state-based reporting projects in Illinois, Iowa, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, Ohio and Virginia.
Recurring themes on the Franklin Center blogs include “
union bosses,”
“Marxian” senators and the perils of
renewable energy.
Franklin has noted that its journalists’ work had landed on major networks from Fox to MSNBC. The details of several stories offered by the Franklin-funded outlets have been called into question, however.
One report from a New Mexico affiliate housed at a free-market think tank also funded by Donors Trust garnered national attention when it reported that millions of dollars in federal stimulus money had been allocated to non-existent congressional districts.
The government database on stimulus spending had indeed listed non-existent districts as receiving funds, but
The Associated Press reported that the problem was due to data errors and that “’phantom congressional districts’ are being used as a phantom issue to suggest that stimulus money has been misspent.”
When asked to comment on the criticism, Franklin Center spokesman Moroney said: “Franklin Center adheres to the highest degree of journalistic integrity and we stand by our Watchdog.org reporting 100 percent. In this case, the Associated Press had it wrong.”
The carafe gaffe gif http://assets.nationaljournal.com/img/2013SOTU/SOTUNC1050.gif
Jesus walked on water. Rubio drank it #saviors (ok, done)
so that's why Beyonce didn't sing live
#GOPResponse #SOTU #gop #tcot http://pic.twitter.com/3hxtgdbP
How Rubio plays it off tomorrow: "I wish it was something stronger." #freeadvice
Rep. Eliot Engel is patiently waiting for a second chance at a presidential handshake.
Obama signs something for Elliot Engel but no smiles. What's up there?
Obama: "Together, we have cleared away the rubble of crisis & can say with renewed confidence that the state of our union is stronger" #SOTU
Boehner has this look of "Rah-rah you won the election, take your hour and get out the door." #SOTU
Obama quoting JFK: "'It is my task,' he said, 'to report the State of the Union – to improve it is the task of us all.'" #nbcpolitics
POTUS says deficit reduction has come "mostly" through spending cuts,signaling he will seek more new revenues. #NBC Politics
Paul Ryan clapping and nodding -- seemed to almost stand -- at Obama's line about keeping promises already made. #NBCpolitics #SOTU
Leaders of BOTH parties have a history of big #deficit reduction promises. #SOTU Here's Pres. Clinton in 2000: http://pic.twitter.com/cndLowHF
RT @chucktodd: "It's not a bigger government we need but a smarter government" is one line WH hopes gets remembered. #nbcpolitics
.@BarackObama #SOTU on climate change: urge Congress pursue bipartisan market-based solution like one McCain & Lieberman worked on together
A Yale poll found that 93% of Democrats think “Global warming should be a priority for the President and Congress” #sotu
WH does not yet have a price tag associated with the POTUS' federal-state universal preK program. They say they'll have by budget time
President Obama: "Over the next year, another 34,000 American troops will come home from Afghanistan" #SOTU http://pic.twitter.com/ak1wWQkF
Very strong bipartisan applause on Afghanistan
POTUS: "We will ensure equal treatment for all service members, and equal benefits for their families – gay and straight." #SOTU
Obama: "Women have proven under fire that they are ready for combat."
President Obama: "We will keep faith with our veterans" #stateoftheunion #JoiningForces http://pic.twitter.com/0uKOu48i
Obama: "This is not the first time this country has debated how to reduce gun violence. But this time is different." http://pic.twitter.com/cyHmafLw
POTUS uses "weapons of war" instead of "assault weapons." Says background checks, weapon ban, magazine limits deserve "a vote in congress."
Obama getting to section about Hadiya Pendleton now #SOTU
.@gabbygiffords stood quietly with family when president talked about gun related reforms # sotu
Boehner stands when Obama invokes gun violence victims. One of the few times he's stood tonight. #SOTU
2 powerful consecutive moments: first chants of "they deserve a vote," then 102-year-old Desiline strains herself to applaud voting reform
John Boehner should stand to salute the 102-yr old voter. Mistake to stay seated.
America is exceptional, we have the God-given right to go as far as talent & hard work will take you. #GOPResponse
Rubio: "I hope the president will abandon his obsession with raising taxes."
Really interesting: Rubio's dropped the "fled from Castro" language for "immigrated for better life" language. The result of good reporting.
The most passionate the pres was all night was taking people rights away. #SOTU Just like his passion on taking rights away in HHS regs
This GIF of Obama's Exploding Fist Bump Is the State of the Union HighlightThis is President Obama doing an exploding fist bump with someone after his arrival and before his speech. (Anyone know who the recipient...
I forsee a hallowed tradition developing where every SOTU features a washed up 70s rock star in the audience.
The man who saved President Obama's healthcare law walks into #Sotu http://pic.twitter.com/6UdtzcHU
'Designated Survivor' Most Powerful Man (or Woman) for Three HoursBy: Meena Ganesan President Obama and Vice President Biden posing with the full Cabinet in the Grand Foyer of the White House, July 26, 2...
Watching #SOTU tonight? Retweet and join the conversation using #NBCPolitics http://pic.twitter.com/Mdk6m4ns
President Obama's getting ready: RT if you're excited to hear his #SOTU speech tonight. http://pic.twitter.com/CF6dRHg9
Rubio to frame bitter tax, spending fights in humanizing terms nbcnews.to/VT9857
Obama is expected to say tonight: "Nothing I'm proposing tonight should increase our deficit by a single dime." #sotUGottaBKiddingMe
Some amazing Americans will be next to me for Barack’s State of the Union Address. Read their incredible stories: wh.gov/d2JS –mo
The First Lady's Box at the 2013 State of the Union | The White HouseFind out who was invited to join First Lady Michelle Obama at the 2013 State of the Union.
From rock stars, to CEOs and gun victims - a diverse guest list for State of the UnionPublished 3:25 p.m. ET -- What do rocker Ted Nugent, Apple CEO Tim Cook, singer Tony Bennett, Mohawk-coiffed NASA staffer Bobak Ferdowski...
NASA's Mohawk Guy Is Headed To The State Of The UnionWASHINGTON - It's been quite a six months for Bobak Ferdowsi, the NASA flight director on the Mars Science Laboratory Curiosity mission, ...
Bo excited for #sotu just like me! Headed to the Capitol!!!! http://pic.twitter.com/yJT4QfrR
Hadiya's mom: State of the Union will be 'bittersweet'It was an invitation she wishes she had no reason to accept. The mother of Chicago gun-violence victim Hadiya Pendleton will be in the au...
Anonymous threatens to take down State of the Union livestreamAccording to a threat posted on Anonymous information website Anon Relations.net, the loosely banded hacker collective will attempt to di...
Ad-libbed, asleep, and going for gold: Memorable States of the UnionFormulaic and often little more than a point-by-point policy primer, the State of the Union - which is not technically required to be a s...
A history of gun proposals in State of the Union speeches nyti.ms/X0CsJ3
Want a better way to watch the State of the Union? Watch live w/ charts, graphs & data at http://wh.gov/sotu #SOTU http://pic.twitter.com/O1YPyEQc
