Pages

Sunday, February 6, 2011

At many big banks, no more free checking

Saying new banking rules will cost them billions of dollars a year, the big banks plan to bring back maintenance fees on basic checking accounts. The poorest will be hit the hardest.

By E. Scott Reckard, Los Angeles Times
February 4, 2011

Free checking, RIP. It was nice while it lasted.

Reversing a trend that began in the mid-1990s, big banks are imposing new fees on their least-profitable customers — those who want just a bare-bones checking account.

Those who can't maintain fat balances, or who don't use other services that would make them more lucrative to a bank, probably will need to cough up about $100 a year if they want to stay put.

Blame the financial crisis. As part of the reforms adopted after the banking system's near-meltdown in 2008, the federal government has made it more difficult for banks to impose credit-card late fees, debit-card overdraft penalties and other charges.

Saying the new rules will cost them billions of dollars a year, the big banks plan to bring back maintenance fees on basic checking accounts.

The country's four giant banks — Bank of America, Wells Fargo, JPMorgan Chase and Citibank — are already phasing in the charges, and large regional banks are expected to follow suit.

The upshot: If you're not prepared to stockpile cash in a checking account, be prepared to pay a monthly fee or to take your money to a smaller bank.

"Wealthy consumers will be able to avoid these charges by maintaining high balances," said Jeremy T. Rosenblum, a Philadelphia lawyer and consumer finance specialist. "But for the poor and moderate-income people whose balances are lower, it's going to be much harder to avoid these fees."

Consumer advocates are largely on board, contending that modest checking fees are preferable to onerous and deceptive overdraft charges.

"A reasonable, upfront monthly fee is much better than abusive back-end overdraft fees or other junk fees that target those who can least afford them," said Lauren Saunders of the National Consumer Law Center.

Some customers are looking for cheaper alternatives.

Valerie Milan of Laguna Beach said Chase plans to start charging her $10 a month next week if she doesn't keep at least $1,500 in her checking account or make a deposit of $500 or more each month.

"I don't make enough to have that much in the bank all the time," Milan, 34, said as she left a Chase branch in Dana Point.

Milan will probably be able to get a better deal from smaller banks still offering free checking — but she'll have to give up access to a vast ATM network and the variety of services offered by bigger competitors.

Industry experts trace the widespread availability of free checking to 1994, when Washington Mutual, a fast-growing Seattle savings and loan angling for middle- and lower-income customers, introduced unconditionally free checking.

It wasn't until 2003, in part because the industry enjoyed a favorable configuration of interest rates, that big banks fully followed WaMu's example and embraced no-cost checking. Typically the only condition was a regular direct deposit.

Of course, free checking was never quite free — at least for the banks. Large institutions typically spend $300 to $350 a year to provide a checking account, including paying for branches, automated-teller machines, online account access and customer service by phone, according to industry consultant Michael Moebs of Lake Bluff, Ill.

Avoiding monthly charges now will take some work.

Consumers who "just sit on the sidelines and do nothing — and there are people who will do that — they're going to get stung badly by fees," Moebs said.

Bank of America, for example, plans to phase in checking fees over two years, first for new customers and then for the 57 million households it already does business with. It's testing reactions in three states to fees of $9 to $25 a month for consumers without big-enough balances or deposits.

BofA says customers can still steer clear of monthly fees by doing all their banking online or at ATMs. But the penalty for straying is stiff: Conduct just one routine transaction with a human teller and you'll get dinged $9 that month.

At Citibank, depositors who make fewer than five debit-card transactions a month already pay $8 a month for checking. Wells Fargo is charging $5 a month for new checking accounts, and its chief executive warned last month of more "costs that will be passed along to customers."

Chase is imposing fees next week on customers whose deposits and balances aren't big enough — $10 a month on the West Coast, WaMu's former stronghold, and $12 elsewhere. Chase spokesman Gary Kishner compared the cost to a couple of trips to Starbucks. He also said 93% of Social Security recipients could avoid the charge by having their monthly benefit electronically deposited.

Consumer advocates advise studying the fine print on your bank statement and other materials, seeing whether free checking bundled with other services suits your needs and calling your bank to object if you see a new charge you dislike.

"It's a pain, but if you do your homework you can avoid the fees," said Consumers Union policy analyst Suzanne Martindale. "And complain. A lot of these are pilot programs, where the banks are testing what their customers will tolerate."

Moebs predicts that the country's 29 largest consumer banks will drop free checking, causing an exodus of customers. By the end of next year, those banks will have only 33% of all checking accounts, down from 45% last year, he projects.

Smaller institutions, such as credit unions, community banks or small regional banks, can still offer free checking because they have lower expenses.

For example, Orange Community Bank, with branches in Orange, Anaheim and Huntington Beach, will open one free checking account per household after an initial $100 deposit but with no minimum balance required after that. Customers receive cash-machine cards immediately but must wait six months for a debit card usable for purchases.

Chatsworth-based Premier America Federal Credit Union, with six locations including Simi Valley, Valencia and Santa Monica, offers free checking and a free debit card to members who initially deposit at least $100 and open a savings account with a $5 deposit.

But it can be hard to give up the convenience of the many branches and ATMs offered by the big guys.

Before Jeff DeCoursey of Aliso Viejo lost his job as a waiter when restaurant chain Claim Jumper shut its Laguna Hills location Jan. 1, it would have been hard for him to deposit $500 at a time to avoid checking fees at Chase. Now it's impossible, he said.

"So until I'm back on my feet, I guess I'll pay the $10 a month," he said. "But I'm going to go to a credit union when I can."

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Lawmakers Rally Lobbyists in 'Call To Arms' For Upcoming Spending Fight


Senate Appropriations Subcommittee Urged Lobbyists to Push for Continued Funding

By JONATHAN KARL & MATTHEW JAFFE

Feb. 4, 2011

As Congress prepares to make deep spending cuts, an army of lobbyists is gearing up to fight back.
In an e-mail obtained by ABC News, a top staffer for the key Senate Appropriations subcommittee called for a meeting of lobbyists and interest groups that would be affected by expected cuts to the Labor and Heath and Human Services budget. The Jan. 24 meeting was attended by approximately 400 people, sources told ABC, and served as a "call to arms" for those determined to fight Republican budget cuts.
"One thing everyone should be able to agree on now is that a rising tide lifts all boats, and that a higher [Labor, Health & Human Services] allocation improves the chances for every stakeholder group to receive more funding," the committee staffer for Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, wrote in an e-mail inviting people to the meeting.
The meeting is in contrast to the rampant calls all over Capitol Hill to cut federal spending. For instance, a recent proposal from Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., called for an 83 percent cut in funding for the Department of Education.
If education is subjected to far greater cuts than defense, for example, then groups in that sector have cause for concern. Cue the lobbying effort.
"Everyone who was there was desperately concerned and very appreciative of being in a room seeing so many people like them who are also concerned," said a source who attended the meeting.
"We obviously have to cut the budget deficit and address the debt problem, but are we going to do that on the backs of the poor, the unemployed, those without child care, et cetera? That's the kind of thing that could halt the economic recovery in its tracks."
Another source familiar with the meeting said Democrats used the meeting as "an attack on House Republicans."
"They said these evil House Republicans are here and they're going to kill all these programs that support little kids, senior citizens, and health care," the source said. "They're trying to instill the fear of God that Republicans are basically going to blow up all these programs, kill these programs, defund them."
"It seemed to me like they are trying to build momentum to push the Republicans back on their promises on funding levels and I think to their credit they were reaching out to a vast number of organizations to build a coalition of people who are willing to take action against whatever may come out of the House."
The funding fight looks set to take center stage in the coming weeks. President Obama is planning to submit his budget proposal for fiscal year 2012 on Feb. 14.

The States Can't Afford ObamaCare


Behind this week's ruling by U.S. District Court Judge Roger Vinson overturning ObamaCare on constitutional grounds, there is a deeper economic reality. The states can't afford it. That's a primary reason why 26 states joined in the Florida lawsuit to nullify the federal law. It also would be a good reason for the Supreme Court to uphold Judge Vinson's ruling.
For decades, the federal government has presumed increasingly to make policy in health, education, welfare, business regulation, law enforcement and other areas beyond the powers enumerated in the Constitution. Up until recently, the courts have largely viewed this intrusion benignly, partly because the states have acquiesced, bargaining their sovereignty away in return for federal aid.
This once-happy marriage is on the rocks. While designing the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, the Pelosi-Reid-Obama troika tried desperately to present a façade of federal fiscal prudence where none actually existed—so they off-loaded massive costs on the states. By opening Medicaid to applicants 33% above the poverty line in 2014, ObamaCare could expand Medicaid enrollment by as much as 25%, according to the plaintiffs in the Florida suit. Medicaid, also rife with fraud in part because of its hybrid federal-state management, is already one of the biggest items in state budgets.
Thanks to the recession and their own spending excesses, nearly all states are suffering budget shortfalls, some to the point where there is no clear idea where the money will come from to meet pension and bond obligations, let alone operating expenses. The prospect of adding a further huge burden down the line, even with Washington kicking in over half the cost, is appalling.
The 26 states party to the Florida suit were saying, in essence: enough! Washington can borrow from the Chinese or call on the Federal Reserve to buy its bonds. But states' only recourse in a budgetary bind is further painful cuts in services.
Chad Crowe
This resistance to a further broadening of the partnership with Washington has heavy grass-roots support. The tea party uprising was a reaction to state as well as federal spending excesses. Voters in November punished the Democratic Congress but even more emphatically banished Democrats from state houses. Republicans now have the most state legislature seats since 1928. They netted five governorships, and the 29 they now hold could grow to 33 or even 36 in 2011 and 2012 if present voting trends continue.
Republican governors and state legislators are increasingly reasserting their claims to state sovereignty. Texas, for example, is disputing the Environmental Protection Agency's right to deny emission permits to Texas industries. Arizona and other states are at war with Washington over immigration policy.
States bucking Washington got their first real satisfaction in December. That's when U.S. District Court Judge Henry Hudson ruled in a suit brought by Virginia that the Constitution's Commerce Clause does not grant the federal government the power to compel individuals to buy health insurance. The 26 states who were plaintiffs in the Florida case raised this issue, and Judge Vinson ruled in their favor.
But these states went further. They argued that it also is unconstitutional for the federal government to coerce the states into spending money on federally designed projects, or, in other words, to essentially assume control over state budgets. ObamaCare does that, the states argued, with its requirement that the states foot a large share of the bill for the Medicaid expansion.
Judge Vinson didn't buy that argument. Instead he sided with the government lawyers, who argued in response that since states are free to withdraw from Medicaid if they so choose, nobody is forcing them to do anything.
Technically, that's true. Yet notwithstanding Judge Vinson's ruling, there is considerable practical merit in the states' position. For one thing, federal taxes levied on the incomes of citizens in states that withdrew would simply go to support Medicaid elsewhere. These citizens would not only get nothing in return for their taxes—they would also be stuck with the cost of alternative ways to provide health care for the poor.
The plaintiffs who brought the suit heard by Judge Vinson explained: "In Fiscal Year 2010-11, Florida will spend about $20 billion on Medicaid, toward which the federal government will contribute approximately $13 billion. For Florida now to opt out of Medicaid and itself provide the same $20 billion in benefits would consume more than half its tax revenues, not counting the significant costs associated with administering such a program."
States that have looked at the option of dropping out of Medicaid have usually stepped back in horror at what that would entail—nursing homes closing their doors, emergency rooms at hospitals overwhelmed, heart-wrenching stories in the newspapers about victims of the cutbacks. Even so, some are mulling alternatives. Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels, for example, recently asked other Republican governors if it might be feasible for states to band together to set up their own health-insurance pool for low-income residents.
The states are also aware that other programs in which they've partnered with the feds are not likely to remain as lush a source of federal funding as in the past. The Republicans who now control the House are looking for ways to cut federal spending in recognition of the fact that the federal government is also in dangerous straits with its projected $1.5 trillion 2011 deficit and soaring national debt. Federal aid to education, for example, will be a prime target for spending cuts.
The framers of ObamaCare seem to have been too clever by half in their attempt to shift costs to the states. However the courts may eventually rule, you can't get blood out of a turnip.
Mr. Melloan, a former columnist and deputy editor of the Journal editorial page, is author of "The Great Money Binge: Spending Our Way to Socialism" (Simon & Schuster, 2009).

The Tax Bowl



We won't predict the winner of this Sunday's Super Bowl between the Pittsburgh Steelers and Green Bay Packers. But we can report this much: The Steelers will get to keep a lot more of their season earnings, though both team's players would be a lot richer if they played all of their home games in Dallas.
Take the Packers' fleet-footed quarterback Aaron Rodgers. He made $8.6 million in 2009, according to USA Today's database of player salaries. Of that, we calculate he paid roughly $680,000 in state and $3.1 million in federal income and payroll taxes. Steeler quarterback Ben Roethlisberger didn't earn as much, but he got to keep a relatively larger chunk of his haul—$4.6 million of his $7.7 million salary. (This excludes taxes paid to states that tax players visiting on away games.)
Unlike Wisconsin, which has a graduated income tax that charges top earners 7.75% on earnings over $220,000, Pennsylvania has a 3% flat rate. Even football players can behold the merit of a flat tax. Of course, both players would keep a lot more of their earnings if like quarterback Tony Romo (salary: $625,000) they played for the Cowboys since Texas levies no state income tax. On the other hand, Packer and Steeler fans will pay if they travel to Texas for the game since Texas's beer tax is more than twice as high as their home state's.
It's also worth noting that Messrs. Rodgers and Roethlisberger will save roughly $750,000 combined this year (if their salaries stay the same) thanks to the extension of the Bush tax cuts. This ought to console Sunday's loser.

The 1099 Repudiation



A revealing debate over one of Washington's dumbest ideas.


Democrats now claim that the infamous 1099 business reporting mandate that the Senate repealed this week was an accident, as if they were as surprised as everyone else to learn that this destructive provision had crept by itself into law. The truth is that the 1099 rule emerged from the same core ideology as ObamaCare, and its overwhelming repudiation by Democrats may be an important inflection point in the health-care debate.
The 1099 rule is the first of the ballast to go over the side, and Democrats hope that such "improvements" will be enough to ride out the public storm. Then again, they also claimed that voters would learn to love ObamaCare once it had been stuffed through Congress, among many other misjudgments. The political history is revealing and instructive.
Associated Press
Sen. Kent Conrad, left, talks to Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus, right, during a Senate Finance Committee hearing on health care reform .
Less than a year ago, liberals couldn't see how anyone could possibly object to a rule requiring businesses to file 1099 tax forms with the Internal Revenue Service every time they spent more than $600 with a single vendor. Yes, this would result in a vast new paperwork and accounting burden for 30 million businesses and hit start-ups hardest, not to mention farms, charities and churches. But Democrats saw IRS surveillance of nearly all business-to-business transactions as merely an exercise in good government.
The point was to close the "tax gap," the largely mythological difference between the estimated taxes due under the business tax code and what the IRS actually collects. During the Bush years, Democrats and more than a few Republicans convinced themselves that businesses were cheating the government out of revenues through deliberate under-reporting and various tax shelters.
This notion prevailed at the Senate Finance Committee under both Democratic Chairman Max Baucus and Republican Chairman Chuck Grassley. Budget Chairman Kent Conrad was another evangelist. In its first budget, the Obama White House promised "robust" tax compliance enforcement "to narrow the annual tax gap of over $300 billion," in contrast to the lethargy of its predecessor.
The 1099 ObamaCare footnote thus received no scrutiny at first because it was so mundane. Everyone in Washington agreed that corporations were stealing billions of dollars every year that rightfully belonged to Congress to spend. (The issue only blew up when the IRS's National Taxpayer Advocate Nina Olson, followed by the GOP and the business lobby, made it a priority last summer.)
In the same Washington mindset, the 1099 mandate doesn't impose any more of a reporting burden than a European-style value-added tax. And it doesn't create any more of a drag on economic growth than the higher income tax rates that liberals believe don't matter either. As recently as September, Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius were still defending the 1099 rule as a good-faith "bipartisan provision to close the tax gap."
At that point, the White House was attempting to head off out-and-out 1099 repeal, and the duo did endorse arbitrary carve-outs for the smallest businesses—but these only made the provision more complex and onerous. House and Senate leaders tried similar gambits, while tying such half-measures to other business tax increases to scare off Republicans and give Democrats a way to tell voters they'd supported repeal.
The day after the election, President Obama deflected questions about the role health care played in the rout by offering the 1099 sacrificial lamb. He called it "counterproductive" and something "I think we can tweak and make improvements on the progress that we've made." He also mentioned it in the State of the Union, and total repeal sailed through the Senate on Wednesday, 81 to 17.
The mystery is the 17 Democrats who continue to think this is a good idea—even authors Messrs. Baucus and Conrad voted to heave it over the side. One of the 17 is Tom Carper of Delaware, which is home to thousands of small businesses. Does he think Christine O'Donnell is going to be his 2012 opponent? And what about New York's Kirsten Gillibrand?
The larger political question is whether voters will be satisfied by this or that "improvement" to ObamaCare. The White House is trying to outflank public opposition with a controlled burn, but wildfires often move in surprising and unmanageable directions.

Government Grants Airport Screeners Union Rights


WASHINGTON—The government will grant collective bargaining rights to the nation's 40,000 airport screeners, the head of the largest federal workers union said Friday.
John Gage, president of the American Federation of Government Employees, told the Associated Press he was informed of the decision at a meeting with John Pistole, head of the Transportation Security Administration.
TSA workers have tried for nearly a decade to win the same union protections as other federal employees, but Republican opponents have balked over worries that union demands could jeopardize national security or slow response times in a crisis.
Union officials call those arguments an insult to the hundreds of thousands of public safety officers that already have collective bargaining rights, including Border Patrol agents, firefighters and the Capitol police.
"Today marks the recognition of a fundamental human right for 40,000 patriotic federal employees who have been disenfranchised since the inception of the agency," Mr. Gage said.
Mr. Pistole had spent months studying the unionization issue since he was confirmed to the post in June. The move comes just days after Mr. Pistole said the agency would not hire private contractors to screen airline passengers, despite calls to do so from some Republican lawmakers and frustrated passengers.
When the agency was created in 2001, it was excluded from regulations that give other federal workers the right to union protections. The law gave the TSA administrator the authority to decide whether collective bargaining should be allowed, and under the administration of President George W. Bush it was always prohibited.
President Barack Obama had pledged to get the screeners collective bargaining rights during his campaign. But the effort was delayed after Obama's first two choices to run the agency dropped out during their confirmation processes.
Earlier this week, Sen. Roger Wicker (R., Miss.) offered an amendment to the FAA authorization bill that would bar the screeners from gaining union rights.
"Burdensome and costly union demands could limit the ability of those responsible for security at some of the most high-risk targets to do their job," Mr. Wicker said. "The FBI, the CIA and the Secret Service do not have collective bargaining rights for good reason."
The Federal Labor Relations Authority has already set union elections at the TSA to begin in early March. TSA employees will choose between AFGE and the National Treasury Employees Union for representation.
AFGE already has more than 12,000 dues-paying members among the screeners' ranks, but the union has not been allowed to bargain on behalf of its members.

Friday, February 4, 2011

Markey Report:

Big Five Oil Companies Approach $1 Trillion in Profits for the Decade, Yet Still Rely on

 100 Year-Old Subsidies to Sell $100 Oil

FEB 3, 2011
WASHINGTON (February 3, 2011) – Nearly $1 trillion – that’s the total profit earned by the top five multi-national oil companies over the first decade of the new millennium. $36.5 billion – that’s the total in tax subsidies the American public will provide to the oil industry over the next decade. $53 billion – that’s the value that oil companies could receive from not paying royalties on some Gulf of Mexico production over the next 25 years. And 1916 – the oldest tax subsidy the oil companies still utilize.
On the same day that the final major oil firm reported their fourth quarter and year-end earnings reports, Rep. Edward J. Markey (D-Mass.), the Ranking Democrat on the House Natural Resources Committee, released a report prepared by the Committee’s Democratic staff  that analyzed the  high profits earned by the largest companies in the oil industry, and their continuing dependency on tax subsidies despite those profits. Today’s report comes at a time when crude prices have risen above $100 per barrel in global markets reportedly due to concerns over political unrest in the Middle East.
“American consumers and small businesses are all told that they will have to tighten their belts, and do their share to bring down our deficit and grow our economy,” said Rep. Markey, who is the top Democrat on the Natural Resources Committee. “Yet even when their top five companies make nearly $1 trillion in profits over the last 10 years, they still defend with a straight face the billions in tax breaks and regulatory subsidies they stand to rake in over the next decade.
“Oil companies simply don’t need 100 year-old subsidies to sell $100 per barrel oil,” continued Markey.
The top five oil companies reported total year-end profits of $77 billion, despite a yearly loss for BP due to their oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. All told, the five companies -- BP, Chevron, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil and Shell -- made $952 billion in profits over the last 10 years, a decade when oil spikes and higher gas prices ate up more of every American’s paycheck. Over the last year, gas prices have outpaced the global economic recovery, now rising to an average of $3.10 per gallon nationally, 44 cents higher than during the same period last year.
The Markey staff report highlights that most oil industry tax subsidies have been on the books for decades, a relic of times when oil industry reserves were plentiful, but untapped. Two of the main tax breaks have been on the books since 1916 and 1926. The 1916 tax break was put on the books just three years after the 16th amendment established the power of the government to levy direct income taxes. Ending just these two subsidies would raise $18 billion over the next decade for the American people.
Since extracting oil even in the deep waters of the Gulf of Mexico can be done for as little as $10 per barrel, and oil is trading near $100 a barrel, revoking the tax subsidies enjoyed by the oil industry will not affect prices in a global market or prices at the pump for consumers, the report says.
The Congressional report notes that the windfalls for the top oil companies haven’t resulted in more research and development into alternatives or other consumer-protecting measures, but instead have been recycled back to shareholders and stock buybacks that benefit executives at the companies. Net profits directed towards dividends and stock repurchases for the big 5 oil companies have gone from 58 percent in 2005 to 89 percent in 2009.
“The oil companies are using tax subsidies put in place shortly after the turn of the 19th century to increase their profits as they move through the 21st century. These subsidies are not needed to ensure continued domestic production. They only get passed along to oil company shareholders and executives,” said Rep. Markey. “This outdated legacy of special tax breaks for oil companies is a drag on an American energy system that is rapidly reorienting to the 21st century. It is badly out of step with an American public that is looking to their government to develop serious solutions to rising fiscal deficits.”
President Obama called for revoking these tax subsidies in his state of the union address last week. And the report notes that the previous U.S. president, George W. Bush, said in 2005, “With oil at more than $50 a barrel, by the way, energy companies do not need taxpayers'-funded incentives to explore for oil and gas.”

GOP LEADERS GET AMNESIA OVER SHUTDOWN TALK....



February 3, 2011

 How can you tell the prospect of a government shutdown is getting increasingly serious? The most obvious hint is the Republican effort to avoid blame.
Today, several Senate Democrats, including the entire leadership team, held a press conference to urge their Republican colleagues to do the right thing, and not shut down the government. Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) took the lead, but he and the other Dems were joined by economist Mark Zandi, the chief economist for Moody's Analytics and a former advisor to John McCain's presidential campaign.
Their collective message was straightforward: be responsible, let cooler heads prevail, and don't shut down the government.
For their part, Republicans said a shut down can be avoided just so long as Dems give the GOP what it wants in the form of budget cuts.
"As Republicans focus on constructive ways for the two parties to work together on cutting spending and debt, Sen. Schumer seems strangely preoccupied with the notion of a government shutdown," a spokesperson for Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R) said. "It is our hope that he soon realizes the only person talking about a shutdown is Sen. Schumer."
It's hard to overstate how very wrong this is. Schumer isn't the one who brought this up. Indeed, it was Mitch McConnell who, just a few days ago, appeared on national television and refused to take a government shutdown off the table.
More importantly, to argue that Dems and Schumer are "the only" ones "talking about a shutdown" is just laughably dishonest. The list of Republican lawmakers who've been threatening, almostwelcoming, a government shutdown is fairly long, and keeps growing. It's not as if Democrats just came up with this fear out of thin air.
One GOP senator described the possibility of a shutdown as "absolutely necessary." Rep. Spencer Bachus (R-Ala.), chairman of the House Financial Services Committee, said Republicans should be prepared to be "brave" in the face of a shutdown. Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-Texas), insisted, "Listen, if it takes a shutdown of government to stop the runaway spending, we owe that to our children and our grandchildren."
Two months before the midterms, Rep. Lynn Westmoreland (R-Ga.) attended disgraced GOP lobbyist Ralph Reed's shindig, brought up shutting down the government, and was cheered. He replied, "That's what I wanted to hear! A good clap for that!"
And don't even get me started on the Republican activists and media figures who've spent a yearcelebrating the idea of a shutdown.
"The only person talking about a shutdown is Sen. Schumer"? I know some of these guys are paid to say nonsensical things like this, but people who take reality seriously should know better than to believe it.
—Steve Benen 4:45 PM Permalink | Trackbacks | Comments (20) 

Senate Democrats Urge GOP To Drop Threats Of Government Shutdown




SenateDemocrats | February 03, 2011 |
Senate Democrats today urged Republicans to join in a responsible approach to deficit reduction, and drop threats to force a government shutdown that would have disastrous consequences for the economy.

Democrats Say House-Proposed Spending Limits "Unworkable"




Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) with Sens. Dick Durbin (D-IL) and Charles Schumer (D-NY)

On Thursday, House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan (R-WI) introduced new limits on spending to fund the government through the end of September. The proposal itself falls a bit short of the GOP pledge to slash spending by $100 billion, on a prorated basis, this fiscal year. But already Senate Democrats are warning Republicans that they'd better willing to negotiate toward the center, or they'll risk a government shutdown.
Indeed, top Democrats addressed reporters about the GOP proposal Thursday afternoon. They criticized the GOP's approach, and its leadership, for not taking a government shutdown off the table. They even brought Sen. John McCain's (R-AZ) old economic adviser -- and Moody's chief economist -- Mark Zandi to the podium to buttress their case: a government shutdown would harm the economy, spending should not be cut dramatically right now, and the standoff should be resolved quickly.
"The chairman of the [House] Budget Committee today -- today -- sent us something more draconian than we originally anticipated," Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) said. He called Ryan's plan "unworkable."
"The Republicans control the House, the Democrats control the Senate and the White House -- that's two-thirds of the decision-making parts of the government here," said Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY). "So it can't be that 80 new Republicans who come in say "we should dictate everything that happens, otherwise we're gonna shut the government down, otherwise we're going to default. And I think the leadership -- the leadership of the House and Senate Republicans -- has been notably silent. Which I think encourages them to continue saying these things. Even saying these things rattles the debt market some."
In reality, the figures aren't actually as draconian as many Republicans wanted, or thought they would be. According to Ryan, "the spending limits will restore sanity to a broken budget process and return spending for domestic government agencies to pre-stimulus, pre-bailout levels." He claims they constitute a $74 billion cut -- but that's from the levels President Obama requested, not from the levels the government is operating under right now. Relative to current funding, Ryan's plan represents a slimmer $32 billion cut (about $40 billion if you count non-defense spending only) -- much less than conservatives on the Republican Study Committee want to see.
His numbers are binding, for now, on the House. So the question is whether Republicans are willing to meet the Democrats mid-way on overall spending -- and on particular spending cuts -- or whether they view their top-line, and their spending priorities, as non-negotiable.

Chairman Rogers Outlines Subcommittee Spending Cuts for Fiscal Year 2011

 
February 3rd, 2011 - -


 
WASHINGTON, D.C. – Following the release by the Budget Committee of the 
overall spending limit for the fiscal year 2011 Continuing Resolution, House 
Appropriations Chairman Hal Rogers today announced spending cut levels 
for each of the twelve Appropriations subcommittees. These cuts will save 
American taxpayers $74 billion compared to the President’s fiscal year 2011 
request and will help fulfill the commitment laid out in the Republican “Pledge 
to America” to cut spending to the pre-stimulus, pre-bailout funding levels of 2008.
 
The statement by Chairman Rogers follows:
 
“The Budget Committee today outlined a responsible and prudent level of 
funding for the federal government for the rest of fiscal year 2011. This top-line 
level will provide for significant spending reductions in the upcoming Continuing 
Resolution (CR), while allowing us to meet our commitment outlined in the 
Pledge to America to reduce non-security discretionary spending to the 
pre-stimulus and pre-bailout non-security funding levels of 2008.
 
“The Appropriations Committee will not only craft legislation that will meet 
the budget committee’s non-security discretionary total of $58 billion, but go even 
further to find savings in virtually every area of the federal government, reducing 
spending from the President's fiscal year 2011 request by a total of $74 billion.
 
“To accomplish this goal, I am instructing each of the twelve Appropriations 
subcommittees to produce specific, substantive and comprehensive spending 
cuts. We are going go line by line to weed out and eliminate unnecessary, wasteful, 
or excess spending – and produce legislation that will represent the largest series 
of spending reductions in the history of Congress. These cuts will not be easy, they 
will be broad and deep, they will affect every Congressional district, but they are 
necessary and long overdue.
 
“With this CR, we will respond to the millions of Americans who have called on this 
Congress to rein in spending and help our economy grow and our businesses 
create jobs. It is my intention –and that of my Committee – to craft a responsible, 
judicious CR that will significantly reduce government spending, begin to get our 
nation’s finances in order so that the economy can thrive, and provide essential 
resources for our national security.”
 
To view the spending limits and cuts announced by Chairman Rogers for 
each Appropriations Subcommittee for the CR, please click the following link:

http://republicans.appropriations.house.gov/_files/2311SubcommitteeAllocationsfor
FY11ContinuingResolution302bs.doc

Chairman Rogers Outlines Subcommittee Spending Cuts for Fiscal Year 2011

Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, February 3, 2011; 10:21 PM
House Republicans pledged Thursday to slice more than $32 billion from agency budgets over the next few months, firing the opening shot in a battle over government spending that is likely to dominate debate heading into the 2012 presidential campaign.

The figure, announced by House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan (R-Wis.), represents an unprecedented rollback that would force some domestic agencies to immediately slash spending by as much as 20 percent, independent budget analysts said.
Democrats immediately vowed to fight the proposal, calling it a short-sighted plan that would kill many critical government services and slow the burgeoning economic recovery. But a group of conservative Republicans is demanding even deeper cuts and vowing to offer a plan to slash $100 billion from agency budgets when House leaders bring a spending bill to the floor Feb. 14.
"Washington's spending spree is over," Ryan said in a statement. "As House Republicans pledged - and voted to affirm on the House floor last week - the spending limits will restore sanity to a broken budget process and return spending for domestic government agencies to pre-stimulus, pre-bailout levels."
The GOP proposal marks the first step in what promises to be an unusually complicated and contentious budget season, with much at stake for both parties. President Obama has vowed to fight for new investments aimed at combating a 9.4 percent unemployment rate, and Republicans are looking to make good on their campaign promise to rein in explosive growth in spending since he took office two years ago.
Republicans control the House; Democrats control the Senate. And with the government operating under a temporary funding resolution that expires March 4, both parties risk triggering a shutdown unless they can agree on a spending bill to pay for operations through the rest of the fiscal year, which ends in September.
New rules adopted by the House last month give Ryan unilateral authority to set spending limits in that bill. On Thursday, Ryan said he would cap total appropriations at $1.055 trillion - $74 billion less than the budget request Obama submitted to Congress last year and $32 billion less than the level at which lawmakers agreed to maintain spending.

Under the GOP plan, agencies related to national security - including the Pentagon and the departments of Homeland Security and Veterans Affairs - would get a slight bump in funding, receiving an extra $8 billion compared with current levels.
Domestic agencies, however, would absorb a deep hit, in excess of $40 billion, Ryan said. House Appropriations Committee Chairman Harold Rogers (R-Ky.), who is in charge of drafting the spending measure, said Thursday that the cuts would fall most heavily on transportation and housing programs; agriculture and the Food and Drug Administration; commerce, justice and science programs; and financial services. Labor, health and education programs would face much smaller reductions, as would state and foreign operations.
Aides said Rogers plans to unveil specific cuts late next week. "It is my intention - and that of my Committee - to craft a responsible, judicious [budget] that will significantly reduce government spending, begin to get our nation's finances in order so that the economy can thrive, and provide essential resources for our national security," he said in a statement.
But Senate Majority Leader Harry M. Reid (D-Nev.) quickly dismissed the GOP plan as "unworkable" and warned that lawmakers could be headed toward a government shutdown. "Cooler heads should prevail," Reid said.
As the parties spar over immediate spending cuts, they are also at work on a longer-term budget for the fiscal year that begins in October. Obama plans to unveil his budget request Feb. 14.
On Thursday, White House budget director Jacob J. Lew traveled to Capitol Hill to brief Senate Democrats on the president's proposal and to hear from lawmakers who want the president to support a multi-year blueprint for deficit-reduction, such as the one developed by a bipartisan fiscal commission Obama appointed last year.
"There are different points of view about how to do it," said Senate Budget Committee Chairman Kent Conrad (D-N.D.), one of the leading advocates of deficit reduction. But, he said, there's broad agreement among Democrats that "now is the time to start."
In his recent State of the Union address, Obama declined to endorse any of the fiscal commission's proposals, such as raising the retirement age for Social Security recipients or reducing cherished tax breaks such as the deduction for mortgage interest claimed by many homeowners. Such policy changes would be politically painful, and administration officials say the president is not inclined to endorse a specific deficit-reduction plan until Republicans have made their intentions clear.
But some Democrats fear the effort will languish without presidential leadership.
After the lunchtime meeting, Sen. Richard J. Durbin (Ill.), the No. 2 Democrat in the chamber, said Lew "heard some sentiments expressed in there that the White House needs to hear, and I think that he's going to have a tough challenge putting together a credible effort to reduce spending and reduce the deficit."
Staff writers Paul Kane and Felicia Sonmez contributed to this report.