Pages

Saturday, December 11, 2010

My last day with Elizabeth Edwards


By Josh Fryday, Special to CNN

December 9, 2010 12:02 p.m. EST
    Editor's note: Josh Fryday, a judge advocate general (JAG) in the U.S. Navy, stationed in Japan, worked on John Edwards' campaigns for the presidential nomination in Raleigh, North Carolina, in 2004 as the national youth and volunteer director and in 2008 as head of the campaign in Northern California. He also traveled with Elizabeth Edwards as an aide during the Iowa primary in 2008.
    Charlottesville, Virginia (CNN) -- A few months ago I had the opportunity to say goodbye to Elizabeth.
    Knowing her time was limited, Elizabeth Edwards visited Japan, where I am stationed, to show her children where she spent much of her childhood. She had endless fond memories. Her father and family had been stationed here with the Navy.
    It was unclear whether she would be healthy enough to make the trip, but right before she came she wrote me, apologizing for being disorganized, and asked if we would have time to see her. The last time I had seen her was at her home in North Carolina, right after the campaign ended. Much had changed between then and now.
    Elizabeth brought her family down from Tokyo to the base in Yokosuka, riding the public train, to meet us on the Navy base -- a base she remembered roller skating on as a child.
    We had lunch in the Officers Club, where we all ordered hamburgers, and began to catch up on life. She shared stories of what the Officers Club meant to her as a child and talked about how she always felt that she had an instant family around the Navy. Her children who came with her, Jack and Emma-Claire, were perfectly behaved, listening to their mother and talking about the Ninja stars they had just bought.

    She agreed to tour my office, where she graciously met the other judge advocates general, allowed pictures to be taken with her, and spoke to everyone about her experiences in the Navy.
    Very much in character, she also took the opportunity to share some specific policy ideas she had to help military families. On a family vacation, toward the end of her life, she was still looking for ways to engage with anyone she could on ideas to improve the lives of others.
    When John and the two kids went on a tour of one of the ships, she stayed behind. Walking up and down ladders and around a ship would have been too much for her weak body. So, I stayed with her in an air-conditioned car outside of the ship's gate, and for an hour and a half we talked.
    We talked about everything, including what had happened during the campaign and what she had been going through afterward. I expressed my disappointment in them, and told her how deeply hurt those of us who put our lives into the causes they championed were by what happened. They were our heroes, my heroes, and we were let down.
    She listened. She told me her story, what she knew, what ate her up inside as well, but she wasn't defensive. It was her life that had been turned upside down, but she let me have my closure.
    On this July day, she was as she only knew how to be, totally raw. She told me then that she didn't know how much more time she had. She feared most for her children, and what would happen to them when she was gone. How would they fare without a mother? She wanted to see Cate get married and watch the kids grow up.
    She was frustrated that her ability to work on the causes she still cared deeply about (there were many) was hampered by her husband's actions. She worried about the future. But she was humble, tested and gracious enough to know that life wasn't always about what you wanted.
    She told me that she had come to believe life isn't valued by how many years we have on Earth, but rather by how many good years we have. And she wanted to live her life out, whatever little she had left, to the fullest.
    After visiting on base she took the kids shopping in Yokohama, and then we all went to a Japanese baseball game that night. At the game we talked politics, ate ramen, laughed about memories of trekking through Iowa in December and January together, and rooted for players in Japanese. She gave me advice for my career and excitedly explained to me the business model for her furniture store in North Carolina.
    She stayed six innings before getting tired. We hugged, and she whispered to me that she was proud of me. Then, for the last time, we said goodbye. She was smiling.
    What made Elizabeth so special was how wonderfully human she was. She embodied in everything she did the entirety of the human experience. She was passionate, edgy, classy, beautiful, unvarnished and sometimes awkward.
    To many she was frustrating, tough, and stubborn. To many more she was inspirational, intellectual, loving, curious, optimistic and nurturing. She wasn't perfect. Yet there was so much beauty in her imperfection. And America fell in love with this beauty.
    Much in her life was tragic, but she never let herself be a tragedy. Despite the anger and sadness she felt from the challenges life brought her, she never stopped living life on her terms, and sharing her amazing life with us.
    Thank you for all the good years, Elizabeth. We are more grateful than you could ever know, and we miss you already.
    The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Josh Fryday.

    Westboro Baptist Church says it will picket Elizabeth Edwards' funeral



    By the CNN Wire Staff
    December 10, 2010 9:37 a.m. EST
    Click to play
    Kansas church targets Edwards funeral
    STORY HIGHLIGHTS
    • Members of the Westboro Baptist Church announce they will picket Elizabeth Edwards' funeral
    • The Kansas-based church is known for its radical stance against minorities
    • Edwards died Tuesday after a six-year battle with breast cancer
    Read more about the protest plans on CNN affiliate WGHP-TV.
    (CNN) -- Members of the Westboro Baptist Church, known for its radical stance against a myriad of issues including homosexuality and the war in Iraq, said Thursday it will picket Elizabeth Edwards' funeral in Raleigh, North Carolina.
    Edwards, the estranged wife of Democratic presidential candidate John Edwards, died Tuesday after battling breast cancer.
    According to the Church's press release, members of the Kansas-based congregation are planning to gather at 12:15 p.m. to rally against Edwards for issues relating to her personal life deemed offensive by the church.
    The Church -- monitored by anti-hate groups such as the Anti-Defamation league and the Southern Poverty Law Center -- is known for its extremist opposition against homosexuals, Jews and other groups.
    Westboro members often hold protests against the war in Iraq, many at funerals held for U.S. service members.
    Led by Pastor Fred Phelps and his family, the church has drawn controversy for targeting soldiers' funerals and asserting that the soldiers' deaths are God's punishment for America's "sin of homosexuality."
    Phelps is the leading patriarch at the Topeka, Kansas-based congregation which is made up mostly of his family.
    Launched in 1955, Phelps' church and his family have made a name for themselves by showing up at high-profile events, preaching their hate-filled brand of Christianity. They blame homosexuals for the destruction of America.
    He describes himself as an "old-time" gospel preacher who says, "You can't preach the Bible without preaching the hatred of God."
    In 2006, two days before a funeral held in Maryland for a Matt Snyder, a young lance corporal who served in Iraq, members of the Westboro church advertised its intent to appear and picket, prompting a heavy police presence including a SWAT team.
    The protest, led by Phelps, did not result in any confrontations or arrests.
    But the corporal's father, Albert Snyder, sued the church, claiming defamation and invasion of privacy, after reading an online "manifesto" the Westboro Baptist Church posted after that protest, where the Phelps family said Albert Snyder and his wife raised Matthew "for the devil" and that "God killed Matthew so His servants would have an opportunity to preach His words" at other venues across Maryland.
    "They are very sick individuals," said Snyder. "It comes down to dignity. No one should be buried with what the Phelps did. Everyone deserves to be buried with dignity."

    More than 1,200 at Edwards funeral; protest fizzles


    By the CNN Wire Staff

    December 11, 2010 3:42 p.m. EST
    Click to play






    STORY HIGHLIGHTS
    • NEW: Edwards eulogized by her daughter, friends
    • Edwards remembered for her love of Christmas, competitive nature
    • Protest by controversial church fizzles
    • Edwards will be buried next to her son Wade; four of his childhood friends are pallbearers
    Raleigh, North Carolina (CNN) -- More than 1,200 mourners, including hundreds who loved and admired Elizabeth Edwards from a distance, packed a Raleigh church Saturday to pay respects to the activist and estranged wife of a failed aspirant to the presidency.
    Elizabeth Edwards died Tuesday at the end of a six-year battle with cancer. She was 61.
    "She has been a light house to all of us. She's always been that source of light to us. Every lesson she has taught us has become part of our ethic," said Edwards' oldest daughter, Cate, in a eulogy to her mother.
    Among those lessons, Cate Edwards jokingly said, was "you'll always regret prints, you'll never regret solids."
    Cate Edwards read from a letter her mother wrote her children in anticipation of death. She said her mother was always more concerned about others than she was herself, and had even tried to cheer up friends and family about her cancer fight and impending death.
    Edwards: 'I want to reclaim my story'
    Elizabeth Edwards: In her own words
    Remembering Elizabeth Edwards
    Mourners included Massachusetts Sen. John Kerry, who in 2004 picked Edwards' husband, John, to be his vice presidential running mate in an unsuccessful bid for the White House. John and Elizabeth Edwards separated earlier this year after the former North Carolina senator admitted to fathering a child out of wedlock while the couple was married. John Edwards entered the church Saturday, holding hands with Cate, and the Edwards' two other children, Jack and Emma.
    Cate Edwards was preceded at the lectern by her mother's longtime friend Hargrave McElroy, who made the audience laugh with tales of Elizabeth's competitive nature, particularly with games. She also noted Edwards' love of Christmas, describing how the Edwards family, including John Edwards, decorated their Christmas tree last Saturday, just three days before she died.
    A friend of Edwards' family said Saturday that Elizabeth Edwards did not plan the funeral or instruct on many details.
    One family friend said the mood has been somber: "We all thought we'd have more time to say goodbye."
    In addition to the eulogies by McElroy and Cate Edwards, another friend, Glenn Bergenfield spoke, remembering when Elizabeth Edwards told staffers about her cancer. According to Bergenfield, she rubbed their backs as they sat on the couch, then turned to them and told them they had on awful shoes, and outlet shopping was necessary, right then and there.
    Others in attendance included North Carolina Gov. Bev Perdue; U.S. Sen. Kay Hagan (D-North Carolina); Vicki Kennedy, the wife of the late Sen. Ted Kennedy; John Podesta, a former Clinton administration chief of staff and current head of the Center for American Progress; members of North Carolina's congressional delegation; and more than 100 former campaign staffers.
    It was a public ceremony because Edwards was known for insisting, much to the dismay of staffers, that all of her events be open to the public, according to a friend. Edwards did not plan the funeral or instruct many details, so the family decided a public funeral was what she would have wanted, even it added some chaos to the ceremony.
    The "public" mourners included several hundred people who packed a balcony inside the church, as well another 150 supporters who gathered a few blocks away from the church for a counter-demonstration against a group of picketers from the controversial Westboro Baptist Church.
    The Kansas-based congregation is known for its extremist opposition against homosexuals, Jews and other groups and regularly holds protests at funerals for fallen U.S. service members, saying the war's dead are God's punishment for the country tolerating gays and lesbians.
    In the end, only five Westboro congregants showed for the protest, which took place in a cold, steady rain.
    Following the service at Edenton Street United Methodist Church Edwards will be buried at Raleigh's Historic Oakwood Cemetery, according to office manager Sharon Freed. Earlier this week, Freed told CNN about the proximity of the burial to Edwards' son Wade, who was buried at the cemetery after dying in a 1996 car crash.
    "He is already interred there in a space. And she will be interred there beside him," Freed said.
    Four of Elizabeth Edwards' pallbearers were childhood friends of her son. They include Tyler Highsmith, Michael Lewis, Charles Scarantino and Ellis Roberts, who was an aide to John Edwards when he was in the U.S. Senate.
    Other pallbearers include longtime friend Bill Spiegel, B.A. Farrell, an Edwards confidant and adviser, and her hospice doctor, Michael Chernier. Trevor Upham, Cate Edwards' fiance is also a pallbearer.
    Edwards, who had four children and had worked as a bankruptcy lawyer in Raleigh, was diagnosed with breast cancer shortly after her husband lost his bid for vice president in November 2004.
    In 2006, after her initial cancer diagnosis, she wrote "Saving Graces: Finding Solace and Strength from Friends and Strangers," which chronicled the aftermath of her son's death and her battle with the disease.
    In 2008, months after withdrawing from the presidential race, John Edwards admitted that tabloid claims about an extramarital affair with former campaign videographer Rielle Hunter were true. Eventually, he also admitted to fathering a child with Hunter -- an allegation he initially vociferously denied even after conceding the affair.
    John Edwards said the affair happened in 2006 while his wife's cancer was in remission. He claimed he informed his wife at the time and asked for her forgiveness.
    In an interview with the Detroit Free Press after her husband admitted to his affair, Elizabeth Edwards said the incident helped her focus on resuming her role as an advocate for the poor and for health care reform. She also said it pushed her to refocus on her role as a mother.
    In a September interview on "The Nate Berkus Show," Edwards was asked what she sees when she looks at her estranged husband, John Edwards.
    "I see the father of my children, and that's very important to me," she said. "Particularly since I have a terminal disease, this is the person who at some point will take over the primary parenting, and it's important to me that he heal, if he needs to."
    A memorial website for Edwards states, "In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to the Wade Edwards Foundation, which benefits the Wade Edwards Learning Lab." According to the site, the learning lab is a computer and learning center in Raleigh that provides services free of charge.

    Edwards remembered for her love, courage, friendship

    I know that I have added a lot of posts for Elizabeth Edwards but she was a hero to me how she lived her life, with dignity, love, and honesty.  She will be missed terribly.


    Published Sat, Dec 11, 2010 12:08 PM
    Modified Sat, Dec 11, 2010 07:04 PM

    CLOWENST@NEWSOBSERVER.COM
    John Edwards, center, leaves the Edenton Street United Methodist Church in Raleigh with his children Emma Claire, left, Jack and Cate, right, after Elizabeth Edward's funeral on Saturday, December 11, 2010.


     Elizabeth Edwards, in a funeral attended by hundreds of mourners at Edenton Street United Methodist Church and many more outside in a steady drizzle in downtown Raleigh, was praised today for her love, courage, optimism, generosity and friendship.
    Former Sen. John Edwards, with his three surviving children, entered the church for his wife's funeral at 1 p.m. He embraced his 2004 running mate on the Democratic national ticket, Sen. John Kerry of Massachusetts, and also Gov. Bev Perdue before Elizabeth Edwards' casket, draped in white, was brought to the front of the church.
    Hargrave McElroy, Elizabeth Edwards' close friend for the past 29 years, praised her optimism, her competitiveness, her generous friendship and her "embrace of all that is possible" in her opening eulogy.
    Longtime friend Glenn Bergenfield then brought laughter from the mourners with stories of his friendship with "sweet, sweet Elizabeth," which began in law school in 1974 and has "sustained me in times both good and wretched."
    Finally, Edwards' older daughter, Cate, spoke. "She could bring out the brave in anyone," Cate said, recounting moments near the end when her mom could no longer speak but still, with gestures, comforted her family more than they could comfort her.
    Down the street, members of the Westboro Baptist Church of Topeka, Kan., known for picketing outside military funerals, brought a small group to picket near Edwards' service. The church members have picketed at the funerals of Coretta Scott King and Jerry Falwell, among many others. A much larger local group, "Line of Love," organized a counterprotest in support of "promoting proper respect for funerals."
    As the funeral began, three adults and two children from the Westboro church were on one side of Edenton Street, holding signs denigrating Edwards.
    On the other side of the street, in front of the Justice Department building, several hundred counterprotesters gathered in the drizzle. Signs in the crowd said, "God loves Elizabeth Edwards," and others, in pink, said simply, "Hope" and "Hero."
    The crowd supporting Edwards sang Christmas carols, the National Anthem and "Lean on Me," the Bill Withers classic. Other supporters circled the block in cars, playing country music as the crowd cheered.
    Some supporters brought American flag umbrellas to pass out to the crowd, and one man brought a poster-making kit.
    Among the Edwards supporters was Bob Krasnicka, who came from Wake Forest to help.
    "I'm sick of hearing about these people going to funerals and spreading their hate," said Krasnicka, 48, referring to the Westboro protesters. Of Edwards, he said, "I know she has young children who don't need to be seeing this kind of hate."
    Edwards, 61, died Tuesday after a battle with cancer. Her husband was the Democrats' 2004 vice presidential candidate and made a failed bid for the presidency in 2008. The couple separated after John Edwards fathered a child with his mistress.
    The couple had four children together, including 12-year-old Emma Claire and 10-year-old Jack.