In Toll of 2,000, New Portrait of Afghan War
Kevin Frayer/Associated Press
Aboard a medical helicopter,
Cpl. Andrew Smith of the Marines was treated by Sgt. Jaime Adame, top,
an Army medic, after being seriously wounded in an attack in Helmand
Province on May 15, 2011. Corporal Smith ultimately recovered from his
injuries
By JAMES DAO and ANDREW W. LEHREN
August 21, 2012
His war was almost over. Or so Marina Buckley thought when her son Lance
Cpl. Gregory T. Buckley Jr. told her that he would be returning from
southern Afghanistan to his Marine Corps base in Hawaii in late August,
three months early.
Instead, Lance Corporal Buckley became the 1,990th American service
member to die in the war when, on Aug. 10, he and two other Marines were
shot inside their base in Helmand Province by a man who appears to have
been a member of the Afghan forces they were training.
A week later, with the death of Specialist James A. Justice of the Army
at a military hospital in Germany, the United States military reached
2,000 dead in the nearly 11-year-old conflict, based on an analysis by
The New York Times of Department of Defense records. The calculation by The Times
includes deaths not only in Afghanistan but also in Pakistan and other
nations where American forces are directly involved in aiding the war.
Nearly nine years passed before American forces reached their first
1,000 dead in the war. The second 1,000 came just 27 months later, a
testament to the intensity of fighting prompted by President Obama’s
decision to send 33,000 additional troops to Afghanistan in 2010, a
policy known as the surge.
In more ways than his family might have imagined, Lance Corporal
Buckley, who had just turned 21 when he died, typified the troops in
that second wave of 1,000. According to the Times analysis, three out of
four were white, 9 out of 10 were enlisted service members, and one out
of two died in either Kandahar Province or Helmand Province in
Taliban-dominated southern Afghanistan. Their average age was 26.
The dead were also disproportionately Marines like Lance Corporal
Buckley. Though the Army over all has suffered more dead in the war, the
Marine Corps, with fewer troops, has had a higher casualty rate: At the
height of fighting in late 2010, 2 out of every 1,000 Marines in
Afghanistan were dying, twice the rate of the Army. Marine units
accounted for three of the five units hardest hit during the surge.
Suffering the most casualties was the Third Battalion, Fifth Marine
Regiment out of Camp Pendleton, Calif. Twenty-five of its Marines died
and more than 180 were wounded, many with multiple amputations, during a
bloody seven-month deployment in Helmand that began in fall 2010.
The analysis also shows that Army casualties during the surge fell
heaviest on two bases with frequently deployed units: Fort Campbell in
Kentucky, home to the 101st Airborne Division, which recorded the most
Army deaths in the surge, and Fort Drum in New York, home to the 10th
Mountain Division.
The summer remained the peak season for fighting, with the single
highest period for American deaths being July, August and September
2010, when at least 143 troops died. And as has been the case since at
least 2008, improvised explosive devices, known as I.E.D.’s, remained a leading cause of death and injury, along with small-arms fire, the analysis showed.
But this year, another threat emerged: an intensified wave of attacks by
Afghan security forces. In just the past two weeks, at least 9
Americans have been killed in such insider attacks. For the year to
date, at least 40 NATO service members, most of them American, have been
killed by either active members of the Afghan forces or attackers
dressed in their uniforms — already outstripping the toll from all last
year.
Those insider attacks have increased concerns about NATO’s ability to
turn security operations over to Afghan forces by 2014, the deadline set
by President Obama for withdrawing the remaining American forces. For
families, the deaths have raised hard questions about whether the
Pentagon is doing enough to protect its troops from their own allies.
Though Afghanistan is now considered the nation’s longest war, at 128
months and counting, the number of dead is fewer than half the total in
the Iraq war, where more than 4,480 died in eight years. More
active-duty and reserve soldiers killed themselves last year, 278, than
died in combat in Afghanistan, 247.
None of that brings solace to the families of the dead. For the
Buckleys, of Oceanside, N.Y., their son’s death so near the end of his
tour, so late in the long war and possibly at the hand of a purported
ally, was uniquely anguishing.
As Mrs. Buckley recounted things her son loved — basketball, girls, movies, the beach — bitterness choked her words.
“Our forces shouldn’t be there,” she said. “It should be over. It’s done. No more.”
A Unit Hit Hard
The Third Battalion, Fifth Marine Regiment out of Camp Pendleton,
Calif., was emblematic of the surge. Sent into Sangin, Afghanistan’s
opium-producing heartland, in 2010, the battalion faced a formidable
enemy expert in the use of I.E.D.’s., losing 25 Marines in a seven-month
tour, the second most of any American unit in the entire war, a Times
analysis shows.
Mark Moyar, an
independent national security analyst who has studied the battalion’s
operations, said that the British who had preceded the Marines in
Sangin, a district in Helmand, focused on economic development and
political outreach to undermine the insurgency. But the Taliban also
operated with near impunity in parts of the district, he said.
The battalion took a different approach, pushing into Taliban-dominated
villages. Fighting was intense, with civilians often getting caught in
the middle, and casualties piled up fast.
On Oct. 8, barely two weeks after the battalion landed, it lost its
first Marine, Lance Cpl. John T. Sparks. Five days later, four Marines
of the battalion died when their armored truck was destroyed by a
powerful bomb. Three more died the next day when they stepped on a mine
during a foot patrol.
The rapid-fire deaths prompted calls in Washington for the battalion to
pull back. But senior Marine commanders — including the battalion
commander, Lt. Col. Jason Morris — prevailed on Secretary of Defense
Robert M. Gates to leave them in place.
“Everyone was shocked, including me, that we lost that many guys that
quickly,” Colonel Morris said. “But honestly, me and most of my Marines
would have rather come home in body bags than let the Taliban claim a
victory.”
Deanna Giles, the mother of a squad leader from the battalion, remembers
those days all too well. Amid the blur of casualty reports, Ms. Giles
began watching for strange cars in her neighborhood in Kankakee, Ill.,
fearing the next one would bear horrible news.
Anxiously seeking information or solace, she took to Internet chat
rooms, forming a powerful digital bond with other families from the
battalion, whom she never met in person.
“You began to care about people in a way you could not have before the Internet age,” Ms. Giles said.
Her son, Sgt. Caleb Giles, came home alive. Patty Schumacher’s son, Lance Cpl. Victor A. Dew, did not.
Ms. Schumacher had begged her son to defer enlisting until the war
ended. When he refused, she urged him to take a job with a presidential
security detail. He again said no, determined to be an infantryman and
to go to war.
“Boy, did my heart sink,” she recalled. “But I was also proud of him for
following his true desires. As a parent you just suck it up, hold your
heart and take a deep breath and hope all goes well.”
In late August 2010, Lance Corporal Dew proposed to his girlfriend, then
was deployed a month later. Within weeks of arriving in Helmand, he
died with three other Marines in a powerful I.E.D. blast. At age 20, he
became the 1,259th American to die in the war.
Inside his coffin, his fiancée placed a photograph of herself, wearing her wedding gown.
Ms. Schumacher maintains a Facebook page to keep his memory fresh, and
occasionally toasts him at dinner. She still cries, too, though the
tears are hard to predict, prompted by stray images and fleeting sounds
that remind her of him: a smile, a song, a joke.
“When do you get better? You don’t ever get better,” she said. “You just
get better in your grieving. There will always be something that
triggers it. And then you are back on that emotional roller coaster.”
Attacks From Afghans
Staff Sgt. Scott E. Dickinson was coming home early. He was originally
scheduled to remain in Helmand until November 2012, but the Pentagon was
pulling Marines out of Afghanistan quickly, looking to get the surge
forces out of the country by fall and shrink the American footprint to
about 70,000 troops. He would be home in Hawaii within a week or two, he
told his father early this month.
Not long after that conversation, his father, John Dickinson, saw an
article about a soldier who had died just a week before he was to come
home. “I thought, ‘He’s not safe until he sets foot in Hawaii,’ ”
recalled Mr. Dickinson, an architect in San Diego.
He was right. Sergeant Dickinson, 29, a supply specialist who had
volunteered to help train Afghan forces, died with Lance Corporal
Buckley on Aug. 10. They were among six Marines killed that day in two
separate attacks by men who appeared to be Afghan security force
members.
The Pentagon asserts that most of those attacks have been the result of
personal grudges, disputing Taliban claims to have widely infiltrated
the Afghan security forces.
But the attacks have also raised anew concerns about the integrity of
the Afghan forces that NATO expects to secure the entire nation after
NATO troops withdraw in 2014.
More fundamentally, the continued deaths, occurring even as American
forces are conducting fewer combat missions, have prompted service
members and military families to wonder: has the decade-long American
presence in Afghanistan made a difference?
Colonel Morris, the former commander for the Third Battalion, Fifth
Marine Regiment, has little doubt that it has. After months of fierce
fighting, he saw clear changes when he left Sangin in early 2011. Those
improvements remain, he asserts, with residents participating in
elections and going to school with less fear of Taliban intimidation —
though such intimidation is far from gone.
“Every single Marine in my battalion could see the impact they had,” he
said. “It was a validation of everything they had sacrificed for.”
Despite his son’s death, Mr. Dickinson agrees. Marina Buckley is not so sure.
“He was the most lovable, caring human being,” she said of her son. “He
wore his heart on his sleeve. Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful.”
He had wanted to join the Marine Corps ever since 9/11, despite her many
attempts to dissuade him. By the time he was in high school a Marine
Corps flag hung in his bedroom and her efforts to get him to go to
college — Adelphi University accepted him his senior year — had failed.
“I’d say, ‘Why the Marines?’ ” she said, and he would reply with a joke.
“I can pick up a lot of chicks with that uniform,” he would say.
But his ambition was serious: he wanted to serve, then become a Suffolk
County police officer. He came to relish the brotherhood of the Marines
and adored his first posting, in Hawaii. But deployment was different.
The loneliness, the heat and the Meals Ready to Eat wore on him, Ms.
Buckley said.
And he never felt secure living alongside Afghans, she said.
“If they want to kill themselves, let them,” she said of the Afghan
people. “But they are killing people who shouldn’t be killed, who have
lives here, and family here, and brothers and sisters here.”
Eddie Goldberger contributed reporting, and Jack Begg, Alain Delaquérière and Jack Styczynski contributed research.
Published: August 21, 2012
2,003 Deaths in Afghanistan
The chart shows deaths of identified United States service members directly involved in the war in Afghanistan. Rocket-propelled grenades and small-arms fire took the largest number of American lives earlier in the war. In 2008, deaths from improvised explosive devices, or I.E.D.’s, began to make up a larger share of combat deaths.
Faces of the Dead
This is an awesome interactive, each tiny square is a picture of a service member who has died in Iraq or Afghanistan and been Identified by the Department of Defense.
