Pages

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Video - President Obama Speaks to the People of Brazil

March 20, 2011 | 22:17 | Public Domain

The President speaks at the Teatro Municipal in Rio de Janeiro, praising Brazil for its transformation into a vibrant democracy and calling on other nations to increase opportunity and respect human rights.


President Obama’s Santiago Speech: "The Latin America That I See Today"

President Obama’s Santiago Speech: "The Latin America That I See Today"

President Barack Obama Speaks at Centro Cultural Palacio de La Moneda in Santiago, Chile
President Barack Obama delivers a speech at Centro Cultural Palacio de La Moneda in Santiago, Chile, March 21, 2011. (Official White House Photo by Pete Souza)
“Latin America is at peace...” 
“Latin America is democratic...”
“Latin America is growing...”
“Latin America is coming together to address shared challenges…”
“And increasingly, Latin America is contributing to global prosperity and security…”
With these refrains, the President described “the Latin America that I see today -- a region on the move, proud of its progress, and ready to assume a greater role in world affairs.”  The 
speech in Santiago, Chile included perhaps his most expansive vision for strengthened alliances across our hemisphere, although as he pointed out, these relationships have been a priority since the beginning of his presidency as demonstrated by his trip in his first few months to Trinidad and Tobago for the Summit of the Americas. 
He began his remarks with a tribute to Chile as a leading example of today’s Latin America, emerging from decades of turmoil towards a future of hope and progress.  He quoted legendary Chilean poet Pablo Neruda:
And in a world of sometimes wrenching pain -- as we’re seeing today in Japan -- it is the character of this country that inspires.  “Our original guiding stars,” said Pablo Neruda, “are struggle and hope.”  But, he added, “there is no such thing as a lone struggle, no such thing as a lone hope.”  The Chilean people have shown this time and again, including your recovery from the terrible earthquake here one year ago.
He went on to discuss what has been the primary purpose of his trip, namely to find paths for joint economic growth and promote American exports:
I believe that Latin America is more important to the prosperity and security of the United States than ever before.  With no other region does the United States have so many connections.  And nowhere do we see that more than in the tens of millions of Hispanic Americans across the United States, who enrich our society, grow our economy and strengthen our nation every single day.        
And I believe Latin America is only going to become more important to the United States, especially to our economy.  Trade between the United States and Latin America has surged.  We buy more of your products, more of your goods than any other country, and we invest more in this region than any other country.
For instance, we export more than three times as much to Latin America as we do to China.  Our exports to this region -- which are growing faster than our exports to the rest of the world -- will soon support more than 2 million U.S. jobs.  In other words, when Latin America is more prosperous, the United States is more prosperous.
But even more than interests, we’re bound by shared values.  In each other’s journey we see reflections of our own.  Colonists who broke free from empires.  Pioneers who opened new frontiers.  Citizens who have struggled to expand our nations’ promise to all people -- men and women, white, black and brown.  We’re people of faith who must remember that all of us -- especially the most fortunate among us -- must do our part, especially for the least among us.  We’re citizens who know that ensuring that democracies deliver for our people must be the work of all.
This is our common history.  This is our common heritage.  We are all Americans.  Todos somos Americanos
The President also spoke of the challenges that remained, from the drug trade and the violence that continues to follow it, to sharp income inequality, to leaders who cling to bankrupt ideologies to justify their own power and who seek to silence their opponents because those opponents have the audacity to demand their universal rights.”  But he also went on to speak of specific initiatives that our nations are working on together, including cracking down on the flow of drugs and guns across the borders, streamlining air travel and cargo transport, creating joint “Pathways to Prosperity” focused on microcredit and entrepreneurship training, and the Energy and Climate Partnership of the Americas that will harness the strengths of every country in moving the world toward a clean energy future and economy.  He also announced two new initiatives:
First, we’re launching a new initiative to harness the power of social media and online networks to help students, scientists, academics and entrepreneurs collaborate and develop the new ideas and products that will keep America -- the Americas competitive in a global economy.
And I’m proud to announce that the United States will work with partners in this region, including the private sector, to increase the number of U.S. students studying in Latin America to 100,000, and the number of Latin America students studying in the United States to 100,000.
The President closed recalling the joyous rescue of the Chilean miners as a symbolic moment:
If ever we needed a reminder of the humanity and the hopes that we share, that moment in the desert was such.  When a country like Chile puts its mind to it, there’s nothing you can’t do.  When countries across Latin America come together and focus on a common goal, when the United States and others in the world do our part, there’s nothing we can’t accomplish together.

Remarks by the President to the People of Brazil in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

The White House
Office of the Press Secretary


Teatro Municipal
Rio de Janeiro
2:56 P.M. BRT
THE PRESIDENT:  Hello, Rio de Janeiro!
AUDIENCE:  Hello!
AUDIENCE MEMBER:  Many welcomes!
THE PRESIDENT:  Alo!  Cidade!  Maravilhoso!  (Applause.)  Boa tarde, todo o povo brasileiro.  (Applause.)
Since the moment we arrived, the people of this nation have graciously shown my family the warmth and generosity of the Brazilian spirit.  Obrigado.  Thank you.  (Applause.)  And I want to give a special thanks to all of you for being here, because I've been told that there’s a Vasco football game coming.  (Cheers and boos.)  Botafogo –- (laughter.)  So I know that -- I realize Brazilians don’t give up their soccer very easily.  (Laughter.)   
Now, one of my earliest impressions of Brazil was a movie I saw with my mother as a very young child, a movie called Black Orpheus, that is set in the favelas of Rio during Carnival.  And my mother loved that movie, with its singing and dancing against the backdrop of the beautiful green hills.  And it first premiered as a play right here in Teatro Municipal.  That's my understanding. 
And my mother is gone now, but she would have never imagined that her son’s first trip to Brazil would be as President of the United States.  She would have never imagined that.  (Applause.) And I never imagined that this country would be even more beautiful than it was in the movie.  You are, as Jorge Ben-Jor sang, “A tropical country, blessed by God, and beautiful by nature.”  (Applause.)   
I’ve seen that beauty in the cascading hillsides, in your endless miles of sand and ocean, and in the vibrant, diverse gatherings of brasileiros who have come here today. 
And we have a wonderfully mixed group.  We have Cariocas and Paulistas, Baianas, Mineiros.  (Applause.)  We’ve got men and women from the cities to the interior, and so many young people here who are the great future of this great nation.   
Now, yesterday, I met with your wonderful new President, Dilma Rousseff, and talked about how we can strengthen the partnership between our governments.  But today, I want to speak directly to the Brazilian people about how we can strengthen the friendship between our nations.  I’ve come here to share some ideas because I want to speak of the values that we share, the hopes that we have in common, and the difference that we can make together. 
When you think about it, the journeys of the United States of America and Brazil began in similar ways.  Our lands are rich with God’s creation, home to ancient and indigenous peoples.  From overseas, the Americas were discovered by men who sought a New World, and settled by pioneers who pushed westward, across vast frontiers.  We became colonies claimed by distant crowns, but soon declared our independence.  We then welcomed waves of immigrants to our shores, and eventually after a long struggle, we cleansed the stain of slavery from our land.  
The United States was the first nation to recognize Brazil’s independence, and set up a diplomatic outpost in this country.  The first head of state to visit the United States was the leader of Brazil, Dom Pedro II.  In the Second World War, our brave men and women fought side-by-side for freedom.  And after the war, both of our nations struggled to achieve the full blessings of liberty. 
On the streets of the United States, men and women marched and bled and some died so that every citizen could enjoy the same freedoms and opportunities -– no matter what you looked like, no matter where you came from.
In Brazil, you fought against two decades of dictatorships for the same right to be heard -– the right to be free from fear, free from want.  And yet, for years, democracy and development were slow to take hold, and millions suffered as a result. 
But I come here today because those days have passed.  Brazil today is a flourishing democracy -– a place where people are free to speak their mind and choose their leaders; where a poor kid from Pernambuco can rise from the floors of a copper factory to the highest office in Brazil. 
Over the last decade, the progress made by the Brazilian people has inspired the world.  More than half of this nation is now considered middle class.  Millions have been lifted from poverty.  For the first time, hope is returning to places where fear had long prevailed.  I saw this today when I visited Cidade de Deus -– the City of God.  (Applause.) 
It isn’t just the new security efforts and social programs  -- and I want to congratulate the mayor and the governor for the excellent work that they’re doing.  (Applause.)  But it’s also a change in attitudes.  As one young resident said, “People have to look at favelas not with pity, but as a source of presidents and lawyers and doctors, artists, [and] people with solutions.”  (Applause.)
With each passing day, Brazil is a country with more solutions.  In the global community, you’ve gone from relying on the help of other nations, to now helping fight poverty and disease wherever they exist.  You play an important role in the global institutions that protect our common security and promote our common prosperity.  And you will welcome the world to your shores when the World Cup and the Olympic games come to Rio de Janeiro.  (Applause.)
Now, you may be aware that this city was not my first choice for the Summer Olympics.  (Laughter.)  But if the games could not be held in Chicago, then there’s no place I’d rather see them than right here in Rio.  And I intend to come back in 2016 to watch what happens.  (Applause.) 
For so long, Brazil was a nation brimming with potential but held back by politics, both at home and abroad.  For so long, you were called a country of the future, told to wait for a better day that was always just around the corner.
Meus amigos, that day has finally come.  And this is a country of the future no more.  The people of Brazil should know that the future has arrived.  It is here now.  And it’s time to seize it.  (Applause.)
Now, our countries have not always agreed on everything.  And just like many nations, we’re going to have our differences of opinion going forward.  But I’m here to tell you that the American people don’t just recognize Brazil’s success -– we root for Brazil’s success.  As you confront the many challenges you still face at home as well as abroad, let us stand together -– not as senior and junior partners, but as equal partners, joined in a spirit of mutual interest and mutual respect, committed to the progress that I know that we can make together.  (Applause.) I'm confident we can do it.  (Applause.)
Together we can advance our common prosperity.  As two of the world’s largest economies, we worked side by side during the financial crisis to restore growth and confidence.  And to keep our economies growing, we know what’s necessary in both of our nations.  We need a skilled, educated workforce -- which is why American and Brazilian companies have pledged to help increase student exchanges between our two nations. 
We need a commitment to innovation and technology -- which is why we've agreed to expand cooperation between our scientists, researchers, and engineers.
We need world-class infrastructure -- which is why American companies want to help you build and prepare this city for Olympic success.
In a global economy, the United States and Brazil should expand trade, expand investment, so that we create new jobs and new opportunities in both of our nations.  And that's why we're working to break down barriers to doing business.  That's why we're building closer relationships between our workers and our entrepreneurs.     
Together we can also promote energy security and protect our beautiful planet.  As two nations that are committed to greener economies, we know that the ultimate solution to our energy challenges lies in clean and renewable power.  And that’s why half the vehicles in this country can run on biofuels, and most of your electricity comes from hydropower.  That’s also why, in the United States, we’ve jumpstarted a new clean energy industry. And that’s why the United States and Brazil are creating new energy partnerships -- to share technologies, create new jobs, and leave our children a world that is cleaner and safer than we found it.  (Applause.)  
Together, our two nations can also help defend our citizens’ security.  We’re working together to stop narco-trafficking that has destroyed too many lives in this hemisphere.  We seek the goal of a world without nuclear weapons.  We’re working together to enhance nuclear security across our hemisphere.  From Africa to Haiti, we are working side by side to combat the hunger, disease, and corruption that can rot a society and rob human beings of dignity and opportunity.  (Applause.)  And as two countries that have been greatly enriched by our African heritage, it’s absolutely vital that we are working with the continent of Africa to help lift it up.  That is something that we should be committed to doing together.  (Applause.)
Today, we’re both also delivering assistance and support to the Japanese people at their greatest hour of need.  The ties that bind our nations to Japan are strong.  In Brazil, you are home to the largest Japanese population outside of Japan.  In the United States, we forged an alliance of more than 60 years.  The people of Japan are some of our closest friends, and we will pray with them, and stand with them, and rebuild with them until this crisis has passed.  (Applause.)
In these and other efforts to promote peace and prosperity throughout the world, the United States and Brazil are partners not just because we share history, not just because we’re in the same hemisphere; not just because we share ties of commerce and culture, but also because we share certain enduring values and ideals. 
We both believe in the power and promise of democracy.  We believe that no other form of government is more effective at promoting growth and prosperity that reaches every human being -- not just some but all.  And those who argue otherwise, those who argue that democracy stands in the way of economic progress, they must contend with the example of Brazil. 
The millions in this country who have climbed from poverty into the middle class, they could not do so in a closed economy controlled by the state.  You’re prospering as a free people with open markets and a government that answers to its citizens.  You’re proving that the goal of social justice and social inclusion can be best achieved through freedom -– that democracy is the greatest partner of human progress.  (Applause.)  
We also believe that in nations as big and diverse as ours, shaped by generations of immigrants from every race and faith and background, democracy offers the best hope that every citizen is treated with dignity and respect, and that we can resolve our differences peacefully, that we find strength in our diversity. 
We know that experience in the United States.  We know how important it is to be able to work together -- even when we often disagree.  I understand that our chosen form of government can be slow and messy.  We understand that democracy must be constantly strengthened and perfected over time.  We know that different nations take different paths to realize the promise of democracy. And we understand that no one nation should impose its will on another. 
But we also know that there’s certain aspirations shared by every human being:  We all seek to be free.  We all seek to be heard.  We all yearn to live without fear or discrimination.  We all yearn to choose how we are governed.  And we all want to shape our own destiny.  These are not American ideals or Brazilian ideals.  These are not Western ideals.  These are universal rights, and we must support them everywhere.  (Applause.)
Today, we are seeing the struggle for these rights unfold across the Middle East and North Africa.  We’ve seen a revolution born out of a yearning for basic human dignity in Tunisia.  We’ve seen peaceful protestors pour into Tahrir Square -– men and women, young and old, Christian and Muslim.  We’ve seen the people of Libya take a courageous stand against a regime determined to brutalize its own citizens.  Across the region, we’ve seen young people rise up -– a new generation demanding the right to determine their own future. 
From the beginning, we have made clear that the change they seek must be driven by their own people.  But for our two nations, for the United States and Brazil, two nations who have struggled over many generations to perfect our own democracies, the United States and Brazil know that the future of the Arab World will be determined by its people.
No one can say for certain how this change will end, but I do know that change is not something that we should fear.  When young people insist that the currents of history are on the move, the burdens of the past can be washed away.  When men and women peacefully claim their human rights, our own common humanity is enhanced.  Wherever the light of freedom is lit, the world becomes a brighter place.
That is the example of Brazil.  That is the example of Brazil.  (Applause.)  Brazil -– a country that shows that a dictatorship can become a thriving democracy.  Brazil -– a country that shows democracy delivers both freedom and opportunity to its people.  Brazil -- a country that shows how a call for change that starts in the streets can transform a city, transform a country, transform a world.
Decades ago, it was directly outside of this theater, in Cinelandia Square, where the call for change was heard in Brazil. Students and artists and political leaders of all stripes would gather with banners that said, “Down with the dictatorship.  The people in power.”  Their democratic aspirations would not be fulfilled until years later, but one of the young Brazilians in that generation’s movement would go on to forever change the history of this country. 
A child of an immigrant, her participation in the movement led to her arrest and her imprisonment, her torture at the hands of her own government.  And so she knows what it’s like to live without the most basic human rights that so many are fighting for today.  But she also knows what it is to persevere.  She knows what it is to overcome -- because today that woman is your nation’s president, Dilma Rousseff.  (Applause.)  
Our two nations face many challenges.  On the road ahead, we will certainly encounter many obstacles.  But in the end, it is our history that gives us hope for a better tomorrow.  It is the knowledge that the men and women who came before us have triumphed over greater trials than these -– that we live in places where ordinary people have done extraordinary things. 
It’s that sense of possibility, that sense of optimism that first drew pioneers to this New World.  It’s what binds our nations together as partners in this new century.  It’s why we believe, in the words of Paul Coelho, one of your most famous writers, “With the strength of our love and our will, we can change our destiny, as well as the destiny of many others.”
Muito obrigado.  Thank you.  And may God bless our two nations.  Thank you very much.  (Applause.)

Obama's First War


Saturday, March 19, 2011 | 4:33 p.m.

GETTY IMAGES
President Obama had to balance the ideals of democracy and the hard-nosed interests of the country in his decision making.

As a fleet of French airplanes lacerated a column of Libyan army vehicles near Benghazi on Saturday, President Obama stuck to his prearranged schedule in Brazil, receiving whispered updates from his aides. Within three hours, more than 100 cruise missiles had hit two dozen targets in Libya. That’s just “the first phase,” William Gortney, the director of the Joint Staff, told reporters.
What he didn't say: It's the first phase of what will become Barack Obama's first new war. By directing the military to hit targets inside Libya, the Obama administration is trying to strike an incredibly delicate balance between a strong disinclination to invade a Muslim country and their determined desire to avoid looking like they’re walking away from the indiscriminate slaughter of innocents.
When Muammar el-Qaddafi first struck back against protesters, Obama hoped that tough sanctions and material support to the opposition would be enough to force the dictator from power. Defense Secretary Robert Gates warned him that a “no fly zone” would be ineffective and essentially commit the country to war. By Monday night, it was clear to Obama that this policy wasn’t working. Countries like Iran were getting the wrong message. The Libyan military was selectively testing the patience of the world by striking opposition strongholds. The opposition was pinned down in the port city of Benghazi, swelled by tens of thousands of refugees. Qaddafi kept using a phrase that stuck in Obama's head: “no mercy.” And France, smarting from seeming to abandon Egyptians during their time of trouble, along with the U.K., were champing at the bit to use force. The Arab League had kicked Libya out and was closer to the French position. It risked its own legitimacy, already questioned by many in the region, if it didn’t side with the rebels.
On Tuesday, during a meeting of his national security team, Obama said he wanted a new policy. “Clearly, what we’re doing is not enough,” he said, according to contemporaneous notes kept by a participant. A “humanitarian disaster” was imminent unless something was done. He wanted more options.
Gates wanted to game out scenarios, knowing that any effective no-fly zone would necessitate a cascade of other military actions that would look a heck of a lot like an invasion, no matter how carefully it was done.
Thomas Donilon, the national security adviser and one of the gatekeepers of Obama’s foreign policy, was worried about the strategic implications of both allowing Qaddafi to succeed in retaking control of Benghazi as well as what would happen down the road in other countries if a successful military response ousted him from power with a minimum of bloodshed. Even the lightest military footprint would result in civilian casualties, he warned. Almost as inevitable would be the death of a coalition soldier or the downing of an airplane.
Hillary Rodham Clinton said instability in Libya threatened to clip the democratic aspirations of its two neighbors, Egypt and Tunisia. She was also worried about the message to Iran if the U.S. and its allies did nothing in Libya: America was so afraid of committing its military to protect Muslims and Arabs that it would allow virtually anything to happen.
The meeting broke up.
Donilon would take charge of a rapid-fire series of conference calls and meetings and would, by that night, bring to the president three new policy proposals, each of which would call for a mix of diplomatic, military and intelligence actions against Libya. Obama had dinner with his combat commanders, and solicited their input about what challenges the military would face. At 9 p.m. that night, he reconvened only his principals. (Clinton was represented by her deputy, James Steinberg.) Donilon laid out his proposals. After about an hour, the Situation Room had come to a rough consensus: a no fly zone wouldn’t work, but more words would not work either. Obama instructed his U.N. ambassador, Susan Rice, to inform the Security Council that France’s resolution, which called for a no fly zone and little else, was insufficient. He asked the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Mike Mullen, to turn into him by the next evening a Concept of Operation Plan, or CONPLAN, for a NATO-executed military campaign in Libya that would be assisted by Arab countries.
In closed session at the U.N., Rice laid out the U.S. position. The situation was urgent and dire. But the world had to know precisely what it would mean to keep Libyan troops from murdering their own citizens. Any resolution would have to include language authorizing strikes against Libyan military infrastructure on the ground to prevent a humanitarian catastrophe. “We are not going to hide pooch,” Rice said in the meeting, according to a U.S. official. “We must be completely clear about what we are going to do and why.” And Arab countries must participate, she insisted, in some visible way, in the campaign. She proposed a number of amendments that added significant heft to the resolution.
For the next 24 hours, Clinton and Rice tag-teamed Arab countries and members of the Security Council. They argued that if nothing was done, despots and beleaguered leaders everywhere would vow never to repeat the “mistake” of Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, who yielded power without foreign military intervention. Iran, in particular, would find itself with an incentive to continue to spread its proxy forces to other countries and further repress its own citizens. And Rice has made the reinvigoration of the United Nations one of her prime goals as ambassador. The legitimacy of that body was at stake too, she argued.
On Wednesday, at about 6:30 p.m., Mullen and Donilon presented Obama with their CONPLAN for Libya. Its contents are mostly classified; an official said the air strikes on Saturday were one part of a larger campaign that includes a variety of overt and covert actions. Published reports suggest that U.K. special operations forces were secreted in the country, scouting out the battlefield in preparation for air strikes. The U.S. Air Force Special Operations Command moved several tactical air teams to a small base on Crete. In order to try and disguise their movements, the U.S. planes changed their call signs once they entered airspace over the Mediterranean, but commercial software that tracks their transponders revealed the shift, and word leaked out on Twitter. These teams would coordinate the air assault but are capable of parachuting into a region and directing them from the ground.
On Friday, the U.S. moved a Rivet Joint signals intelligence plane to Souda Air Base on a Greek Island, bearing the provocative call sign of “SNOOP 55.” Subs capable of launching Tomahawk missiles idled near Italy. The USS Florida, armed with more than 100 Tomahawks, moved into firing range. Twenty four hours after the U.S. introduced its amendments, it got its resolution, 10-0. Obama spoke with his counterparts in France and the UK and agreed that they’d give Qadaffi 24 hours to turn heel and retreat. If he didn’t, France would begin the bombardment.
It was important to the U.S. that Libyans and the world understand that this coalition of the willing was more than a U.S. rhetorical construct. An hour before bombing began Saturday, Clinton spoke to the press in Paris. Asked why military action was in America’s interest, she gave three reasons and implied a fourth. A destabilizing force would jeopardize progress in Tunisia and Egypt; a humanitarian disaster was imminent unless prevented; Qaddafi could not flout international law without consequences. The fourth: there’s a line now, and one that others countries had better not cross.
The development of a new doctrine in the Middle East is taking form, and it could become a paradigm for how the international community deals with unrest across the region from now on. The new elements include the direct participation of the Arab world, the visible participation of U.S. allies, as well as a very specific set of military targets designed to forestall needless human suffering. Though the Libyan situation is quite unique - its military is nowhere near as strong as Iran’s is, for one thing – Obama hopes that a short, surgical, non-US-led campaign with no ground troops will satisfy Americans skeptical about military intervention and will not arouse the suspicions of Arabs and Muslims that the U.S. is attempting to influence indigenously growing democracies.

Congress Not Eager to Assert Power of Purse in Libya Operations



War costs could mean new cuts elsewhere.

Tuesday, March 22, 2011 | 4:00 p.m.
When President Obama proposed his 2012 budget, congressional Republicans were quick to criticize the spending increases included, even as they were busy hunting for cuts in 2011. But when the president ordered the U.S. military to intervene in Libya’s civil war, a decision that could end up costing billions, the congressional leadership from both parties had little to say about the expense, preferring to let Obama make the decisions.
While a recess week and fast-moving events are partially to blame for Hill inactivity, it’s a glaring example of the double standard between spending on defense and spending on anything else. Though legislators from both parties have complained about the administration’s process in reaching decisions and lack of a clear endgame, there is no clear consensus on what, if anything, Congress will do to use its power of the purse to limit the Libya campaign.
The challenge is made especially difficult by the tensions, familiar to anti-war Democrats, between supporting troops in the field while disagreeing with policy decisions made in Washington.
“Our beef is with the president, not the troops,” said Rep. Jason Chaffetz, R-Utah, a member of the House Budget Committee. “I think Americans will pay any price to secure our homeland, but I see no clear and present danger in Libya. In this case, I do think that the finances become an issue.”
The Department of Defense said it is funding its operations in Libya from existing 2011 appropriations, and the White House Office of Management and Budget said that the administration is not currently planning to request supplemental funding.
“You have never had a decent oversight of the executive branch when it came to military spending or military initiatives, certainly in the 40 years that I was in Congress,” said former House Appropriations Chairman David Obey, D-Wisc., who retired last year. “The administration is in danger of seeing the Congress just sort of say, 'Well, another war, we’ve already got two of them going on, this is just the last straw.'”
Sen. Richard Lugar, R-Ind., the ranking member on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, who has been a key ally for President Obama on many issues, has been among the most outspoken critics of the conflict.
“We argue over where to cut $100 million here and there from programs many people like,” Lugar said in a statement on Monday. “So here comes an open-ended military action with no endgame envisioned. The facts are that our budget is stretched too far and our troops are stretched too far.”
Committee leadership at the House and Senate Appropriations and Budget committees have not weighed in on how the conflict’s cost -- as yet undefined, but estimated to be at least $1 billion -- could affect a final deal for spending in 2011 or the 2012 budget request. If sorties continue, the operation could take a serious chunk out of the approximately $8 billion in budget cuts House Republicans have managed to enact so far.
House Republicans did not propose cutting military funding in their 2011 spending bill, though it consumes about a fifth of government spending. Many fiscal experts, and a growing number of defense scholars, are questioning the traditional leniency Congress allows the Pentagon.
"Discretionary spending is discretionary spending, and it's all fungible,” said Andrew Exum, a fellow at the Center for a New American Security. Exum's blog notes that the initial missile assault on Libya cost roughly twice as much as the budget for the United States Institute of Peace and 33 times as much as public funding for National Public Radio -- two programs targeted for elimination by House Republicans.
Though Congress must approve military action within 60 days under the War Powers Resolution, political science professor Andrew Rudalevige of Dickinson College argues that Obama’s advisory to Congress did not trigger the WPR’s “clock,” which means legislators may have to start it themselves with a concurrent resolution. Given the administration’s promises to wind down the U.S. role in the conflict within days, that may be too little, too late.
Regardless, the bills will still need to be paid.
“It’s going to cost, money that will have to be borrowed, and the way the House is plunging along these days, there’s no doubt in my mind it will be paid for by additional squeezes on domestic activities that we can ill-afford to squeeze,” Obey said.
Though Obey was joined by the late Rep. Jack Murtha, D-Pa., in advocating a war surtax to fund conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq, there is even less appetite for tax increases in the current Congress, and the costs of the war will likely come from cuts to other programs.

The Case for Asking Congress on Libya


Seeking approval for the Libyan intervention would be good for the war effort, the nation, and Obama.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011 | 9:40 a.m.
ALEX WONG/GETTY IMAGES
President Obama speaks to both houses of Congress during his first State of the Union address on January 27, 2010.

The constitutional question in Washington is whether President Obama is required to get Congressional authorization for America's participation in the European intervention in Libya. As usual, it's the wrong question, in part because it has no clear answer and in part because there's a better question:
Why in heaven's name wouldn't he seek authorization?  Doing so would be good for the war effort, good for the nation, and good for Barack Obama.

It's customary at moments like this to hear constitutional literalists proclaiming that any military action requires Congress to "declare war." Rep. Dennis Kucinich, D-Ohio, laid out this line of thought in a statement Friday:
"Congress should be called back into session immediately to decide whether or not to authorize the United States' participation in a military strike. If it does not, the action of the President is contrary to the U.S. Constitution. Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution clearly states that the United States Congress has the power to declare war. The President does not. That was the Founders' intent."
Many of the same people insist that both Gulf Wars and the war in Afghanistan are also illegal, since they weren't precedent by a certified "Declaration of War." The problem with this argument is two-fold.  First, the action in Libya is not an all-out "war" between nation-states. And anyway, the legal term "declare war" is obsolete today -- indeed, as Alexander Hamilton noted in Federalist Number 25, it had begun to wane after the Peace of Paris in 1763.  Since the Kellogg-Briand Pact of 1928, nation-states have agreed not to use offensive or aggressive war as "an instrument of national policy" to settle international disputes -- meaning that we don't haul off and "declare war" on another country even if we are really cheesed at them.
The United Nations Charter built on that norm; today, nations derive legal authority to use armed force from the Security Council. That the United States has done. A document called "declaration of war" would be at best supererogatory and at worst silly. That's not to argue (as John Yoo did in 2001) that Congress has no role in authorizing force; it does. But it does mean that "declare war" is not a magic incantation that must be said before the missiles fly.

The second problem is that it's not clear the Constitution invariably requires authorization for use of force before the conflict begins. The level-headed Jack Goldsmith, former head of the Office of Legal Counsel under George W. Bush, lays out the uncertainty about what the dueling clauses (president as "commander in chief" v. Congress as body to "declare war") have come to mean in historical practice. Ever since Jefferson confronted the Barbary Pirates in 1801, when confronted with an emergency military situation, presidents who have taken emergency action asked Congress for authorization after the fact. Congress ratified that procedure by passing the War Powers Resolution of 1973, which implicitly recognizes situations in which the president may introduce U.S. forces into hostilities and then report to Congress within 48 hours. 

Obama can claim the legal authority to enforce the UN Security Council Resolution and cut Congress out of the discussion altogether, if he chooses.  But the wisest course for Obama would be to report to Congress under the War Powers Resolution and then ask for a formal resolution authorizing continued operation in Libya.  

Doing that would be both good constitutional stewardship and good constitutional politics. The two aren't as distinct as they might seem. If the Constitution is primarily a set of rules for carrying on politics in a self-governing republic, it makes sense that acting in the spirit of the document would often be politically wise. The president who most prominently relied on UN authorization was Harry Truman in 1950, who disdained congressional authorization and suffered political collapse when the war went south.

Obama could ask Capitol Hill to put up or shut up. The Republican critique of his actions so far seems to be that (1) he hasn't acted strongly enough, and (3) is reckless for acting at all. A debate on an authorization resolution would require them to pick one and stick with it. Democrats of the Kucinich stripe complain that any new military engagement in the Middle East is a potential quagmire. Debate on an authorization resolution might force them to debate whether the U.S. should allow the pro-democracy rebels in Libya to be exterminated.

The prospect that Congress would disapprove of military action -- ("All members who volunteer for attack ads saying VOTED TO SUPPORT MOAMMAR QADDAFI, don't raise your hands!") -- is practically nil. Obama, Congress, and the nation would gain from an authorization debate. The administration has yet to articulate its military aims and its criteria for success. If a congressional debate pushed them to sharpen their rationale for war, that might make it easier to conclude Barbary War III than if -- like George W. Bush in Iraq -- Obama rushes into battle unclear on whether we are after a cease-fire, a civil war between Libyan forces, or regime change.

After a congressional vote, Libya would no longer be "Obama's War," but a national endeavor. Beyond that, it could actually help heal our hideously broken Congress. Treating the new Congress like a serious legislative body might -- just might -- impel its members to act like statesmen.  And if not -- if the body went into filibuster-and-impeachment gridlock -- it would permit Obama to argue, correctly, that someone must act in America's interests in an international emergency.
Over the weekend, House Speaker John Boehner said:
"The United States has a moral obligation to stand with those who seek freedom from oppression and self-government for their people. It's unacceptable and outrageous for [Qaddafi] to attack his own people, and the violence must stop. The president is the commander-in-chief, but the administration has a responsibility to define for the American people, the Congress, and our troops what the mission in Libya is, better explain what America's role is in achieving that mission, and make clear how it will be accomplished. Before any further military commitments are made, the administration must do a better job of communicating to the American people and to Congress about our mission in Libya and how it will be achieved."
For Boehner the statesman, this was the right thing to say. But as a partisan figure, Boehner might prefer Obama to disobey. The Constitution gives the president most of the cards in the game of war and peace. It's hard to understand why Obama wouldn't want to play them.

Western Satellites Track Libyan Mustard Agent



This article originally appeared in Global Security Newswire,  produced independently by National Journal Group under contract with the Nuclear Threat Initiative, a nonprofit, nonpartisan group whose mission is preventing the spread of nuclear, biological and chemical weapons.

Tuesday, March 22, 2011 | 12:31 p.m.
Western spy satellites have been monitoring an isolated site in the Libyan desert where the Qadhafi government has stored its remaining stockpile of mustard blister agent in six large containers. No unusual activity has yet been spotted at the garage site, the Washington Post reported on Saturday (see GSN, March 14).
Western leaders continue to be concerned about the possibility that besieged Libyan dictator Muammar Qadhafi could attempt to use his remaining cache of chemical warfare materials against opposition forces. U.S. forces took a lead role over the weekend in international efforts to impose a no-fly zone over Libya and to halt attacks by Qadhafi loyalists on civilians and opposition fighters. President Obama, however, said no U.S. soldiers would be deployed on the ground.
Qadhafi's regime is estimated to possess 9.5 metric tons of mustard blister agent and a quantity of chemical warfare precursor materials that have yet to be eliminated as mandated by the Chemical Weapons Convention. Thousands of empty aerial munitions were previously destroyed, eliminating Qadhafi's ability to wage a chemical air attack.
Blister agent disposal work was broken off last month, ostensibly due to technical problems with the heating system of a chemical neutralization plant housed next to the garage. Two international monitors observing the disarmament operations left the site, as their presence was only called for during active destruction operations (see GSN, Feb. 2). Popular protests against the Qadhafi regime broke out shortly afterwards.
Tripoli's envoy to the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons recently told OPCW chief Ahmet Üzümcü that the mustard agent was still secure and that Qadhafi remained in adherence to the CWC treaty, according to previous reports.
While U.S. officials say it would be difficult for Qadhafi to militarize the mustard agent for use in a strike should he decide to do so, some European leaders have voiced worries that the longtime Libyan strongman could attempt to use the deadly chemicals in a last-ditch effort to remain in power.
"There are lots of rational reasons why Qadhafi could decide not to use them -- not the least of which is the absence of a reliable and safe delivery method -- but we all know that rational decision-making is not always the hallmark of dictators," a U.S. official said. "It will come down to a decision by one man on how to proceed."
Tripoli's ex-envoy to the United Nations, Abdurrahman Mohamed Shalgham, who publicly broke from Qadhafi in February, said earlier this month that "I do expect that he's going to attack [rebel stronghold] Benghazi with chemical weapons," if loyalist forces reach the city.
French President Nicolas Sarkozy threatened that his country would carry out "targeted" responses against Qadhafi's forces should he attempt to use the mustard agent. The United Kingdom has also warned of harsh reprisals against any possible chemical attack.
The mustard storage site is protected by a barbed wire fence, a berm and a small-size security force, according to sources who have viewed photographs of the site. Roughly 20 percent of the remaining blister agent has gelled over time, making the chemical difficult to deploy, according to diplomats and Western officials. The remaining material is in liquid form that theoretically could be sprayed from helicopters or airplanes -- a highly risky endeavor for the air crew that could prove lethal on the ground only if the toxin did not freeze beforehand.
"It would be little more than a terror weapon, with localized effects, and no particular military significance," chemical weapons expert Jonathan Tucker said.
Tripoli's other weapons of mass destruction efforts -- a drive to build a nuclear warhead and a missile program that included a cache of Scud missiles with the ability to strike neighboring nations -- were halted years earlier and the delivery vehicles surrendered to the United States in 2004 (see GSN, March 1).
"You can't say that what's left there is ash and trash, but pretty close," former Bush administration disarmament specialist Paula DeSutter said.
Some U.S. officials still disagree over the possibility that Qadhafi could have retained some undeclared WMD materials, such as infectious pathogens or nerve agents that he might seek to use in a final bid to stave off the toppling of his regime.
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton hinted at the possibility in remarks made to House of Representatives lawmakers earlier this month: "[Qadhafi] still does, as you probably know, have some remaining chemical weapons and some other nasty stuff that we're concerned about" (Jeffrey Smith, Washington Post, March 19).
Joint Chiefs of Staff chairman Adm. Michael Mullen on Sunday said Qadhafi's remaining mustard agent was "something he could do a lot of damage with," Agence France-Presse reported.
"It's something we're watching very closely," Mullen said in an interview with CBS of the possibility that Qadhafi might try to deploy the chemical toxins (Agence France-Presse/Univision.com, March 20).

Five Days into Operation Odyssey Dawn, Costs Mounting


The Libya operation could cost billions -- and require the Pentagon to request emergency funding from Congress.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011 | 1:35 p.m.
A US Navy F-16 fighter jet based at Sigonella airbase on the Italian island of Sicily takes off on March 21, 2011 to take part in operations in Libya.



U.S. officials said on Wednesday that coalition forces have suppressed Muammar el-Qaddafi’s air defenses, but his ground forces continue to target population centers in Libya, feeding concerns that the operation could ultimately cost the United States billions -- and require the Pentagon to request emergency funding from Congress to pay for it.
Five days into Operation Odyssey Dawn, the bill racked up by the U.S. alone is undoubtedly already in the hundreds of millions of dollars. And the U.S. military, which remains in the lead now, will continue to pump millions more into strikes targeting military assets in Libya.
The cost of war is often as unpredictable as war itself -- a lesson the U.S. military learned the hard way on Monday when it lost its first major piece of equipment, an F-15 fighter aircraft that crashed because of a mechanical failure.
After nearly a decade at war, the Pentagon has routinely leveraged emergency funding to replace older fighters lost in battle with fifth-generation stealth aircraft. And, if the Libya operation is no exception, the Defense Department could seek to buy an extra F-35 -- with a price tag of more than $100 million -- to replace the downed F-15. 
The ultimate total the United States spends will hinge on the length and scope of the strikes as well as on the contributions of coalition allies. But Todd Harrison, a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments, said the U.S. costs could “easily pass the $1 billion mark on this operation, regardless of how well things go.”
The Pentagon has the money in its budget to cover unexpected contingencies and can also use fourth-quarter dollars to cover the costs of operations now. “They’re very used to doing this operation where they borrow from Peter to pay Paul,” said Gordon Adams, who served as the Office of Management and Budget’s associate director for national security during the Clinton administration.
However, there comes a point when there simply isn’t enough cash to pay for everything. The White House said this week it was not prepared to request emergency funding yet, but former Pentagon comptroller Dov Zakheim estimated the Defense Department would need to send a request for supplemental funding to Capitol Hill if the U.S. military’s share of Libya operations expenses tops $1 billion.
Such a request would likely be met with mixed reactions in a Congress focused on deficit reduction. And while many key lawmakers have been agitating for action in Libya, others have been more reluctant and have increasingly raised concerns about the mounting costs.
Senate Foreign Relations ranking member Richard Lugar, R-Ind., argued that Congress should have had the opportunity to weigh in on what he has warned will be a very expensive operation. U.S. budget dollars -- not to mention heavily deployed troops -- are simply spread too thin, he says.
“Congress has been squabbling for months over a budget to run the federal government for a fiscal year that is almost half over,” Lugar said. “We argue over where to cut $100,000 million here and there from programs many people like. So here comes an open-ended military action with no-end game envisioned.”
So far, the operation has focused on creating a limited no-fly zone mostly targeting the capital city of Tripoli, which is Qaddafi’s stronghold, and other areas along the coast. That will require a wide range of military assets. 
In a report released earlier this month, Harrison estimated that the initial stages of taking out Qaddafi’s coastal air defenses would cost between $400 million and $800 million. But the coalition is now targeting his ground forces in an effort to protect civilians -- a factor that Harrison said will drive up the initial costs of the operation. 
“At some point, though, we will have degraded his forces to the point that there are not that many targets left,” Harrison said on Monday. “So we’d expect to see the sortie rate start to drop off.”
Meanwhile, Harrison estimated that maintaining a coastal no-fly zone after those initial strikes would cost in the range of $30 million to $100 million per week.
As Lugar and others have stressed, these unanticipated costs come at a time when the Pentagon is putting pressure on Capitol Hill to pass its fiscal 2011 budget. Continuing to operate under a stopgap continuing resolution through September, senior Defense officials argue, would amount to a $23 billion cut to the military’s request for the current fiscal year, which began on October 1. The Pentagon wants $708.3 billion for this year, including $159.3 billion for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
For the U.S. military, the highest costs of the operations over Libya come in the form of munitions, fuel for aircraft, and combat pay for deployed troops -- all factors that will pile up each day U.S. forces remain at the helm of the operation.
By late Tuesday, U.S.-led forces launched 162 long-range Tomahawk cruise missiles, which cost about $1 million to $1.5 million apiece, from ships stationed off the Libyan coast. The total to replace those missiles comes to between $162 million and $243 million. It is unclear how many of those Tomahawks came from the U.S. inventory, but it is believed the vast majority did.
The Defense Department typically buys about 200 Tomahawks a year. While the military likely can put off buying new missiles for months, it will ultimately need to boost planned procurement rates to refill its stockpile.
Defense budget watchers said the deployment of guided missile destroyers and submarines would not put a major dent in the Pentagon’s accounts because the ships were already deployed to the region. But the U.S. military has tapped its B-2 bombers as well as F-15 and F-16 fighter jets to strike a number of targets, undoubtedly forcing an immediate uptick in the military’s operations and maintenance expenditures, including fuel costs.
The military flew the three bombers deployed for the mission from Missouri’s Whiteman Air Force Base, a nearly 12,000-mile round trip that will incur significant fuel and maintenance costs, Harrison said.
Meanwhile, it generally costs $10,000 per hour, including maintenance and fuel, to operate F-15s and F-16s. Those costs do not include the payloads dropped from the aircraft. The B-2s dropped 45 Joint Direct Attack Munitions, or JDAMS, which are 2,000-pound bombs that cost between $30,000 and $40,000 apiece to replace.
Army Gen. Carter Ham, the Odyssey Dawn operational commander, said allies are stepping up to shoulder much of the mission. But it appears the United States is still flying the majority of sorties. Between Tuesday and Wednesday morning, the U.S. aircraft flew 113 sorties, while coalition aircraft logged 63.
But Rear Adm. Gerard Hueber, the operation’s chief of staff, stressed on Wednesday that coalition participation has increased dramatically from just 15 percent of sorties three days ago.
On the personnel front, special pay for soldiers involved in the operation will kick in immediately -- unlike the munitions costs, which the Pentagon can defer.
A week long operation involving a limited number of U.S. troops would be manageable within the existing defense budget. But if it drags on for weeks and months, the Pentagon would likely have to do some maneuvering.
Complicating matters is the fact that most of the coalition nations’ militaries, which operate on a fraction of the Pentagon’s yearly allowance, are grappling with budget pressures of their own. While the Defense Department hopes to transfer control to coalition partners in the coming days, the longer the operations over Libya continue, the more difficult it will be for allies to take the lead.
“If it goes on more than a month, we’re going to be in the forefront [of operations] or we’re going to let Qaddafi stick around,” predicted former Defense comptroller Zakheim, who served under President George W. Bush. “The choices aren’t very pleasant.”