Pages

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Photos From the Protests in Egypt

127 photos that are thought provoking, emotional, and very telling of a people wanting change in their government and their country......

White House, Egypt Discuss Plan for Mubarak’s Exit

February 3, 2011


WASHINGTON — The Obama administration is discussing with Egyptian officials a proposal for President Hosni Mubarak to resign immediately, turning over power to a transitional government headed by Vice President Omar Suleiman with the support of the Egyptian military, administration officials and Arab diplomats said Thursday.
Even though Mr. Mubarak has balked, so far, at leaving now, officials from both governments are continuing talks about a plan in which Mr. Suleiman, backed by Lt. Gen. Sami Enan, chief of the Egyptian armed forces, and Field Marshal Mohamed Tantawi, the defense minister, would immediately begin a process of constitutional reform.
The proposal also calls for the transitional government to invite members from a broad range of opposition groups, including the banned Muslim Brotherhood, to begin work to open up the country’s electoral system in an effort to bring about free and fair elections in September, the officials said.
Senior administration officials said that the proposal was one of several options under discussion with high-level Egyptian officials around Mr. Mubarak in an effort to persuade the president to step down now.
They cautioned that the outcome depended on several factors, not least Egypt’s own constitutional protocols and the mood of the protesters on the streets of Cairo and other Egyptian cities.
Some officials said there was not yet any indication that either Mr. Suleiman or the Egyptian military was willing to abandon Mr. Mubarak.
Even as the Obama administration is coalescing around a Mubarak-must-go-now posture in private conversations with Egyptian officials, Mr. Mubarak himself remains determined to stay until the election in September, American and Egyptian officials said. His backers forcibly pushed back on Thursday against what they viewed as American interference in Egypt’s internal affairs.
“What they’re asking cannot be done,” one senior Egyptian official said, citing clauses in the Egyptian Constitution that bar the vice president from assuming power. Under the Constitution, the speaker of Parliament would succeed the president. “That’s my technical answer,” the official added. “My political answer is they should mind their own business.”
Mr. Mubarak’s insistence on staying will again be tested by large street protests on Friday, which the demonstrators are calling his “day of departure,” when they plan to march on the presidential palace. The military’s pledge not to fire on the Egyptian people will be tested as well.
The discussions about finding a way out of the crisis in Cairo take place as new questions are being raised about whether American intelligence agencies, after the collapse of the Tunisian government, adequately warned the White House and top lawmakers about the prospects of an uprising in Egypt.
During a Senate hearing on Thursday, both Democrats and Republicans pressed a senior Central Intelligence Agency official about when the C.I.A. and other agencies notified President Obama of the looming crisis, and whether intelligence officers even monitored social networking sites and Internet forums to gauge popular sentiment in Egypt.
“At some point it had to have been obvious that there was going to be a huge demonstration,” said Senator Dianne Feinstein, the California Democrat who is chairwoman of the Senate’s Select Committee on Intelligence.
She said that intelligence agencies never sent a notice to her committee about the growing uprising in Egypt, as is customary in the case of significant global events.
Stephanie O’Sullivan, the C.I.A. official, responded that the agency had been tracking instability in Egypt for some time and had concluded that the government in Cairo was in an “untenable” situation. But, Ms. O’Sullivan said, “we didn’t know what the triggering mechanism would be.”
Because of the fervor now unleashed in Egypt, one Obama administration official said, Mr. Mubarak’s close aides expressed concern that they were not convinced that Mr. Mubarak’s resignation would satisfy the protesters.
In an interview with Christiane Amanpour of ABC News, Mr. Mubarak said that he was “fed up” with being president but that he could not step down for fear of sowing chaos in the country.
“The worry on Mubarak’s part is that if he says yes to this, there will be more demands,” said Leslie H. Gelb, president emeritus of the Council on Foreign Relations. “And since he’s not dealing with a legal entity, but a mob, how does he know there won’t be more demands tomorrow?”
A number of high-level American officials have reached out to the Egyptians in recent days. While administration officials would not offer details of the alternatives that were being discussed, they made it clear that their preferred outcome would be for Mr. Suleiman to take power as a transitional figure.
Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. spoke by phone to Mr. Suleiman on Thursday, the White House said in a statement, urging that “credible, inclusive negotiations begin immediately in order for Egypt to transition to a democratic government that addresses the aspirations of the Egyptian people.”
Mr. Biden’s phone call came after a mission by Mr. Obama’s private emissary, Frank G. Wisner, was abruptly ended when Mr. Mubarak, angry at Mr. Obama’s toughly worded speech on Tuesday night, declined to meet with the envoy a second time, officials said.
Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates has made three calls since the weekend to Egypt’s powerful defense minister, Field Marshal Tantawi, who served on the coalition’s side in the Persian Gulf war of 1991.
Pentagon officials declined on Thursday to describe the specifics of the calls but indicated that Mr. Gates’s messages were focused on more than urging the Egyptian military to exercise restraint.
Officials familiar with the dialogue between the Obama administration and Cairo say that American officials have told their Egyptian counterparts that if they support another strongman to replace Mr. Mubarak — but without a specific plan and timetable for moving toward democratic elections — Congress might react by freezing military aid to Egypt.
On Thursday, the Senate passed a resolution calling on Mr. Mubarak to begin the transfer of power to an “inclusive, interim caretaker government.”
Anthony H. Cordesman, an expert on the Egyptian military at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, said that a transition government led by Mr. Suleiman and the military, with pledges to move toward democratic elections, was in his mind “the most probable case.” But he said the administration had to proceed with extreme caution.
“Everybody working this issue knows that this is a military extremely sensitive to outside pressure,” Mr. Cordesman said.
Even as the Obama administration has ratcheted up the pressure on Egypt, it has reaffirmed its support for other Arab allies facing popular unrest.
The White House released a statement saying that Mr. Obama called President Ali Abdullah Saleh of Yemen on Wednesday to welcome Mr. Saleh’s recent “reform measures” — the Yemeni president promised not to run again in 2013.
And on Thursday, Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton called King Abdullah II of Jordan to say that the United States looked forward to working with his new cabinet — recently announced — and to underline the importance of the relationship between Jordan and the United States.
Philip J. Crowley, the State Department spokesman, declined to say whether Mrs. Clinton had enlisted King Abdullah in an effort to ease out Mr. Mubarak. But Mr. Crowley praised the king for responding to the unrest in Jordan.
“He’s doing his best to respond to this growing aspiration,” Mr. Crowley said. “And we appreciate the leadership he’s shown.”
Elisabeth Bumiller, Mark Mazzetti and Thom Shanker contributed reporting.


Stephen Crowley/The New York Times
President Barack Obama on Thursday. The White House is in discussions to find a way out of the crisis in Cairo.

I bet the "Chaos in Cairo" will give this dumb song some life:

Steve Martin - King Tut (Live 1979)

Republicans Say Everything the Dems Pass Is Unconstitutional -- Even Policies They've Championed for Decades

 TEA PARTY AND THE RIGHT




By Joshua Holland, AlterNet



Posted on January 28, 2011, Printed on February 3, 2011
http://www.alternet.org/story/149705/
That Republicans are relentlessly attacking the constitutionality of what had long been one of their signature ideas for reforming the health-care system -- the individual mandate requiring people to buy insurance or pay a penalty – is a testament to just how far down the rabbit-hole our discourse has gone.
Late last year, when a federal judge ruled against the mandate (two other courts disagreed, and the Supreme Court will end up deciding the question), Senator Orrin Hatch, R-Utah,rejoiced. "Today is a great day for liberty," he said. "Congress must obey the Constitution rather than make it up as we go along.” It was an odd testament to freedom, given that Hatch himself co-sponsored a health-care reform bill built around an individual mandate in the late 1990s.
Journalist Steve Benen noted that while “the record here may be inconvenient for the right ... it's also unambiguous: the mandate Republicans currently hate was their idea.”
It was championed by the Heritage Foundation... Nixon embraced it in the 1970s, and George H.W. Bush kept it going in the 1980s. For years, it was touted by the likes of John McCain, Mitt Romney, Scott Brown, Chuck Grassley, Bob Bennett, Tommy Thompson, Lamar Alexander, Lindsey Graham, John Thune, Judd Gregg, and many other ... notable GOP officials.
According to NPR, the mandate was the Right's response to progressive proposals to establish a single-payer system. Mark Pauly, the conservative economist widely credited with the idea, explained that "a group of economists and health policy people, market-oriented, sat down and said, 'Let's see if we can come up with a health reform proposal that would preserve a role for markets but would also achieve universal coverage.'"
That was then, this is now. Since it was a Democratic Congress that enacted the mandate, this conservative idea for creating a business-friendly model of universal health care has become something profoundly un-American, according to many of those very same Republicans who championed it. (Asked about the GOP's retreat from the individual mandate it had long promoted, Pauly said, "That's not something that makes me particularly happy.")
And as is generally the case in these heady days of Tea Party conservatism, it's not just that the individual mandate is bad – it's also “un-Constitutional” (just like child labor laws, federal disaster assistance, food safety standards, etc.). As Gary Epps, a legal scholar at the University of Baltimore, put it, "Conservative lawmakers increasingly claim that the 'original intent' of the Constitution's framers and the views of the right wing of the Republican Party are one and the same."
A brief filed in support of Virginia's challenge to the Affordable Care Act by the Landmark Legal Foundation – headed by noted wing-nut radio host Mark Levin, who believes that the Tea Partiers have been "tormented and abused far more than the colonists were by the King of England" – laid out the argument, calling the erstwhile Republican approach to universal health care “evidence of congressional power run amok.”
Congress can tax interstate commerce, it can regulate interstate commerce, it can even prohibit certain types of interstate commerce, but it cannot compel an individual to enter into a legally binding private contract against the individual’s will and interests. There is nothing in the history of this nation, let alone the history of the Constitution ... that endorses such a radical departure from precedent, law, and logic.
Like most of the Right's views of the Constitution – and the Founders' intent – this is entirely wrong; it's historical revisionism driven by ideology.
In 1792, none other than George Washington signed the Uniform Militia Act, a law requiring every white male citizen to purchase a whole basket of items – “a good musket or firelock, a sufficient bayonet and belt, two spare flints, and a knapsack, a pouch, with a box therein” – from private companies. Bradley Latino at Seton Hall law school's Health Reform Watch added that “this was no small thing.”
Although anywhere from 40 to 79% of American households owned a firearm of some kind, the Militia Act specifically required a military-grade musket.  That particular kind of gun was useful for traditional, line-up-and-shoot 18th-century warfare, but clumsy and inaccurate compared to the single-barrel shotguns and rifles Americans were using to hunt game. A new musket, alone, could cost anywhere from $250 to $500 in today’s money.  Some congressmen estimated it would cost £20 to completely outfit a man for militia service -- about $2,000 today.
Some on the Right have argued that this history is irrelevant as the law was passed under the auspices of the Constitution's militia clauses, not the Commerce Clause. That's true, but doesn't change the fact that it disproves the claim that Congress has never compelled citizens to purchase goods or services from private firms – that's patently false, regardless of how the measures differed in their details.
And despite the fact that there were a number of legislators serving in that Congress who had signed the Constitution five years earlier, “not one of militia reform’s many opponents thought to argue the mandate was a government taking of property for public use. Nor did anyone argue it to be contrary to States’ rights under the Tenth Amendment.” Those who opposed the bill simply argued that it would put too great a burden on the poor.
Of course, mandating that citizens buy a gun is different than requiring them to purchase health insurance. But as Rick Ungar, an attorney and writer, pointed out, Congress did in fact pass a mandate requiring health insurance...back in 1798.
The Act for Sick and Disabled Seamen created a government-operated hospital system – socialized medicine! – and mandated that all privately employed sailors purchase health insurance in order to sail.
It's not an exact parallel. Nobody was forced to become a merchant seaman. But as Ungar noted, “this is no different than what we are looking at today. Each of us has the option to turn down employment that would require us to purchase private health insurance under the health care reform law.”
The Act also required sea captains to withhold 1 percent of sailors' earnings to finance the program rather then mandate that they purchase a policy themselves – it was the first payroll tax. But as Ezra Klein noted in the Washington Post, “if conservatives really do prefer a system of payroll taxes that purchase you public insurance to the private system envisioned in the Affordable Care Act, I'm sure there are a lot of liberals who would vote for a bill that repealed the Affordable Care Act and replaced it with Medicare-for-all.”
It's an important point – the liberal approach to universal health care is not only simpler and far more cost-effective, but unlike the Right's individual mandate, it also falls unambiguously within the federal government's enumerated powers.
Health care is also, in the words of the Congressional Research Service, “a unique market” in that one cannot opt out of it even if one wishes to do so. That's because, by law, we don't allow people to simply die in the streets, untreated. The uninsured without the means to pay nonetheless get (very costly) care in emergency rooms, and the rest of us pick up the tab.
And here, again, it's worth noting that “the 5th Congress did not really need to struggle over the intentions of the drafters of the Constitutions in creating this Act as many of its members were the drafters of the Constitution.” The bill was signed into law by none other than John Adams, considered to be among the most influential of the “Founding Fathers.” Thomas Jefferson was the president of the Senate at the time, and Jonathan Dayton, the youngest man to sign the Constitution, served as Speaker of the House.
As the current legislation stands, even the American Enterprise Institute concedes that “the majority of constitutional experts are betting that the courts will uphold the mandate” – although they're not happy about it. And that's because the other Constitutional arguments against the reforms are just as dubious. Conservatives have come to use the Constitution as a crutch, avoiding debates on the merits of various proposals by asserting, with a broad wave of the hand, that whatever the policy in question may be, it's all illegitimate.
The constitutionality of the health-care mandate will ultimately be decided by an activist majority on the Supreme Court. Nobody can predict how it will rule, but the Constitution gives the Congress power to “to lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises ... and provide for the common Defense and general Welfare of the United States,” a power the Congressional Research Service characterizes as ”one of the broadest powers in the Constitution,” and one that forms “the basis of government health programs in the Social Security Act, including Medicare, Medicaid, and the State Children’s Health Insurance Program.”
The Supreme Court has interpreted the Commerce Clause as giving the government the authority to regulate not only interstate commercial transactions in a limited sense, but also “those activities having a substantial relation to interstate commerce.” (Our health-care system is the costliest in the world, and eats up about 18 percent of our economic output, so it's hard to see how one can argue that it doesn't have a “substantial relation” to our national economy.)
Then there's the common conservative argument that the Commerce Clause only covers economic activity, but not inactivity – a claim that is also factually incorrect, but was nonetheless accepted by Henry Hudson, the federal judge who ruled against the government in the Virginia suit. But even if it were true, it's hard to see the relevance of the argument given the Constitution's Necessary and Proper clause, which authorizes the government to “make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers.”
So, to recap: Congress is expressly authorized to raise taxes and spend public funds to further the “general welfare” of the nation; it can regulate any area that has a “substantial relation” to interstate commerce, and it can pass any law that is “necessary and proper” to further those enumerated powers.
On its face, there's nothing in the Constitution constraining the government from enacting its health-care scheme. But the heart of conservative rhetoric these days is that any legislation passed by Democrats is illegitimate and defies the will of the Founders, as channeled by the mystics who lead the Tea Party movement.
That's apparently the case even when those policies are among those they've championed for years based on their own ideological preferences.

12 Examples of Stunning Hypocrisy from Tea Party Republicans In One Short Month

TEA PARTY AND THE RIGHT



By Joshua Holland, AlterNet



Posted on February 3, 2011, Printed on February 3, 2011
http://www.alternet.org/story/149776/

It's only been a month since the new Tea Party lawmakers took office, but the entirely predictable results of their ascension are already coming in. The Republican Party's newest class of “mavericks” have again stormed into office intent on proving their theory that government is inherently evil by screwing up everything in sight.
Before we embark on our tour of the Tea Party politicians' early moves – and those of the party they were supposed to be “taking back” -- let's recall exactly what they promised: they were relentlessly focused on economic issues – and, we were told, would eschew the kind of social issues that had long marked Republican politics in the era of the Religious Right. They would bring greater transparency and accountability to government. They promised to be good fiscal stewards, respond to the wishes of the people and, above all else, they swore up and down to obey the letter of the Constitution.
Let's see how they did in the early going.
I Hate Government Health Care. Also: Where Is My Government Health Care?
The hypocrisy began before the new class of pols was sworn in. When it was reportedthat “a conservative Maryland physician elected to Congress on an anti-Obamacare platform surprised fellow freshmen at an orientation session by demanding to know why his government-subsidized health care plan takes a month to kick in,” it raised eyebrows.

When Rep. Ron Paul, R-Texas, the titular inspiration for the Tea Party movement, wasasked if he thought it was hypocritical for members of Congress to accept government-subsidized and regulated health plans, he replied simply, “[c]ould be.”

Violating the Constitution on Day One
The Constitution is the answer to every policy debate for the conservative wing of the GOP – or at least their tenuous grasp of what it says. But they didn't take long to trash the document. As Ryan Grimm reported for the Huffington Post:
Two House Republicans have cast votes as members of the 112th Congress, but were not sworn in on Wednesday, a violation of the Constitution on the same day that the GOP had the document read from the podium.
As if that weren't enough, the two lawmakers, incumbent Pete Sessions, R-Texas, and newcomer Mike Fitzpatrick, R-Pennsylvania, couldn't make the swearing-in because “they were attending a fundraiser at the U.S. Capitol even though lawmakers are barred from using official resources for campaign or fundraising activities.” That's illegal, and they did it on day one!
And Their Own Rules
The new GOP majority in Congress was supposed to be different this time. Heavily influenced by the Tea Partiers' message, they promised greater transparency. “Leaders overreach because the rules allow them to,” said newly minted Speaker John Boehner in a speech to the American Enterprise Institute. “Legislators duck their responsibilities because the rules help them to. And when the rules don’t suit the majority’s purposes, they are just ignored.”
That was before he took the speaker's gavel, however. Later, as Politico reported, “the new majority is already showing these promises aren’t exactly set in stone.”
After calling for bills to go through a regular committee process, the bill that would repeal the health care law will not go through a single committee. Despite promising a more open amendment process for bills, amendments for the health care repeal will be all but shut down. After calling for a strict committee attendance list to be posted online, Republicans backpedaled and ditched that from the rules. They promised constitutional citations for every bill but have yet to add that language to early bills.
That was certainly fast. But as Boehner said, “when the rules don’t suit the majority’s purposes, they are just ignored.”
Cutting Your Grandparents' Medicare
In October, Politifact noted that “Republicans often complained the Democratic plan would cut Medicare” during the reform debate, and “they are now repeating those attacks in campaign ads against many Democratic candidates, targeting older voters who may be worried their Medicare benefits will be harmed.”
Rep. Jeb Hensarling, a Tea Party favorite from Texas, went so far as to suggest, in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, that “the left” wanted to “cut Medicare by $500 billion to finance a corner of ObamaCare.” Given that older voters tend to skew toward the GOP, this line of attack made sense for turning out the Republicans' base.
Yet just two short months after Hensarling wrote that op-ed, the National Journalreported, “House GOP members are considering a measure to convert the government-backed Medicare program into a voucher system,” which would represent a drastic benefit cut for seniors in years to come:
Republican Conference Chairman Jeb Hensarling of Texas said that he expects Republicans to support the provision, which would require Medicare to give seniors an allotment of money to buy private coverage starting in 2021. The eligibility age would also be raised, from 65 to 69.
Austerity for Thee; Lavish, Corporate-Sponsored Parties for Me!

They were going to represent “the people,” but one has to remember that, in the conservative worldview, big corporations are people too!

To be fair, corporate sponsors generally kick in dollars for new governors' electoral balls, but as Think Progress noted, some of the new Tea Party-backed governors took it to the extreme, allowing “corporations with a vested interest in policy outcomes from a friendly government to pay for their inaugural bashes.”
Florida Gov. Rick Scott (R-FL) spent $3 million in funds from Florida’s business interests that have “the most at stake in his administration,” including tobacco, real estate, gambling, and drug companies seeking specific regulatory advantages for their business. Gov. Nikki Haley (R-SC) also received a big inaugural bash courtesy of private donations from Boeing, Duke Energy, and SCANA. Several other Republican governors are following suit. According to local reports, Govs. Rick Perry (TX), John Kasich (OH), Brian Sandoval (NV), Mary Fallin (OK), and Rick Snyder (MI), are the newest state executives to join the pay-to-play club.
They're Not Just on Capitol Hill
Maine's new governor, Tea Party-favorite Paul LePage, promised his transition team would look for “the best and the brightest” as it “seeks people to fill key roles in what’s expected to be a pro-business administration,” reported the Associated Press. In the end, that included not only several conservative think-tankers, but also his 22-year-old daughter Lauren, to whom he gave “a staff position within the upper echelon of his administration.”
According to the Bangore Daily News, “Lauren LePage said that although she did not study politics in college, she enjoyed her work on the gubernatorial campaign and saw this as a unique opportunity.” While salaries in the current governor's office start at $30,000 per year, the recent college grad will be pulling down $41,000 under her father, who was elected promising to clean up Augusta.
Moonlighting
Scott Gessler was a Tea Party fave when he ran for the office of Colorado Secretary of State. “We need to trust our elected leaders,” he said on the trail. But soon after his election, Gessler gave voters reason to question whether he could be trusted when he announced that he would supplement his $68k annual salary by moonlighting with his old law firm on the side.
"To the extent he is working for his old firm and his old firm is dealing with the Secretary of State's office, it creates a real conflict," Elena Nuñez, program director for Colorado Common Cause, told the Denver Post. "In some cases it may just be the appearance of conflict."
What's more, Gessler refused to recuse the Secretary of State's office from cases involving his side job. “He said he would treat his old firm just like any other when it came to the decisions his office makes,” according to the Post.
Remember Transparency?
Tennessee governor Bill Haslam may win some kind of prize for hypocrisy.
On January 16, the Associated Press reported that Haslam had “stressed the themes of transparency, responsiveness and humility at his first full Cabinet meeting.”  But that statement came just 24 hours after he had signed an executive order eliminating “a requirement for the governor and top aides to disclose how much they earn.” The APnoted that “the move wipes off the books former Democratic Gov. Phil Bredesen’s first executive order of 2003, which required the top executive branch officials to make annual reports about their total earnings.” Haslam, it should be noted, had been “heavily criticized during the campaign for refusing to say how much he earned from family owned Pilot, a national truck stop chain with annual revenues of about $20 billion.”
Fiscal Insanity
I have always maintained that “limited government” is attractive as an abstract concept, but looks quite ugly in the real world. Evidence for that comes from Long Island, where a Tea Party-backed local pol has rapidly brought about financial disaster to Nassau County.Reuters explained the mess, which it called “a black eye for the Tea Party”:
At his January 2010 inauguration, Tea Party-backed Republican Edward Mangano marched up to the podium, pen in hand. Even before being officially declared Nassau County Executive, he signed a repeal of an unpopular home energy tax.
But Mangano didn't cut spending, nor did he figure out a way to make up the lost revenues, perhaps believing the conservative myth that cutting taxes leads to more tax dollars. The problem is that the belief is firmly grounded in magical thinking.
The fiscal consequences ...were anything but cool. The repeal set Mangano on an immediate collision course with the state-appointed fiscal overseer, the Nassau County Interim Financial Authority, or NIFA. It culminated in NIFA seizing control of the wealthy New York county's finances just weeks after the new County Supervisor was sworn in.
The tax had cost homeowners and average of around $7 per month – repealing it had truly been a triumph of ideology over common sense.
The Religious Right by Any Other Name ...
Last March, the New York Times reported that Tea Party leaders were “deliberately avoid[ing] discussion of issues like gay marriage or abortion.”
Tea Party leaders argue that the country can ill afford the discussion about social issues when it is passing on enormous debts to future generations. But the focus is also strategic: leaders think they can attract independent voters if they stay away from divisive issues.
In September, Rep. Mike Pence, R-Indiana – a Tea Party favorite – said that “putting our fiscal house in order, creating policies that will open the doors of opportunity to families during this difficult economy and create jobs has to be the first priority and I believe will be the first priority if Republicans are given another opportunity to lead.”
That lasted a total of 17 days after taking office. Then, Mike Pence's very first act in the new Congress was to offer legislation that would limit abortion services by redefining rapeto include only “forcible" rape. “We must not remain silent when great moral battles are being waged,” Pence said when he unveiled the bill. “Those who would have us ignore the battle being fought over life have forgotten the lessons of history. As in the days of a house divided, America's darkest moments have come when economic arguments trumped moral principles.”
Spitting on the Constitution
For a movement that pledges unwavering fealty to the Constitution, it's remarkable how many blatantly unconstitutional pieces of legislation these new firebrands are introducing.
The Iowa Tea Party is backing a “nullification” bill allowing the state to ignore federal laws, a direct violation of the Supremacy Clause. David Gray Adler, who directs the University of Idaho's McClure Center for Public Policy Research, told the Washington Post that “nullification proponents ignore the fact that one Supreme Court decision after another has gone against them.” The state's Republican Attorney General weighed in, stating the obvious: “There is no right to pick and choose which federal laws a State will follow,” which is why “no court has ever upheld a State effort to nullify a federal law.”
Jason Brodeur, a local Tea Party newcomer in Florida, also got into the act, offering a bill that would make it a crime – punishable by a hefty fine or even jail time – for a doctor to ask a patient whether there are guns in the patient's home. The constitutional problem seems obvious: it doesn't permit the government to limit a physician's free speech rights just because some lawmaker really, really likes guns. Or, as the Orlando Sentinel put it, the proposed law "protects the Second Amendment from the First."
Then there are various bills to strip citizenship from children born to undocumented immigrants. They're popular, but as the figurehead of the Tea Parties, Ron Paul, has long acknowledged, the only constitutional approach to the issue would be to lose or change the 14th Amendment. The provision has been tested in a series of Supreme Court cases, making it a “super-precedent.” Passing simple legislation to strip people of an established and tested right is unconstitutional.
Ethics, Ethics, Ethics
The new GOP caucus promised to restore the American people's confidence in their party after it had become tainted by its culture of corruption during the Bush years. During last year's campaign, Eric Cantor, R-Virginia, assured the public that the GOP would "institute a zero-tolerance policy" when it comes to lawmakers' transgressions.
Nice talk, but just a month after taking control of the lower house, a GOP freshman is already facing a serious ethics problem. As the Washington Monthly's Steve Benenreported, “not quite three weeks into the 112th Congress, a newly elected Republican congressman is facing a scandal so severe, the leadership is already preparing for his ouster.”
With Miami's David Rivera, it's not just one controversy, it's a series of head-shaking outrages that make one wonder what on earth voters in his district were thinking.
The most recent scandal is Rivera's inexplicable decision to try to cover up loans from his mother's gambling-related marketing company, a matter that's already under investigation by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. Indeed, it appears that the owners of a dog track made more than $500,000 in secret payments to a company Rivera owned.
The Republican congressman is also at the center of domestic violence allegations, has been accused of driving a truck off a road because it was carrying flyers from a rival campaign, hiding the finances surrounding foreclosure proceedings on a house he co-owned with Marco Rubio, and bizarre lies about nonexistent work he did for the U.S. Agency for International Development.
Benen added that despite “Cantor's promise of a 'zero-tolerance policy,' the House Majority Leader has refused to say a word about Rivera's multiple, ongoing scandals, or the criminal investigation.”
To be fair, Rivera is not a Tea Partier. But his corruption is so blatant, he deserves honorable mention here nonetheless. For more on Rivera's ethical and legal problems, seehere.

Joshua Holland is an editor and senior writer at AlterNet. He is the author of The 15 Biggest Lies About the Economy (and Everything else the Right Doesn't Want You to Know About Taxes, Jobs and Corporate America). Drop him an email or follow him on Twitter.

Senate probe faults Army, FBI for missing warning signs before Fort Hood attack





Victims, heroes remembered at Fort Hood

Family members of the 13 people killed one year ago during a shooting rampage at Fort Hood kneeled, cried and ran their hands across their loved one's names etched in a 6-foot-tall granite memorial. (Nov. 5) (The Associated Press)



By William Wan and Felicia Sonmez

Washington Post Staff Writers
Thursday, February 3, 2011; 6:40 PM 


A Senate investigation of the Fort Hood shootings faults the Army and FBI with missing warning signs and not exchanging information that could have prevented the massacre.
The report, released Thursday, concludes that systemic and cultural problems caused military officials to miss signs that the suspect, Maj. Nidal M. Hasan, was becoming increasingly radical before the 2009 attack.
It also concludes that the FBI did not share information with the Army - notably, e-mails that Hasan, an Army psychiatrist and practicing Muslim, exchanged with a "suspected terrorist," a likely reference to Anwar al-Aulaqi, an ic cleric known for his extremist views. The report says the agency may have dismissed such clues to avoid causing "a bureaucratic confrontation."
At a news conference Thursday, Sen. Joseph I. Lieberman (I-Conn.) said the investigation's "painful conclusion is that the Fort Hood massacre could have and should have been prevented."
In particular, Lieberman said the report, issued by the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, indicates that the FBI had compelling evidence of extremism that should have led to Hasan's military discharge and made him the subject of a counterterrorism investigation.
The Army and FBI said in separate statements that they have implemented numerous preventative steps since the shootings. The military, for example, has begun requiring troops to report behavior by fellow service members that might indicate extremism.
In its statement, the FBI said: "We agree that we need to accelerate our transformation, particularly given the growing complexity of the threats, but we are encouraged that the report validates the FBI's vision for being intelligence-led and threat-focused."
The report is the latest in a series of investigations - including one by the Pentagon and another by the FBI - of the Fort Hood shootings, which left 13 people dead.
The new Senate report highlights one contentious issue that has become a running debate throughout the various inquiries - whether the Fort Hood shootings were an act of terrorism and not related to the workplace.
The report by Lieberman and Sen. Susan M. Collins (R-Maine) said the Defense Department "still has not specifically named the threat represented by the Fort Hood attack as what it is: violent Islamist extremism."
Since the attack, defense officials have been careful not to cast the shootings as fueled only by Hasan's religion. Lieberman, chairman of the homeland security committee, and Collins, the ranking Republican on the panel, have long pointed to the Fort Hood shootings as evidence of wider systemic problems in the fight against domestic terrorism.
In their report, the senators argue that the Pentagon's avoidance of the "Islamist extremist" in the Fort Hood case underlines its failure to train troops to distinguish the peaceful practice of Islam from its extremist branches.
As proof, the Senate report points out an instance in which Hasan's higher-ups wrote his officer evaluation reports in a way that "sanitized his obsession with violent Islamist extremism into praiseworthy research on counterterrorism."
The argument reflects a larger political debate over how far authorities can and should go in combating homegrown terrorism.
Reached by phone Thursday in Texas, Rep. John Carter (R), whose district includes the Fort Hood base, said: "Political correctness has clearly become a part of the problem. We've become so careful about saying certain things that might hurt people's feelings that we don't recognize real threats."
Meanwhile, with Hasan's case still in the initial stages of the military judicial system, John Galligan, his attorney, reacted to the latest report with outrage, saying the FBI and the Pentagon continue supplying e-mails and personnel files for such investigations but have withheld them from Hasan's defense in the course of the legal discovery process.
"I'm not the least bit surprised by the remarks being made," Galligan said. "But what concerns me most is that all this stuff you're seeing in all these reports, I haven't seen a shred of it. I'm not properly prepared to defend my client."

CORNYN & HUTCHISON COMMEND BIPARTISAN REPORT ON FT. HOOD SHOOTINGS


Feb 03 2011

WASHINGTON – U.S. Senators John Cornyn (R-TX) and Kay Bailey Hutchison (R-TX) today released the following statements regarding the release of the bipartisan report by Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee Chairman Joe Lieberman (ID- CT) and Ranking Member Susan Collins (R-ME) on the failures of the U. S. government to prevent the November 5, 2009 shooting at the Fort Hood Army base:  
“This report makes clear that the FBI and the DoD, between them, had enough pieces of the puzzle to prevent Major Nidal Hasan from committing this atrocity, but failed to do so. It also confirms that military leaders failed to confront the threat of homegrown Islamic terrorism within their own ranks,”said Senator Cornyn. “We must never allow the safety of those who defend our freedom to play second fiddle to political correctness. It is unacceptable that the DoD and FBI failed so miserably to protect the brave Americans who were killed and wounded at Fort Hood that day and this report should serve as a call to action for Congress. The time for these reforms is now, before more innocent lives are taken. The Fort Hood community is still healing, but it is highly resilient and will continue to play a key role in ensuring our national security.”
“I commend the work of the committee to deepen our understanding of how the worst act of domestic terrorism since 9/11 unfolded. The report reveals what many of us feared – there were clear and troubling warning signs that were ignored.  We must learn from the violent attack at Fort Hood so we can prevent future tragedies,” said Senator Hutchison.

A Special Report by Joseph I. Lieberman, Chairman Susan M. Collins, Ranking Member

A TICKING TIME BOMB
COUNTERTERRORISM LESSONS FROM THE U.S. GOVERNMENT’S
FAILURE TO PREVENT THE FORT HOOD ATTACK

U.S. Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
Washington D.C. 20510
February 2011


This the executive summary 



On November 5,  2009, a  lone attacker strode  into  the deployment center at  Fort Hood, 
Texas.  Moments later,  13  Department of Defense (DoD) employees were dead and another 32 were wounded  in  the worst terrorist attack on U.S. soil  since September  I I, 200 I . 
The U.S.  Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmenta l Affairs launched 
an  investigation of the events preceding the attack wi th  two purposes:  (I) to assess the 
informat ion  that  the U.S. Government possessed prior to  the attack and  the actions that  it took or failed  to take  in  response to  that  infonnation; and (2)  to  ident ify  steps necessary to protect the United States against  future acts of terrorism by homegrown violent  Islami st extremists.  This investigation  flows  from the Committee's four-year, bipartisan review of the threat of violent Islamist extremism to our home land wh ich  has  included numerous bri efings, hearings, consultations,  and  the publicat ion of a staff report  in  2008 concerning the  internet and  terrorism. 
In our investiga tion of the Fort Hood attack, we have been cogn izant of the record of 
success by 000 and  the Federal Bureau of Investigation  (FBI) in  the  ten years since 9/ 11.  We recognize that detection and  interdiction  of lone wol f terrori sts  is one of the most difficult 
challenges  facing our law enforcement and  intelligence agencies.  Every day, these agencies are presented wi th myriad  leads that require the exercise of sound j udgment to determine which to pursue  and which to close out.  Leaders must allocate their time, attention, and  inherently limited resources on the highest priori ty cases.  In  addit ion,  the  individua l accused of the Fort Hood attack, Army Major Nidal Ma lik Hasan,  is  a U.S. citizen.  Even where there  is  evidence that a U.S.  cit izen may be radicalizing,  the Constitution appropriately limits the act ions that government can  take. 
In present ing our findings and recommendations below, we are gratefu l for  the service 
given by our nation 's mili tary,  law enforcement,  and  intelligence personnel.  Our aim  in this 
investigati on was not to single out  individua l negli gent judgment;  such instances are  for the 
agenc ies to deal with, as appropriate. Nor do we seek  to second-guess reasonable judgments. 
Instead, we act under our Const itutional duty  to oversee the Executive Branch's pcrfonnance and thus to detennine - independently from  the Executive Branch's own assessment - what, ifany, systemic  issues are exposed by  the Hasan case.  The specific  facts uncovered by the Committee's investigation necessarily  led  us to  focus our key findings and  recommendations on 000 and  the FBI.  But  the Hasan case also evidences the need  for a more comprehensive and coordinated approach to counterradicalization and homegrown terrorism across a ll  agencies,  including federal,  state, and  local  entities, wh ich are critical to keeping our country safe. 
Our basic  conclusion  is  as  follows:  Although neither 000 nor the FBI had  specific 
informat ion  concerning the  time, place, or nature of the attack, they collecti vely had suffic ient 
information  to  have detected Hasan's radica lization  to  violent  Islamist extremism but  failed both to understand and  to act on  it.  Our investigat ion  found  specific and systemic  fai lures  in  the government's handling of the Hasan case and raises additional concerns about what may be 
broader systemic  issues. 
Both the  FBI and 000 possessed  information  indicating Hasan's radicalization to violent 
Islamist extremism.  And, to  the  FBI's credit,  it fl agged Hasan  from among the chaff of 

intell igence coll ection  for  additional  scrutiny.  However,  the FBI  and DoD  together  fai led  to 
recogni ze and  to  link  the information  that they  possessed about Hasan: ( I ) Hasan was a military officer who li ved under a regimented system with strict officership and security standards, standards which his behavior during his military medical  training violated; and (2) the 
government  had  [REDACTED] communicat ions from Hasan to a suspected  terrorist, 
[REDACTED], who was  in volved  in  ant iwAmerican acti vities and  the subject of an  unrel ated FBI terrorism in vestigation.  Thi s  individual will  be  referred to as the "Suspected Terrori st"  in  this report. I  Although both  the public and  the private signs of Hasan's radicalizat ion to  violent Islami st extremi sm while on acti ve duty were known  to government official s, a string of failures 
prevented these officials from intervening against him  pri or to  the attack. 
•  Evidence of Hasan's radicali zati on to violent  Islamist extremism was on  full  display  to 
hi s superiors and coll eagues during his military medical  training.  An  instructor and a 
coll eague  each referred to Hasan as a "ticking time bomb."  Not only was no action  taken 
to di scipline or di scharge him, but  al so his Officer Evaluation Report s sanitized hi s 
obsession wi th  violent  Islamist extremism into praiseworthy research on 
counterterrorism. 
•  FBI Joint Terrorism Task Forces (JTfFs) are units in FBI  field offices that conduct 
counterterrori sm investigations and are  staffed  by  FBI  agents and employees from  other 
federa l, state, and  local agencies.  A JTTF learned  that Hasan was  communicating with 
the Suspected Terrori st,  flagged Hasan's initial  [REDACTED] communicat ions  for 
further review, and  passed them  to a second JTTF  for an  inquiry.  However, the ensuing 
inquiry  fai led  to identi fy  the  totality of Hasan's communications and  to  inform Hasan's 
mi li tary chain of command and Army  security officials of the fact that he was 
communicating with a suspected violent  Islamist extremi st - a shocking course of 
conduct for a U.S. mi li tary officer.  Instead, the JTTF  inquiry relied on Hasan's erroneous 
Officer Evaluation Reports and  ult imately dismissed his communi cat ions as legitimate 
research. 
•  The JTTF  that had reviewed the  initial  [REDACTED] communications di smi ssed the 
second  JTTF's work as "slim" but eventually dropped  the matter rather than cause a 
bureaucratic confrontation.  The JTTFs now even dispute  the extent to which they were 
in  contact with  each other in  this case.  Nonetheless,  the JTTFs never raised the dispute to 
FBI  headquarters  for  resolution, and entit ies  in FBI headquarters responsibl e for 
coordination among  fi eld offices never acted.  As a result, the FBI's inquiry  into Hasan 
ended premature!y. 
As noted, DoD possessed compelling evidence that Hasan embraced views so extreme 
that  it  should have discipl ined him or discharged him from the military,  but DoD failed to  take 
action against him.  Indeed, a number of poli cies on commanders' authori ty, extremism, and 
1 The redact ions in  this  report were  requi red by  the  Intelligence Community pursuant to Executive Branch classifical ion policies and are  the  result of intensive negotiations spanning three months.  We  take issue with  the extent of these redact ions, some of wh ich we believe are unjustified, but we have consented to  them  in order to produce  this  report in a timely manner. 

personnel gave supervisors  in  his chain of command the authority to  take such actions.  It is clear from  this failure that 000 lacks the  institutional culture, through updated policies and  training, sufficient to  inform commanders and all  levels of service members how to  identify radicalization to  violent Islamist extremism and to dist inguish th is ideology from  the peaceful practice of Islam. 
To address this  failure,  the Department  of Defense shou ld confront  the threat of 
radicali zati on to  violent  Islami st extremism among servicemembers explicitly and direct ly and strengthen associated  policies and  training.  000 launched  an  extensive  internal  review after the Fort Hood attack by commissioning a review  led by  two  former senior DOD officials (former Army Secretary Togo West and ret ired Chief of Naval Operations Admiral Vern Clark) and requiring multiple reviews across the Military Services of force protection and  related issues. 
DOD has also  inst ituted a regimented process  for  instituting and monitoring  implementation of recommendat ions  from  these reviews, which  included two memoranda  from Secretary of 
Defense Robert Gates assessing and adopting particular recommendations  from  the West/Clark review.  However, 0 00  - including Secretary Gates's memoranda - still  has not speci fically named  the  threat  represented by the  Fort Hood attack as what it is:  violent  Islami st extremism. 
Instead, DoD's approach subsumes  thi s threat within workplace violence or undefined "violent 
extremism" more generall y.  DoD's  failure  to  identify  the threat of violent  Islamist extremism 
expl ici tl y and directly confli cts with DoD's hi story of directl y confronting white supremacism 
and other threatening activity among servicemembers.  DoD should revise its poli cies and 
training  in  order to confront the  threat of violent  Islamist extremism directly. 
More specifically, DoD should update  its policies on extremism  and religious 
accommodat ion  to ensure tha t violent Islamist extremism  is not  tolerated. DOD should also train servicemembers on violent  Islami st extremi sm and how  it  differs from  Islamic religious belief and practices.  Without this improved guidance and  training, the behavioral  tendency among superiors could be  to avoid proper appli cat ion of the current general policies to situat ions involving violent  Islami st extremism. 
The 9/11 attacks  led  the FBI  Director, Robert Mueller, to act to  trans rorm  the FBI's 11
institut ional and operational  architecture.  He declared that  the FBI's top priority would 
henceforth be preventing domestic terrorist attacks and  that  the FBI needed  to become an 
in elligcnce~ce tric rather  than purely law~enforcement~ cen tr ic organizati on.  The FBI has made substantial progress in  transforming itself in these ways.  The FBI is more  focused on producing counterterrorism  intell igence and more integrated than  it had been.  Its  init iat ives are  headed  in the  right direction.  To its credit,  the FBI moved swiftly after the Fort Hood attack to conduct an internal  review,  identify  gaps, and  implement changes  in  response; the FBI  also commissioned an outside review by former FBI Director and  Director of Central  Intelligence Judge William Webster.  Nonetheless, our in vestigation finds  that the Fort Hood attack  is an indicator that the current  status of the FBI's  transformation  to become intelligence-driven is incomplete and that the  FBI faces  internal challenges - which may  include cultural barriers - that can frustrate the on-going  institutional rerorms.  The FBI  needs  to acce lerate  its  transformation. 

•  In the Hasan case, two JTTFs (each  located  in  a different fi eld office) disputed the 
significance of Hasan' s communications wi th the Suspected Terrori st and how vigorously 
he should be  in vesti gated.  The JTTF that was  less concerned about Hasan controlled  the 
inq ui ry and ended it prematurely after an  insufficient examinat ion.  Two key 
headquarters units - the Counterterrori sm Division, the "National JTTF" (which was 
created specificall y to be the hub among JTTFs), and  the Directorate of Intelligence -
were not made aware of the dispute.  This unresolved conflict ra ises concerns that, 
despi te the more assertive role that FBI headquarters now plays, especially since 9/ 11 in 
what historically has been a decentralized organization, field offi ces still  prize and protect 
their autonomy  from headquarters.  FBl headquarters also does not have a written plan 
that articulates  the divis ion of labor and hierarchy of command-and-control authoriti es 
among its  headquarters units,  fi eld offices, and  the JTTFs.  This  issue must be addressed 
to ensure that headquarters establishes more effective strategic control of its  fi eld  offi ce 
operations. 
•  In the Hasan case, the FBI  did not effectively ut ilize  intelligence analysts who could have 
provided a different perspective given the evidence that  it had.  The FBI 's inquiry 
focused narrowly on whether Hasan was engaged in terrorist activity - as opposed to 
whether he was  radicalizing  to violent Islarn ist extremism and whether this  radicalization 
might pose counterintelligence or other threats (e.g., Hasan might spy  for the Taliban if 
he was de ployed  to Afghanistan).  This  cri tica l mistake may have been avoided  if 
intell igence analysts were appropriately engaged  in  the inqui ry.  Since 9/1 1, the FBI has 
increased  its  inte lligence  focus by creat ing a Di rectorate of Intelligence and  Field 
Intell igence Groups  in the  field offices and hi ring thousands of new and better qualified 
analysts.  However, the FBI must ensure that  these ana lysts are effecti vely uti lized, 
including  that  they ach ieve significant stature in  the FBI.  The FBI must also ensure  that 
all of its agents and ana lysts are trained  to understand violent Islamist extremism. 
•  In  the Hasan case, the FBI did not ident ify  the need to update its tradecraft  (i.e., the 
methods and processes  for conducting  investigative or  intell igence acti vities) regarding 
the process ing and analys is of communi cations (REDACTED] unti l aft er the Fort Hood 
attack.  This de lay  led to a failure to  identify all  of Hasan 's communicati ons with the 
Suspected Terrorist and  the extent of the threat contained wi thin them.  The FBI  has had 
numerous successes aga inst homegrown terrorist cells and  individuals since 911 1 that 
have saved count less American  lives.  However, the FBI should  still ensure that all  of its 
tradecraft  is systemicall y examined so  that  flaws  can be corrected prior to failures.  The 
FBI  leadership should continue  to oversee this  element of its  transformat ion to a  fi rst· 
class,  intell igence.driven counterterrorism organi zation. 
•  In the Hasan case,  the JTfF model  did  not live up to the FBI' s strong vision of JTTFs as 
an effective  interagenc),  information-shari ng and operational coordination mechanism. 
JTTFs have been expanded signi ficant ly since 9111  and are now the principal domestic 
federal opera tional arm  for counterterrorism  investigat ions and  intelligence coll ect ion. 
They perfonn criticall y important homeland  securi ty funct ions and have produced 
numerous successes  in  disrupting and apprehending potenti al  lerrorists.  However, the

specific handli ng of the Hasan case, and systemic disputes between DoD and  the FBI 
concerning JITFs which  remain unreso lved,  rai se concerns that  the JITF model  requires 
additional  revi ew and  improvement in order for JTTFs to  function as effectively as our 
nation  requires. 
We  ask  that DoD and the FBI  review and  respond  to  the concerns  identified  in this report 
on  an  urgent  basis. 
Finall y,  we request thaL the National Security Council and Homeland Security Council 
lead  in  the development of an integrated approach  to  law enforcement and  intell igence 
domestica ll y and a comprehensive  national approach  to countering homegrown radicalization  to violent  Islamist extremism.  The threat of homegrown  radicalization goes beyond  the 
capabilities of the  law enforcement, intelligence, and homeland  security agencies and requires a response from  a broad range of our government which will  produce plans to  translate and  implement this comprehensive national approach  into specific, coordinated, and measurable act ions across the government and  in cooperati on with the Muslim-American community.