The rise and fall of the 9/11 conspiracy theory
Wednesday, January 9, 2013
Piers Morgan: Alex Jones 'Terrifying,' A Perfect 'Advertisement For Gun Control'
Posted: 01/09/2013 8:45 am EST | Updated: 01/09/2013 10:15 am EST
Piers Morgan said on Tuesday that his infamous encounter with radio host Alex Jones would only help his gun control crusade.
The radio host more than lost his temper with Morgan on Monday, going on a monumental rant about guns. He then speculated that he might be murdered by undercover police officers.
"I can't think of a better advertisement for gun control than Alex Jones' interview last night," Morgan told CNN on Tuesday. "It was startling, it was terrifying in parts, it was completely deluded. It was based on a premise of making Americans so fearful that they all rush out to buy even more guns ... the kind of twisted way that he turned everything into this assault on the Second Amendment is exactly what the gun rights lobby people do."
At least one person agreed that Jones was a terrible spokesman for gun rights: Glenn Beck. Speaking on his radio show Tuesday, he said that Morgan had chosen well if his intention was to discredit the pro-gun movement.
"Piers Morgan is trying to have gun control," Beck said. "He is trying to make everybody who has guns and who believes the Second Amendment to be a deterrent to an out of control government look like a madman. So now he immediately books the madman and makes him look like a conservative."
Radio host Alex Jones delivered an intense pro-gun rant on CNN's "Piers Morgan Tonight" on Monday.
Morgan invited Jones onto his show to discuss the conservative pundit's campaign to "Deport Piers Morgan" in the wake of the CNN host's advocacy of gun control following the Sandy Hook massacre.
Jones first came to prominence as a ferociously libertarian radio host who argued, among other things, that the U.S. government was involved in the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.
Jones began the segment by arguing that world governments and "the megabanks that control the planet" are conspiring to take guns away from regular citizens. "They've taken everybody's guns, but the Swiss and the American people," he said. The 2nd Amendment, he then went on to argue, was created to "protect us from tyrannical government and street thugs."
Over the course of the tirade -- during which he referenced the recent high-profile gang rape in India and Chinese revolutionary Mao Zedong -- Jones' demeanor grew noticeably more irate before finally boiling over with the following declaration:
The radio host more than lost his temper with Morgan on Monday, going on a monumental rant about guns. He then speculated that he might be murdered by undercover police officers.
"I can't think of a better advertisement for gun control than Alex Jones' interview last night," Morgan told CNN on Tuesday. "It was startling, it was terrifying in parts, it was completely deluded. It was based on a premise of making Americans so fearful that they all rush out to buy even more guns ... the kind of twisted way that he turned everything into this assault on the Second Amendment is exactly what the gun rights lobby people do."
At least one person agreed that Jones was a terrible spokesman for gun rights: Glenn Beck. Speaking on his radio show Tuesday, he said that Morgan had chosen well if his intention was to discredit the pro-gun movement.
"Piers Morgan is trying to have gun control," Beck said. "He is trying to make everybody who has guns and who believes the Second Amendment to be a deterrent to an out of control government look like a madman. So now he immediately books the madman and makes him look like a conservative."
Alex Jones' Piers Morgan Rant: Radio Host Unleashes Explosive Pro-Gun Tirade (VIDEO)
The Huffington Post
|
By Peter Finocchiaro
Posted: 01/08/2013 1:15 am EST | Updated: 01/08/2013 1:03 pm EST
Radio host Alex Jones delivered an intense pro-gun rant on CNN's "Piers Morgan Tonight" on Monday.
Morgan invited Jones onto his show to discuss the conservative pundit's campaign to "Deport Piers Morgan" in the wake of the CNN host's advocacy of gun control following the Sandy Hook massacre.
Jones first came to prominence as a ferociously libertarian radio host who argued, among other things, that the U.S. government was involved in the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.
Jones began the segment by arguing that world governments and "the megabanks that control the planet" are conspiring to take guns away from regular citizens. "They've taken everybody's guns, but the Swiss and the American people," he said. The 2nd Amendment, he then went on to argue, was created to "protect us from tyrannical government and street thugs."
Over the course of the tirade -- during which he referenced the recent high-profile gang rape in India and Chinese revolutionary Mao Zedong -- Jones' demeanor grew noticeably more irate before finally boiling over with the following declaration:
"I'm here to tell you, 1776 will commence again if you try to take our firearms! Doesn't matter how many lemmings you get out there on the street, begging for 'em to have their guns taken. We will not relinquish them. Do you understand?! That's why you're going to fail, and the establishment knows, no matter how much propaganda, the republic will rise again!"Watch the full segment below:
Jack Lew To Be Nominated For Treasury Secretary By Obama: Report
Posted: 01/09/2013 9:56 am EST | Updated: 01/09/2013 3:16 pm EST
President Barack Obama will nominate White House Chief of Staff Jack Lew to be Treasury Secretary, Bloomberg reports.
Outgoing Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner is expected to leave his post at the end of the month.
Some Republicans have scoffed at the idea that Lew should be Treasury Secretary. The decision to replace Geithner with Lew could also disappoint critics hoping for dramatic changes in Obama's second term, as HuffPost's Mark Gongloff and Christina Wilkie reported earlier:
Outgoing Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner is expected to leave his post at the end of the month.
Some Republicans have scoffed at the idea that Lew should be Treasury Secretary. The decision to replace Geithner with Lew could also disappoint critics hoping for dramatic changes in Obama's second term, as HuffPost's Mark Gongloff and Christina Wilkie reported earlier:
Throughout Obama's first term, Geithner has been constantly criticized as looking out for the interests of Wall Street over Main Street, particularly for what some critics say was his opposition to mortgage relief for underwater homeowners out of concern for bank profits. Lew seems likely to be less of a lightning rod than Geithner, who is the protege of bank-deregulator Robert Rubin. Lew is widely seen as a smart, tough negotiator and an able public servant. But his professed lack of expertise in financial regulation, along with his own tenure at Rubin's old firm, the original too-big-to-fail bank, Citigroup, has raised warning flags among critics. They fear a Lew Treasury might not aggressively push back financial industry efforts to water down the Dodd-Frank financial-reform law or keep an eye out for the next financial crisis.
Despite doubts, Lew has played a vital role in key past Obama negotiations. HuffPost's Sam Stein reported earlier:
White House Chief of Staff Jack Lew has been an unassuming figure during the Obama years. His media appearances are dull; his presentation is a bit bookworm-ish -- as if Harry Potter grew up and replaced his magic wand with Excel spreadsheets. When he speaks, the tone is usually measured and unemotional. Behind the scenes, however, Lew has proven to be Obama's most skillful consigliere in matters of political trench warfare. Time and again during the debt ceiling debate, as Republicans attempted to get the administration to bend on top domestic priorities, it was Lew who proved to be a stick in the mud. Then serving as Office of Management and Budget Director, his insistence on playing out the practical impact of those cuts irritated Republicans to no end
White House Chief of Staff Jack Lew has been an unassuming figure during the Obama years. His media appearances are dull; his presentation is a bit bookworm-ish -- as if Harry Potter grew up and replaced his magic wand with Excel spreadsheets. When he speaks, the tone is usually measured and unemotional. Behind the scenes, however, Lew has proven to be Obama's most skillful consigliere in matters of political trench warfare. Time and again during the debt ceiling debate, as Republicans attempted to get the administration to bend on top domestic priorities, it was Lew who proved to be a stick in the mud. Then serving as Office of Management and Budget Director, his insistence on playing out the practical impact of those cuts irritated Republicans to no end
Jacob Lew, Obama Nominee And Former Citigroup Executive, Doesn't Believe Deregulation Led To Financial Crisis
First Posted: 09/21/10 09:27 AM ET Updated: 05/25/11 06:45 PM ET
Understanding the Second Amendment
Posted: 01/09/2013 8:05 am
Opponents of laws regulating the sale, manufacture and use of guns fervently invoke the Second Amendment. In their view, the Second Amendment ("a well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed") forbids the government to regulate guns. Period. End of discussion.
But it is more complicated than that. At the outset, let's put aside the argument that the "well-regulated militia" clause signficantly narrows the scope of the Second Amendment. Although most judges and lawyers endorse that interpretation, the Supreme Court, in its controversial five-to-four decision in District of Columbia v. Heller, rejected that understanding of the text.
So, let's consider that matter "settled." Let's assume, then, that the Second Amendment reads: "The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed." Now, that sure sounds absolute. But it's not that simple.
Consider, for example, the First Amendment, which provides: "Congress shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech." This also sounds absolute. But does the First Amendment mean that the government cannot constitutionally regulate speech?
But how can this be so? Doesn't the text mean what it says? Here's the catch: Even though it is true that "Congress shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech," we still have to define what we mean by "the freedom of speech" that Congress may not abridge. The phrase "the freedom of speech," in other words, is not self-defining. And as Justice Holmes demonstrated with his hypothetical, it does not cover an individual who falsely shouts "fire!"in a crowded theater.
But that is only the beginning, for despite the seemingly absolute language of the First Amendment, the Supreme Court has long-held that the government may regulate speech in a great many situations. In appropriate circumstances, for example, a speaker can be punished for defaming another individual, for making threats, for selling obscenity, for distributing child pornography, for inciting a murder, for "leaking" confidential information, for using a loudspeaker at night in a residential neighborhood, for handing out leaflets on a public bus, for erecting a too-large billboard, and for using naughty words on television, to cite just a few of many possible examples.
Thus, although the First Amendment seems absolute in its protection of "the freedom of speech," the Supreme Court has reasonably recognized that it does not guarantee us the right to say whatever we please, whenever we please, wherever we please, in whatever manner we please. The "freedom of speech" is subject to regulation.
The same is of course true of the Second Amendment. Even if we agree that the Second Amendment forbids the government to "infringe" the right to "keep and bear arms," that does not mean that the government cannot reasonably regulate the manufacture, sale, ownership and possession of firearms. Indeed, this is precisely what Justice Scalia said in his opinion for the Court in Heller.
It is time for opponents of gun control to stop mindlessly shouting "The Second Amendment!!" as if that ends the discussion. It does not. Just as there is no First Amendment right to falsely yell fire in a crowded theatre, there is no Second Amendment right to carry an AK-47 there.
And that is only the beginning of what the Second Amendment does not guarantee.
- Comments 1,821
Walmart Will Send Representatives To White House To Talk Gun Control
First Thoughts: Biden's gun violence listening sessions begin
Low expectations for NRA meeting with White House on guns … Obama’s two options on guns – incremental or bold, either one puts him in a box. … The U.S. is signaling it wants out of Afghanistan and using “zero option” as negotiating tactic with Karzai … With Afghanistan policy, cabinet picks, a confident Obama’s fully implement the “Obama Doctrine.” … 2016 watch: There are several governors/potential 2016 hopefuls giving State of the State addresses. What they say could lay the groundwork for 2016 bids … 2014 watch: A conservative group goes after McConnell, Strickland won’t run again for governor in Ohio.
By Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, Domenico Montanaro, and Brooke Brower
*** Joe Biden’s gun violence listening sessions begin:
Beginning today, Joe Biden begins the series of gatherings at the White House, aimed at trying to create some consensus on what to do about gun violence. These are the meetings President Obama promised would take place in the wake of Newtown, and these are the meetings that are designed to come up with recommendations in time for the president to push in his State of the Union. The most intriguing session could be tomorrow when gun groups, including the NRA, are represented at the White House. But let’s not get too optimistic about the NRA’s participation. This meeting may be for show, pure and simple. Both sides had to do it. The White House had to issue an invite to the NRA, and the NRA had to say yes, which the NRA says will indicate the seriousness with which they take this offer. The NRA is sending a representative (not LaPierre) to hear what the White House has to say, but it is just one of several gun-advocacy groups that will participate in this Biden guns summit.
The
vice president returned to Washington Thursday and is scheduled to meet
with victim groups and gun-safety organizations. The Daily Rundown's
Chuck Todd reports.
*** Not much common ground with the NRA:
If there is any common ground between the NRA and the White House, it could be on the idea of mandating state participation in the mental-health database and stronger mental-health screenings. But nothing on gun restrictions themselves, not on clips either. As for today’s meeting, Biden meets with victims’ groups and gun-safety advocates. And he’s also expected to meet with representatives from the video game and entertainment industry, but those meetings have yet to be scheduled. New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R) on TODAY said that despite New Jersey having some of the toughest gun laws in the country, that banning guns is not enough. “I’m willing to have that conversation,” Christie said of a federal ban on powerful, high-capacity weapons, “but you’ve got to deal with these other issues.”
Chip Somodevilla / Getty Images
Vice
President Joe Biden stands on the steps of the Capitol as Sen. Mark
Kirk, R-Ill., nearly a year after suffering a major stroke, marks his
return to the Senate by walking up the steps to the Senate door.
The White House has a self-imposed deadline of the end of this month to come up with some tangible items. They can go one of two ways: (1) Incremental (magazines and mental-health screenings): This will show the White House trying to create proposals that can pass, but there will be a lot of disappointed people, or (2) Bolder (really pushing for reinstating the assault-weapons ban, mandatory background checks of all purchases, including private sales, a national gun ownership database): But the risk of the bold approach is that it can’t pass Congress. It’s a bit of a political box for the White House; they’d like to do something, and there is a chance to “do something,” but what is possible and what some gun-control advocates really want are not in the same ballpark.
The New Jersey governor talks with TODAY's Matt Lauer about the state of
the Republican party, gun control, and his frustrations over the
postponement of a vote on disaster aid for superstorm Sandy victims,
saying, "people are suffering."
*** U.S. wants out of Afghanistan:
Afghan President Hamid Karzai hits Washington this week. He will meet with the president at the White House Friday. Coinciding with that visit, White House national-security officials held a conference call yesterday, in which they said, per NBC’s Ali Weinberg, that leaving no troops at all in Afghanistan after the scheduled 2014 drawdown is a possibility. It’s clear President Obama wants as minimal a presence in Afghanistan post-2014 as possible (short of covert ops and special forces). The “zero option” is all about negotiating leverage with Karzai. (The range being talked about seriously is from 3,000 up to a high of 15,000, pushed by military types.) Yes, Karzai says publicly he wants the U.S. out of Afghanistan, but he really needs and wants more U.S. troops there for security. But clearly, this is not going to be a sustained nation-building effort.
*** ‘Obama Doctrine’ being fully implemented:
The mercurial Obama Doctrine is now clear and being fully implemented with the president free of politics. In his first term, Obama was boxed in politically by the Pentagon and had a cabinet full of politically palatable holdovers (Gates, Petraeus) and a rival (Clinton). He probably regrets the Afghan surge but he can never say it, because soldiers died. Compare that to now – the U.S. on the verge of complete withdrawal from Afghanistan (minus covert/special ops) and a national-security team of Hagel, Brennan, and Kerry. The U.S. needs some presence in Afghanistan to launch attacks on al Qaeda, et al, but Obama policy will likely make it look more like how the U.S. operates in Pakistan and Yemen than George W. Bush’s Iraq and Afghanistan.
Rep. Tom Cotton, R-Ark. Joins The Daily Rundown's Chuck Todd to talk
about why he wanted to join Congress, and his colleagues should say "no"
to Obama more often.
While we still don’t know when the president is delivering his State of the Union, there are 50 “State of States” coming up. And there are a bunch we’ll be looking at delivered by potential 2016 hopefuls -- from Chris Christie in New Jersey (on the cover of Time, by the way, as “The Boss”) to New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, Bob McDonnell (R) in Virginia, Bobby Jindal (R) in Louisiana, and Martin O’Malley in Maryland. Christie, who delivered his yesterday, focused on Sandy and pragmatism (mildly rebuking his party on TODAY: “We’ve lost two elections in a row. The answer is no… we have to be thinking about doing something different.”) Cuomo, who delivers his today, will focus on guns and pushing for stricter limits on them. McDonnell, who also makes his “State of the Commonwealth” address tonight, unveiled his transportation funding plan, which remarkably called for the elimination of the gas tax. That’s traditionally been what’s funded transportation projects both statewide and at the federal level. But McDonnell also proposed making the source of transportation funding with higher sales taxes and other fees, including even a $100 annual fee on hybrid cars and alternative-fuel vehicles. For those governors thinking about running for president, these speeches could provide a baseline for what they’re platform might be.
*** Three-way race in Virginia?
Speaking of Virginia, the governor’s race to replace McDonnell could get a little more interesting. Lt. Gov. Bill Bolling, who’d have a hard time winning a GOP primary against Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli, is leaving the door wide open to an independent bid. “I have been tremendously encouraged,” Bolling told a local TV station, adding, “Unfortunately when the Republican Party needs to be a big tent party it seems to me we are doing everything we can to become a pup tent party. That is not the right direction for the Republican Party.” He says he’ll make his decision on whether to enter this year’s race by mid-March. By the way, a Quinnipiac poll shows a statistically tied race between Cucinelli and Democrat Terry McAuliffe, with lots of undecideds. McAuliffe has the narrow 40%-39% edge. Bolling only gets 13% in a potential three-way with McAuliffe and Cucinelli both at 34%.
*** 2014 watch:
Conservative group launches Internet ad against Mitch McConnell: “Whose side are you on? … Former Democratic Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland said yesterday he won’t run in a rematch against incumbent Republican John Kasich. … The Boston Globe digs into where Ed Markey, thinking about a run for the Senate, has gotten his money over the years. He was chairman of the House Subcommittee on Telecommunications, and “the communications and electronics industries have been Markey’s largest sources of campaign cash….”
Tuesday, January 8, 2013
World News 1/8: Rep. Gabby Giffords' Exclusive Interview with Diane Sawyer
Giffords and Kelly: Fighting gun violence
Gabrielle Giffords and Mark Kelly
9:45a.m. EST January 8, 2013
Our new campaign will launch a national dialogue and raise funds to counter influence of the gun lobby.
In response to a horrific series of shootings that has sown terror in our communities, victimized tens of thousands of Americans, and left one of its own bleeding and near death in a Tucson parking lot, Congress has done something quite extraordinary — nothing at all.
I was shot in the head while meeting with constituents two years ago today. Since then, my extensive rehabilitation has brought excitement and gratitude to our family. But time and time again, our joy has been diminished by new, all too familiar images of death on television: the breaking news alert, stunned witnesses blinking away tears over unspeakable carnage, another community in mourning. America has seen an astounding 11 mass shootings since a madman used a semiautomatic pistol with an extended ammunition clip to shoot me and kill six others. Gun violence kills more than 30,000 Americans annually.
This country is known for using its determination and ingenuity to solve problems, big and small. Wise policy has conquered disease, protected us from dangerous products and substances, and made transportation safer. But when it comes to protecting our communities from gun violence, we're not even trying — and for the worst of reasons.
An ideological fringe
Special interests purporting to represent gun owners but really advancing the interests of an ideological fringe have used big money and influence to cow Congress into submission. Rather than working to find the balance between our rights and the regulation of a dangerous product, these groups have cast simple protections for our communities as existential threats to individual liberties. Rather than conducting a dialogue, they threaten those who divert from their orthodoxy with political extinction.
As a result, we are more vulnerable to gun violence. Weapons designed for the battlefield have a home in our streets. Criminals and the mentally ill can easily purchase guns by avoiding background checks. Firearm accessories designed for killing at a high rate are legal and widely available. And gun owners are less responsible for the misuse of their weapons than they are for their automobiles.
Forget the boogeyman of big, bad government coming to dispossess you of your firearms. As a Western woman and a Persian Gulf War combat veteran who have exercised our Second Amendment rights, we don't want to take away your guns any more than we want to give up the two guns we have locked in a safe at home. What we do want is what the majority of NRA members and other Americans want: responsible changes in our laws to require responsible gun ownership and reduce gun violence.
We saw from the NRA leadership's defiant and unsympathetic response to the Newtown, Conn., massacre that winning even the most common-sense reforms will require a fight. But whether it has been in campaigns or in Congress, in combat or in space, fighting for what we believe in has always been what we do.
Let's not be naive
We can't be naive about what it will take to achieve the most common-sense solutions. We can't just hope that the last shooting tragedy will prevent the next. Achieving reforms to reduce gun violence and prevent mass shootings will mean matching gun lobbyists in their reach and resources.
Americans for Responsible Solutions, which we are launching today, will invite people from around the country to join a national conversation about gun violence prevention, will raise the funds necessary to balance the influence of the gun lobby, and will line up squarely behind leaders who will stand up for what's right.
Until now, the gun lobby's political contributions, advertising and lobbying have dwarfed spending from anti-gun violence groups. No longer. With Americans for Responsible Solutions engaging millions of people about ways to reduce gun violence and funding political activity nationwide, legislators will no longer have reason to fear the gun lobby. Other efforts such as improving mental health care and opposing illegal guns are essential, but as gun owners and survivors of gun violence, we have a unique message for Americans.
We have experienced too much death and hurt to remain idle. Our response to the Newtown massacre must consist of more than regret, sorrow and condolence. The children of Sandy Hook Elementary School and all victims of gun violence deserve fellow citizens and leaders who have the will to prevent gun violence in the future.
Gabrielle Giffords is the former Democratic U.S. representative from Arizona. Mark Kelly is a former astronaut.
More: Arizona marks two years since Giffords shooting
Florida Governor Inflates Cost Of Medicaid Expansion By 2,500% To Avoid Implementing Obamacare
By Tara Culp-Ressler posted from ThinkProgress Health on Jan 8, 2013 at 6:55 pm
Internal email messages uncovered by Health News Florida reveal that Gov. Rick Scott (R-FL) is knowingly citing inaccurate cost estimates to justify his refusal to expand Florida’s Medicaid program. Though the governor’s office is fully aware that the numbers are wrong, Scott continues to use them anyway, the documents show.
Florida, which has one of the highest rates of uninsurance in the nation, could extend health coverage to about one million low-income residents by accepting Obamacare’s optional Medicaid expansion. But the governor — an ardent Obamacare opponent — has repeatedly said that expanding Medicaid would just be too expensive, claiming it would cost the state $26 billion over the next 10 years.
As Health News Florida reports, however, that figure from Florida’s Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA) is inflated because it doesn’t take into account the full amount that the federal government will reimburse states for choosing to expand Medicaid. A more accurate analysis found that expansion would cost the state around $1 billion:
But those numbers are based on a flawed report, state budget analysts say. A series of e-mails obtained by Health News Florida shows the analysts warned Scott’s office the numbers were wrong weeks ago, but he is still using them. [...]According to the email chain that Health News Florida obtained, state officials began calling the AHCA’s $26 billion cost estimate into question as early as December 20. One member of the House Health Care Appropriations Subcommittee even pointed out that, since the health reform law specifies that the federal government will help fund Obamacare’s Medicaid expansion, it would actually break Florida state law to expand Medicaid without using the federal dollars mandated for that purpose.
The Act says the federal government will pay the lion’s share of the cost for new Medicaid eligibles if a state agrees to expand its program — a decision the Supreme Court left up to the states. The federal contribution for the new eligibles would be 100 percent between 2014 and 2016, then would taper after that to 90 percent by 2020 and stay there.
But the AHCA report assumes the federal match for the new patients would be much lower, about 58 percent. It came up with that by averaging the match amount over the past 20 years. The report doesn’t say why the authors made that assumption. [...]
As Health News Florida reported on Dec. 21, the AHCA estimates were huge in comparison to a study released by the Urban Institute and Kaiser Family Foundation, two neutral research groups that specialize in Medicaid studies. Their study estimated that if Florida agreed to expand Medicaid, about 1 million uninsured people would gain coverage at a 10-year cost to the state of around $1 billion.
Nevertheless, Scott has continued to repeat his false claim that Florida can’t afford to provide its low-income residents with the health coverage they need. Scott met with U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius on Monday to express his concerns about what expanding Medicaid would mean for his state’s bottom line. “Growing government, it’s never free,” Scott explained to reporters. “It always costs money.” Just not as much money as Scott says it does.
VIDEO: Interview with Jim DeMint on the Future of Conservatism (Part 1)
VIDEO: Interview with Jim DeMint on Success and Failure (Part 2)
Senator Jim DeMint joined The Heritage Foundation this week, leaving
his job in Congress to prepare to become the think tank’s next president
in April. This is the second part of our interview with DeMint, which
covers his greatest accomplishment in Congress and biggest failure.
VIDEO: Interview with Jim DeMint on Family and Work (Part 3)
Let Barney Frank Take Over for Kerry
By Wendy Kaminer
Jason Reed/Reuters
"All politics is local," the late Democratic House speaker Tip
O'Neill famously observed, and Republican members of Congress who vote
in fear of primary challenges from right-wing activists would probably
agree. But sometimes, all politics is personal.Consider the apparent role of personal animus, or mistrust, in machinations over the crucial, interim appointment to the U.S. Senate seat expected to be vacated by Secretary of State nominee John Kerry. A special election to fill Kerry's unfinished term will likely be held by the end of June, 2013, as Massachusetts law requires an election within 145 to 160 days of a seat being vacated. The governor will appoint someone to serve in the interim, and Governor Deval Patrick has pledged to appoint a caretaker who will not run in the special election.
Democratic leaders, justifiably worried about a likely comeback campaign by Scott Brown, are trying to avoid a battle in advance of the special election. So when Congressman Ed Markey, buoyed by $3 million in the bank, announced his candidacy in the special election, he was quickly anointed by the national and state Democratic establishment, to the chagrin of Congressman Mike Capuano, who is also considering running for Kerry's seat, along with Congressman Steve Lynch.
Enter former congressman Barney Frank, who announced last week he is seeking the interim appointment. Frank has a friendly relationship with Capuano and, since redistricting, has had a rather unfriendly one with Markey. Announcing his retirement last year, Frank accused Markey of using his influence in the state legislature to protect himself during redistricting to the detriment of others in the Massachusetts delegation, Frank in particular.
Declaring his interest in the seat, Frank reiterated his firm commitment not to run in the special election and noted persuasively that, in the interim, he is especially well-qualified to help resolve historic, pending fiscal debates. Markey apparently disagrees. He was "rankled" by the possibility of Frank's appointment, the Boston Globe reports, because he fears being "overshadowed" by him.
Enter political consultant Doug Rubin, advisor to Patrick, new Senator Elizabeth Warren, and many members of the state Democratic establishment that's supporting Markey. Not surprisingly, Rubin has announced his opposition to Frank's appointment: "[T]here are better options for MA Senate interim appointment," he tweeted.
Who might be more qualified than Barney Frank? Someone less qualified, according to Rubin. "(E)xperienced people are the ones creating the gridlock" in Washington," he told the Globe. We need to "get beyond the traditional names" to people who will bring "fresh ideas and energy to Washington."
I'll give Rubin the benefit of the doubt and assume he doesn't actually believe that inexperience is a virtue. I bet he doesn't consider his own experience as a political consultant a disadvantage that deprives him of "fresh ideas and energy." I bet he doesn't advise prospective clients not to hire him because he knows what he's doing. And I suspect he knows that it's inexperienced people -- mainly freshman Tea Party members of Congress -- not experienced people (like John Boehner), who have "created the gridlock in Washington."
But I do question Rubin's political acumen if he thinks rejecting Frank's bid for an interim appointment will help Markey win the special election for the seat. Frank can be trusted not to run. If he wanted to run for Senate, he'd say so. (Has anyone ever accused Barney Frank of not saying what he thinks?) Besides, Frank is newly married, in his early seventies, and has seemed relaxed and happy contemplating retirement. He will not be Markey's opponent, and serving as an interim senator, he could be Markey's friend.
Politically, Frank's visibility and the role he could play in the fiscal debates seem likely to help Democratic efforts to fend off Scott Brown, not hamper them. And Frank might naturally be more inclined to help Markey if he doesn't oppose Frank's interim appointment.
Of course, the deal may be done. Rubin denies speaking for the governor (or Elizabeth Warren), but even if that's true, he is speaking to the governor, as well as other state Democratic leaders. Too bad for Massachusetts, and the country, if they listen.
How John Kerry Could Out-Internet Hillary Clinton as Secretary of State
By Brian FungWith rumors that John Kerry may be tapped to take Clinton's place when she departs the agency this month comes rising speculation over how the current chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee might handle State's technological mandate. But a better question isn't what would happen to "21st-century statecraft" under Kerry -- it's what it would take to convince Kerry to consider digital a priority.
Kerry is a manager, and a very capable one. But he's not an ideas man. So unless there's a compelling argument to do something differently, he'll simply leave alone many of the programs Clinton put in place. That's especially true for a project like digital diplomacy, which is valuable precisely because it distributes responsibility downward and away from top-level officials. The next stage of digital diplomacy's development will be hard not because Kerry has some devious plan to dismantle it but because he has no reason to pay attention to it.
Digital diplomats who want to get on Kerry's radar need to appeal to Obama's presumptive nominee in the context of his main responsibilities. And that means making 21st-century statecraft an instrument for big foreign-policy breakthroughs -- not just a tool for keeping up relations with foreign publics. Here's how that could -- could -- happen.
Over the next several years, there'll be a number of opportunities for digital diplomacy to become a go-to weapon in the U.S. foreign-policy arsenal. One of these opportunities has to do with the structure of the Web itself: although it may have been spared from tougher international regulations last December, countries with a strong interest in monitoring Internet activity such as Russia and China are likely to keep proposing new restrictive rules. By helping build friendly coalitions through online tools, the State Department can open another front in the battle for a free Internet and apply direct pressure on opposing negotiators for self-reinforcing political victories.
Digital diplomats can also gain leverage by using the domestic social networks of target states. Consider China, which boasts a rich indigenous Internet culture that Western tools like Twitter and Facebook don't reach. Kerry would be wise to begin investigating Sina Weibo and other Chinese-language Web services as another way to get into the country. And while in repressive countries Internet censors may block these attempts, that in itself gives Washington diplomatic ammunition.
Kerry can use 21st-century statecraft to strengthen public-private partnerships. He can make digital diplomacy more effective by learning from corporate experiments with social tools. (Watching trends in media and journalism will be especially valuable; latching onto memes or trading in bite-size pieces of Internet, as a great deal of even the non-Western Web does, could be one successful model.) He can invest in stronger sentiment analysis tools that will dramatically enhance his agency's ability to interpret open-source intelligence. And that's just a start. But digital diplomats can't assume Kerry -- or whomever is confirmed to succeed Clinton -- will act either way of his own accord. In the best tradition of the Internet, those from below need to make the case for themselves that "21st-century statecraft" can mean more than "PR."
6 Reasons Obama Is Nominating Chuck Hagel for Secretary of Defense
By Jill Lawrence
Reuters
Back at the 2004 Republican convention, when then-Senator Chuck Hagel
was weighing whether to run for president in 2008, he paid a call on
the Iowa delegation. His obligatory joke about his devotion to ethanol
went over well. But then, to the puzzlement of some in the room, he
started talking to his conservative breakfast audience about the United
Nations and the need for multilateralism in tackling world problems.- Chuck Hagel's Biggest Problem: He's Like President Obama
- Thankless Job Awaits Jack Lew If He Heads to Treasury
- Don't Bet on Barney Frank for Senate
There are well known controversies associated with Hagel's expected nomination, involving everything fromclimate change and gay rights to Israel, Iraq, and Iran. But unlike the case of U.N. ambassador Susan Rice, who withdrew as a potential secretary of state nominee amid criticism from Republicans, President Obama is pressing forward with Hagel.
Given the huge battles looming over immigration, the national debt, and other issues, I urged Obama not to pick a fight over Rice. What's different about Hagel? Here are six possibilities:
- Obama does not want to be seen as caving twice to GOP attacks, Rice followed by Hagel. More importantly, he had a solid alternative for secretary of state in Senator John Kerry. Hagel is unique in several ways, among them that he is a decorated Vietnam War veteran. The two other top candidates for defense secretary, Ashton Carter and Michele Flournoy, did not serve in the military.
- Hagel would be a solid ally at the Pentagon. Obama has had his share of tensions with the military, as many accounts have made clear, including retired General Stanley McChrystal's new memoir and the Rolling Stone article that led to his resignation. Hawks in Congress have also been highly critical of Obama. Hagel would be a counterweight to demands for more troops and more intervention around the world, particularly in Iran.
- Hagel shares Obama's caution about military intervention. Though he voted to authorize an invasion of Iraq, Hagel had reservations and later became a sharp critic of the war. All indications are he would be supportive now if Obama decides to withdraw U.S. troops from Afghanistan more quickly than currently planned. Immediately after Osama bin Laden was killed in 2011, Hagel said that Obama has "got to start heading toward the exits." The pursuit of bin Laden and al-Qaeda was "the reason we invaded Afghanistan" after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, Hagel told the Lincoln (Nebraska) Journal Star, not the pursuit of the Taliban. "We have lost our purpose, our objective. We are in a universe of unpredictables and uncontrollables," he said.
- Hagel would add a tinge of bipartisanship to Obama's cabinet. He angered many Republicans with his vociferous objections to the Iraq war, declined to back GOP nominee John McCain in 2008 and criticized last year's Republican hopefuls for being in "race to say who would bomb Iran first." Still, his overall record in Congress was conservative. In 2007, when Hagel was still weighing a presidential bid, American Conservative Union chairman David Keene told The Washington Times that Hagel is "bright, decent and conservative on almost all issues." He said Hagel's lifetime ACU rating was over 85, "and we consider anyone who scores 80 or above a fairly reliable conservative."
- Obama and Hagel like and trust one another. They traveled together to Iraq in 2008, and Hagel defended him that year against campaign-trail attacks. "Obama and I got to know each other pretty well in the Senate even though he wasn't there very long," Hagel said last year in an interview with al-Monitor, an English-language website covering the Middle East. "I have the highest regard for him in every way. I think he's one of the finest, most decent individuals I've ever known, and one of the smartest."
- Senators are sometimes inclined to give deference to their own in a confirmation process. But Hagel's blunt run in public life has provoked discomfort and dismay among Republicans and Democrats alike. The former Nebraska senator has a lot of reassuring and convincing to do before he can count on winning that deference from former colleagues and others in the chamber he left four years ago.
Meet John Brennan, Obama's Drone Czar and Nominee for CIA Director
By David A. Graham
Pete Souza/The White House
You might not know John Brennan's name yet, but that's about to change.
And even if you don't know who he is, you're almost certainly familiar
with his work: If you've heard about any drone strike over the last four
years, you've witnessed his hidden hand. Brennan, currently President
Obama's chief counterterrorism adviser, is the driving force behind
America's overseas drone program. And if the president has his way,
Brennan will soon be the director of the CIA, replacing General David Petraeus.For Petraeus, the move from commanding U.S. troops in Iraq and Afghanistan to leading the CIA provided an opportunity to continue to pursue the small-footprint, assassination-focused method of prosecuting the war on terror that he'd worked hard to implement from within the Army.
For Brennan, a move to the top of the CIA could signal the evolution of the drone program, which he has both overseen and sought to reign in.
If he's confirmed, it won't be Brennan's first tour of duty in Langley. He spent 25 years at the agency, including time as station chief in Saudi Arabia; he's also a fluent Arabic speaker. (Incredibly, he applied to work at the CIA after seeing a want ad in the New York Times.) It's also not his first bid for the director's chair: After Obama's 2008 victory, Brennan was a leading contender for the job, but he withdrew his name after pressure from liberals and civil libertarians over his role in so-called "enhanced interrogation tactics" -- read torture -- while heading the National Counterterrorism Center during the Bush Administration.
Leon Panetta became CIA director, and Brennan ended up advising Obama on counterterror, which has gotten him some high-profile assignments. He briefed the press on the Christmas 2009 Underwear Bomber and on the raid that killed Osama bin Laden. (The administration highlighted his work on the Bin Laden raid in its talking points on the nomination.) It has also earned him the trust of the White House, and Obama confidants talk about him in almost comically laudatory terms. "He is like a John Wayne character," David Axelrod told Newsweek's Dan Klaidman. "I sleep better knowing that he is not sleeping." Massimo Calabresi says Brennan is considered "the Holy Ghost" in Obama's trinity of terrorism advisers. He's also been described as a "priest-like presence" in terrorism discussions for his devotion to just war.
But Brennan's biggest impact -- and the issue sure to arouse the most controversy during the nomination hearings -- has been in the targeted killing program. Brennan is the man in charge of deciding who gets targeted and who doesn't. He has delivered the longest and most detailed defense and explanation of the program and how it works, in an April 2012 speech at the Woodrow Wilson Center. And he's also been the most prominent administration voice calling for the limiting and reining in of drone strikes. As the presidential election approached, he was part of an effort to set down legal restrictions on how the unmanned vehicles could and could not be used -- restrictions partly intended to ward off what White House insiders were worried could be abuses if Mitt Romney won the election. And according to a series of Washington Post reports from October, he was concerned even without the election looming:
Brennan is leading efforts to curtail the CIA's primary responsibility for targeted killings. Over opposition from the agency, he has argued that it should focus on intelligence activities and leave lethal action to its more traditional home in the military, where the law requires greater transparency. Still, during Brennan's tenure, the CIA has carried out hundreds of drone strikes in Pakistan and opened a new base for armed drones in the Arabian Peninsula .... There are many associates who use the words "moral compass" to describe his role in the White House. It is Brennan, they say, who questions the justification for each drone attack, who often dials back what he considers excessive zeal by the CIA and the military, and who stands up for diplomatic and economic assistance components in the overall strategy.This makes Brennan's move to the CIA even more fascinating. Will he continue to work to restrain the role of intelligence agents in killing suspected terrorists? Or, once he's ensconced at the agency, will he decide that perhaps he's still the best person to oversee the program after all -- even if that requires a de facto delegation of authority over it to the CIA? Panetta was reportedly viewed with wariness when he arrived at the CIA, but quickly won loyalty for pushing back at liberal demands for serious investigation and sanctions over the torture program. Brennan might feel compelled to defend agency turf, as well -- but he also might feel empowered to go his own way, relying on his quarter-century career to grant him legitimacy. There's been a lot of attention given to the Obama Administration's will-they-or-won't-they handling of Chuck Hagel's nomination for secretary of defense, but nominating the two men at the same time, as Obama did Monday afternoon, may actually give Brennan some cover and ease his confirmation. He's also earned some praise from conservatives, and he doesn't have partisan baggage: "I'm neither Republican nor Democrat," he noted in 2010. "I've worked for the past five administrations."
Still, don't expect the most ardent critics of either the drone program or the torture program to give Brennan anything resembling a free pass. My colleague Conor Friedersdorf has been one of the most consistent voices challenging Brennan for years, on matters ranging from how the administration speaks out of both sides of its mouth about drones, both bragging about them and insisting they are secret, to the reliance on imperfect technology, to the fact that strikes have been carried out both against U.S. citizens, forsaking constitutional due process, and also against targets the government can't even identify. In September Micah Zenko delivered a brutal indictment in Foreign Policy, noting seven claims Brennan has made that are at best overly optimistic and at worst blatantly untrue.
The torture questions will almost certainly resurface too. What did Brennan know, and when did he know it? It's still not entirely clear. On the other hand, Andrew Sullivan, who vociferously opposed a Brennan nomination four years ago, has changed his mind. But it's hard to imagine criticism of this sort derailing Brennan's nomination. Obama already deeply disappointed his civil-libertarian supporters in his first term, and Republicans (with occasional exceptions) have shown little interest in restraining the drone program. In announcing the Brennan nomination Monday, Obama praised him as "an advocate for greater transparency in our counterterrorism policy, and adherence to the rule of law." What his ultimate impact on those issues will be is perhaps too soon to tell.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
